Is it ok to use lamb stock in place of the chicken stock? I had some lamb bones and made a big batch of lamb stock.
Sure, I don’t see why not!
Oh no, I just dredged the lamb in flour out of habit–most lamb stew call for that. Any ideas on why this recipe does not call for that step?
Hi VWF, we have people in our family who are sensitive to gluten, so I often skip things like dredging in flour if I don’t think the step is necessary. You can dredge the lamb in flour in you want.
Hi. Can I use lamb necks instead? How would I best prepare them for the stew? Thanks!
Hi Ralph, although I’ve eaten stew made with lamb neck several times in restaurants (delicious!), I haven’t yet tried cooking with them myself. I would imagine that you would prepare them the same way, cut into chunks, marinated, then brown. If bones are involved, if they aren’t too small, then leave them in and pull them out before serving.
Love this recipe ! I have made it twice. Marinated it over night. Roasted 4 large home grown large red peppers and added mushrooms to add even more to the earthy taste. The longer you cook it the better it gets.
Would the time that it takes to cook – 4 hours – be different if I use less lamb, like, let’s say I halved it or used 2 pounds instead of 3 1/2? Should I cook it less and if so, what’s the formula?
No, the cook time will not change.
I was looking at this recipe–I found it on your blog years ago–I think I’ve been making this for at least ten years. One of our favorites. I’ve used leg of lamb, shoulder, or stew meat, just whatever I happen to find at the grocery. I’ve used red wine, white wine, even lamb & chicken stock instead of wine. It’s always turned out great! We love it with yellow rice–it makes for a gorgeous presentation.
I’ve been wondering for months what to do with the rest of this lamb roast in our freezer and I thought a stew was the way to go. This one sounded so delicious, so I tried it with our roast lamb and it was SPECTACULAR!
Canned roasted bell peppers don’t seem to be a Thing where I live, so I just took two fresh bell peppers and roasted them in the hot cast iron skillet after browning the lamb and the onions. Worked great.
This is kind of a different stew, very wonderful, and I will make it again no question.
I plan on making this recipe weekend but I am curious because I am not a wine drinker and know next to nothing on wines. What is a good brand of dry white wine? Same for the red wine. What would be a good brand to use?
Hi Hailey, look for a Sauvignon Blanc, a dry white wine, that was made in New Zealand. I’ve never had a bad Sauvingnon blanc from New Zealand. Monkey Bay makes one that is reasonably priced and good. Yellow Tail is a brand from Australia that I’ve found to have consistently acceptable wine at a very good price. As for the reds, I usually use a zinfandel from anywhere in Amador County. Whatever you do, don’t use the wine they label “cooking wine” at the grocery store. None of those are good for cooking.
How wonderfully simple. Meat, onion, peppers, tomato, aromatics, spices and wine.
Readers should also take a look at a chicken recipe that uses many of the same techniques.
I’m a big fan, Elise, and I steer as many people as possible to your site.
I made this recipe in a crock pot at home. No red wine, I substituted white instead. Sauteed the onions and deglazed with white wine before adding to the crock pot. I also used a homemade lamb stock that I made the night before instead of the chicken stock with about a cup more stock added to the mix overall. I used some sun dried tomatoes and tomato sauce that I had lying around instead of the large ripe tomato that the recipe calls for. Also, I used 1 lb. ground lamb instead that I rolled into small meatballs with an egg, a bit of flour, salt, and some cumin to spice it up a bit. Not the exact recipe but it’s stewing away happily in the crock pot at the moment so I’ll let you all know how it goes!
This is delicious. Being a broke 19 year old college student, I had to try to stretch it out for a bit of a cheaper dinner. Took out a pound of lamb and added a pound of yukon gold potatoes. Only substitution I made and it was amazing.
Well, no red wine either. Had to dilute some red wine vinegar with some beef stock. Luckily, I had some white wine on hand from last time I cooked dinner for a friend.
Elise, I have made this recipe several times over the past 3 years and it is always savory and delicious. My husband and I are Puerto Rican and love lamb! I am making it next week for a group of friends, serving it with crusty bread and salad. Que rico!
I also wanted to add I used a butterflied leg of lamb cut up and think it really worked well. Tender and tasty.
Delicious, especially with smoked paprika. I halved everything except for the paprika and I used half a large onion, half a shallot and the full amount of garlic for 1.5 pounds lamb. Nice on tomato cous cous with side of paper thin boiled and buttered kohlrabi.
I used leg of lamb, the biutt part, instead of shoulder. I have never made lamb stew. After much labor, the stew is good, but I am very disappointed with the meat. It is stringy and dry. Why?
Hello Dana, the only thing I can think of that would result in dry meat would be it cooking at too high of a heat. It shouldn’t be stringy unless your lamb leg included the shank, which like a chicken drumstick, is stringy.
Hi, can I substitute the lamb for beef? Thanks.
Hello Jonitha, I’ve only ever made this with lamb. If you try making it with beef, please let us know how it turns out for you.
Made this recipe a week ago without marinating the meat it was still wonderfull!!!! Used oven roasted peppers as I could not get ready made peppers.
