Cinnamon Toast

Print

So much of our enjoyment of foods comes from the memories they evoke, don’t you think? Cinnamon toast. Just saying the words and I see myself 8 years old sitting at our dining room table with assorted siblings, elbowing each other while we greedily reached for the sugar and cinnamon to sprinkle on our warm buttered toast. (My sister probably doesn’t remember this, but she would skip the cinnamon and just sprinkle on sugar.) Cinnamon toast was a treat. It took skill; if you weren’t careful holding that spoon you would end up with hilly clumps instead of an even spread.

When I mentioned to my friend Heidi that I wanted to write about cinnamon toast she declared, “But it’s so easy!” Then I asked her how she made hers. She mixes a little cinnamon with quite a bit more sugar in a bowl or a jar and then sprinkles over buttered toast. Dear reader, you may think I am a complete ignoramus for admitting this, but never, ever had anyone in our family thought of mixing the two together before sprinkling. We buttered our toast, sprinkled on sugar and then the cinnamon. So naturally, we ended up with a lot of clumps of cinnamon. My father had to oversee the process to make sure we didn’t pour on too much sugar (which we did any time we could get away with it.)

I made cinnamon toast for my goddaughter and her sisters a while ago, mixing the cinnamon sugar first. Cinnamon is expensive, sugar is cheap. A little cinnamon goes a long way. So mix a little cinnamon into the sugar and you don’t waste the cinnamon. The ratio I find that works for me is 1/4 teaspoon of cinnamon to 1 tablespoon of sugar, or about 1:12. I checked this out with Hank, and he told me that his mother’s ratio for cinnamon toast was 1:10. So adjust to your liking.

For all you 8-year olds, in age or spirit, have some toast!

Cinnamon Toast Recipe

Print
  • Yield: Makes two slices of cinnamon toast (and lots of smiles).

Feel free to play with the ratio of cinnamon to sugar to get it to how you like it. Some people like 1:3 cinnamon to sugar, some 1:12, and some in between.

Ingredients

  • 2 slices of sliced bread
  • 2 pads of butter, softened or room temp
  • 1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1 Tbsp white granulated sugar

Method

In a small bowl or jar, stir together the cinnamon and sugar so they are well mixed. Toast your bread. Slather the toast with butter. Sprinkle the cinnamon sugar over the buttered toast.

Hello! All photos and content are copyright protected. Please do not use our photos without prior written permission. If you wish to republish this recipe, please rewrite the recipe in your own unique words and link back to Cinnamon Toast on Simply Recipes. Thank you!

Print

If you make this recipe, snap a pic and hashtag it #simplyrecipes — We love to see your creations on Instagram, Facebook, & Twitter!

There has been much discussion floating around the Internet about the relative merits of making cinnamon toast in the method described here compared to sprinkling the untoasted bread with cinnamon sugar and toasting the slices in the oven. Either way will work, but with the method I've described, the child gets the joy of making her own individual slice of cinnamon toast. Even as an adult I recall the pleasure I had in carefully sprinkling the toast with the sugar and cinnamon, and then eating it right away. The satisfaction that comes from making something yourself, for yourself, is simply priceless. ~Elise

Links:

Like the flavor of cinnamon toast? Check out this cinnamon toast perfume. (Via Amy of Cooking with Amy)
Cinnamon toast ice cream from The Way the Cookie Crumbles
Strawberry cinnamon toast from Fake Food Free
Cinnamon Toast Butter from Tribeca Yummy Mummy

cinnamon-toast-b.jpg
Heidi's daugher (my goddaughter) Piper making her cinnamon toast


Never miss a recipe!

Subscribe to Simply Recipes free via email:

Showing 4 of 154 Comments

  • Fork Lift Operator

    I doubt that Heidi’s daughter had good results applying the cinnamon sugar with a spoon.

    You don’t need to buy cinnamon and sugar separately and blend them. Pretty much everybody sells cinnamon sugar already blended. The only exception would be if you want Ceylon cinnamon instead of Saigon cinnamon. Ceylon cinnamon is another one of those things that most Americans know nothing about. Ceylon is now called Sri Lanka. Madagascar also grows what I believe is the same species.

    Many of the blended products come with shaker tops but I like to keep what’s called a dredge in the cabinet, full of cinnamon sugar. Look for the stainless steel kind that come with a plastic top. If you make the mistake of throwing an aluminum dredge into the dishwasher, it will come out looking awful.

    The best one I’ve found was at Williams Sonoma. Search on “mesh sugar shaker”. Of course they work well for confectioner’s sugar, dusting artisanal bread loaves with flour and dusting countertops and pizza peels with flour when making pizza.

    Just as good as cinnamon toast without the fat from the butter is apple butter toast. There’s no butter in apple butter. Most stores have apple butter in the jelly/jam section. Give it a try. I suppose you could also splash some cinnamon onto the apple butter…I think I just gave myself an idea. Hmmm.

  • Barbara

    Wow . . . have not thought about ‘sugar toast’ in years, we did not add the cinnamon, but it sounds really yummy. Can’t wait for tomorrow morning to make some for breakfast. Bet my 3 year old son will love it.

    Thanks

  • Julia

    I too grew up on cinnamon toast. Our version was the broiler method, but when we went camping we learned to make it from a park ranger and his method is the bomb. In a pie pan combine powdered sugar and cinnamon and set aside. Heat up griddle. In another pie pan put milk. Dip slices of bread into milk until just dampened. Then dip bread into cinnamon sugar mixture. Cook french toast style on buttered griddle until sugar melts and carmelizes. Don’t burn your tongue gobbling it down cause it is fantastic.

  • plainsgal

    I’ve never given up on cinnamon toast-I’ve eaten for more than 50 years, and raised my children on it too! But you must try broiling it. Watching it get to the perfect bubbly state, then anticipating the first warm, crunchy bite is part of the fun. Yes, the bread is only toasted on one side, but the caramelized cinnamon sugar makes up for it!

  • Karina

    Ooh, my favorite way of making cinnamon toast is to mix softened butter, cinnamon, brown sugar and a dash of vanilla, spread it on bread, then bake it in the oven for several minutes. Finish it off under the broiler and oh my goodness, it’s hard to stop myself from eating eight or ten pieces in one sitting (:

View Responses / View More Comments / Leave a Comment