Elise, how do you think this would turn out using boneless leg of lamb? Has anyone tried this?
Hi Kaitlyn, the recipe calls for lamb shoulder which is a tougher cut of meat than leg of lamb. Think about it this way, the lamb is a grazing animal, always bending its neck down to eat grass. That movement uses the shoulder muscles, which is why they are tougher and also more flavorful. Lamb shoulder is best slowly cooked in stews or braises. Leg of lamb is a wonderfully tender cut of meat (not the shank, but the back thigh). This cut does not need hours of slow cooking to make it tender. It works perfectly well as a roast. So, you could use it in this recipe, but frankly I think it would be a waste of a tender piece of meat to cook it this way.
I made this today and it was really delicious. I’m looking forward to how the flavors develop in the leftovers. This is definitely a keeper of a recipe.
This looks so yummy. Can I ask is there something I can substitute for the red and white wine? We are not wine drinkers and I have tipped many bottles of wine down the sink over the years because I bought them for a recipe and then the unused wine would go off.
I don’t know about a substitute for wine, but you can buy in smaller packages now. Where I live, there are small cartons of wine usually stocked with the box wine. There are some pretty good ones now, and they usually contain a little under two cups of wine. Another idea is to find a couple of recipes that contain wine that you can make within a week.
Don’t throw unused wine away, keep it in a wide-necked glass container with an air-permeable cover and let it turn to vinegar. Good quality wine vinegar is something to be enjoyed. If you are patient you need nothing but air and patience and leftover wine. If you are impatient there are shortcuts and you can find them online.
Looks delish, although I am a meat eater, I have an aversion to eating lamb. Would this be good with another type of meat perhaps? I have made many of your recipes and often receive requests from others to share them! Thanks Elise!
Hi Brenda, your guess is as good as mine with this one. I’ve only made it with lamb.
I love your website and it is my go-to site for new recipes. I love trying all your ethnic recipes. Although I live in a fairly large city, and even in the best grocery store in town, lamb cuts are minima (and expensive). I can find lamb shoulder chops, leg of lamb (boneless), lamb shank. Which would you recommend for this recipe?
Hi Kay, Since the recipe calls for lamb shoulder, I would start there. If not, try it with boneless leg of lamb.
Great luck, the lamb shoulder chops were on sale, and it will be easy to cut the chunks of lamb. Since tomatoes are out of season I’ll use a can of plum tomatoes. Can’t wait to try this on Saturday.
…made this last night for my family…..we all loved it…..we will definately have this again…….thanks for all your wonderful recipes!
I made this for dinner on this very cold January day. It was perfect! I substituted a can of diced tomatoes for the fresh tomatoes. Put the juice in also. After bringing it to a boil on top of the stove, I put it in the oven at 275 degrees for 2-1/2 hours. The red peppers are a necessity! Used smoked paprika also. Thanks Elise!
I plan to make this stew this weekend and now is a good a time of any to clear up my confusion about the various types of paprika. Is Hungarian paprika, sweet paprika? Or are they different. The bag of paprika I have at home simply says “Paprika” so I don’t know whether I should just use what I have or whether I should specifically seek out Sweet Paprika. What do you think?
If you have paprika and it isn’t labeled sweet or hot, most likely it is sweet. Just taste it. If it is hot paprika, it will taste as if someone added cayenne to it. If it doesn’t taste chili-hot, then it’s sweet.
I know this is old, but I just found the recipe and thought someone else might wonder about the paprika. I thought in this country if it’s labelled just “paprika,” it’s sweet, but “Hungarian paprika” would be hot. If you’re lucky enough to get it from an ethnic market with no English on the package, erős paprika is hot and édes or édesnemes paprika is sweet. It also had a lot stronger flavor! We bring back or have relatives send it straight from Hungary.
Hi Erin, the regular labeled paprika here is sweet paprika. When I find the “Hungarian” paprika at the store, it comes in two varieties—sweet or hot. Both are labeled such.
The “mint” mentioned here, is very much Basque, if not for most lamb receipes. I don’t know how this will work with a stew, but if you cook lamb chops or steaks, leave a small “pile” of mint-jam or jelly on the plate, so you can “dip” your lamb prior to putting it in your mouth. YOU WILL BE IN HEAVEN! Mint jam/jelly goes VERY WELL with lamb.
And, if you really want to “impress,” don’t forget to offer (yourself or/and) your guests with a “pecan punch.” It is a cocktail and the receipe can be found on-line. Don’t drink too much, or you will “forget” that you have a meal to eat! This cocktail is “more” than wonderful and as authentic as you can get along with your Basque meal! ENJOY!
Thanks for this, it’s an excellent recipe. Because I like a little more heat, I’ve used a little Basque red pepper, piment d’esplette.
We eat one whole lamb each year. this stew is fantastic.
I’d like to mention that the largest Basque community outside of Europe actually resides in Idaho, around Boise. There’s some great Basque restaurants in Boise and its suburbs and they’re pretty much the only places I eat when I go through. ^_^ Will have to try this soup soon!
There’s also a large Basque community in Elko, Nevada. :-)
And Winnemucca, NV!
Large Basque community here in Bakersfield, Ca., too. We are an ag town and many of our oldest families are Basque. In 2011 one of our Basque restaurants, Noriega’s, won a James Beard award. We are fiercely proud of our Basque!
This sounds wonderful, Elise. I actually have two lamb shoulder roasts I’m planning to simmer for several hours in the dutch oven tonight (with lots of tomatoes and peppers and some rosemary from one of the plants on the windowsill), but now I’m thinking maybe I should change the menu. :) You know I love when you post lamb recipes – and I somehow missed this one in the archives. Thanks!
I am Basque, and always on the look-out for recipes. My great grandmother and great aunt, use to make a lamb stew such as this. They would marinade in red wine, though, and it did not have roasted peppers. Just lots of garlic, onions and Piment d’Espelette. They would serve it with homemade Basque Sheepherders bread – I could eat bowls of it!! Love it!
My family isn’t very fond of lamb unfortunately. Would the recipe still work with pork or beef? Thanks.
I haven’t tried making this with pork or beef, but if you do, please let us know how it turns out for you.
I made this for my husband last week and he loved it! I want to make it again, but forgot to buy the white wine. Can I use red wine for the marinade? If not, what do you suggest?
You could try it. If you do, please let us know how it turns out for you.
Looking forward to making this weekend and was wondering if you have tried substituting smoked paprika in the recipe?
I have not, but if you do, please let us know how it turns out for you!
What kind of parsley?
Doesn’t matter – Italian or curly. Either way it’s going to get chopped up.
Looks perfect, my family is not keen on red bell pepper – may substitute with what?
There is no substitute for roasted red bell pepper in this recipe. ~Elise
You can substitute green bell pepper.
If I wanted to use my own roasted red bell peppers, how many bell peppers is this? Thanks!
3 bell peppers.
I loooooove this recipe. I add more red wine, Green Beans & also diced Potatoes. It just allows me to stretch it a little farther and blends well.I also add fresh Parsley to the marinade. I used canned diced tomatoes w/herbs. Everyone really enjoys this and it’s ALWAYS a hit!
This recipe is incredible. I used grass-fed locally-raised lamb stew meat, and pastured organic chicken fat (schmaltz) in place of the vegetable oil for browning the meat. Also thyme in place of rosemary as I had no fresh rosemary (not a big rosemary fan). Also had to add an extra 1/2 cup of chicken broth (homemade, from pastured chicken) as the liquid seemed to be evaporating too quickly. It was incredibly delicious. Even my husband, who strongly dislikes lamb said this was great (he even had seconds!). This took a bit of work but it was well worth it!!!
I had used all of my tomatos so I subbed in canned whole tomato at the last second and it still turned out awesome. Will definately make this again and would absolutely use it for entertaining to impress guests. Sadly there were no leftovers.
This is the best recipe for lamb. I serve it in all the important occasions! Thank you so much Elise!
While looking for Basque recipes in English with standard measurements, I stumbled upon this one, which looks like a typical “estofado de cordero” recipe from Euskadi. Yet, I must say that any Basque grandma worth her salt would probably have included bay leaf in her estofado instead of rosemary. Try them both and see?
On egin denei!!
Made this for church Easter pot luck. The hit of the event, positive comments from everyone. Cooked it in a Le Creuset French Oven. Lamb was VERY tender. Flavors pronounced. Absolutely heavenly. Do this over noodles, rice, or a grain like quinoa. You’ll be very very happy.
Wonder who was the Easter Super Star this year (besides You-know-who of course!)? Me! and it was all thanks to this incrediblly simple but genuinely good recipe…I still can hear the ohhhs and aahhhs :)
Only had 1 lb of lamb stew. Used all the ingrediants pared down to the amount of lamb I had but still went heavy on the tomatoes. Used roasted red peppers from a jar! Served it over couscous… How Awesome is this???
This is the first time I ever made lamb and I’m in LOVE!
FYI, since I had less lamb it didn’t as long to simmer until tender which meant I got to eat it sooner.
I made this for my husband last year! It was awesome! He has been away for a month on a training mission and this was his request for when he returns!
This is by far the best recipe we have found!!!
Loved it! I spooned off a good bit of grease before serving, but the dish was still very flavorful. I served it over quinoa and it was a big hit. Looking forward to tasting it again in a couple of days to see how it sets up.
Thanks for posting this!
Made this as is except added a clove of garlic, one more tomato, and a little extra red wine. Excellent! I made it another night with beef and used beef broth instead of chicken broth and added a bay leaf, omitted the mint. Very good.
Hubby made these for me for Valentine’s Day but without the red wine though. Still tasted good to me!
Hi, I made this last night, and I wanted to let you know I followed the recipe through step 2, then added mixture and chicken broth to slow cooker, cooked on low for about 2 1/2 to 3 hours. Came out great and was very convenient!
I made this tonight for tomorrow’s dinner. It only simmered an hour, I’ll set it to simmer for the last hour tomorrow around 4.
OMG, so yummy. Thank you!
I tried this last week and my wife and I couldn’t believe how tasty it was! Followed the recipe to a “t” and the results were outstanding.
In fact, we’re having company over the house tomorrow and plan on serving this.
Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.