Frutti di Mare Seafood Salad

Please welcome Hank Shaw as he shares a favorite summer seafood salad. ~Elise

Frutti di mare, the Italian mixed seafood salad you see in deli counters all over the country, can range from appalling to sublime. Back when I was living on Long Island, there was an Italian deli in Babylon that made such a fantastic frutti di mare that it has lingered in my memory for decades.

What made it so great? It’s all in the freshness of the ingredients, and the choice of seafood. I remember calamari that melted in your mouth, flakes of crab, briny, firm shrimp, and a mix of tiny clams and scallops so buttery I always saved them for the last bite.

Which seafood you use is up to you. Lobster would be the high end, of course, but crab, scallops, shrimp, crawfish, clams, mussels, calamari, octopus, cuttlefish — really anything you like. A mix of seafood is what is important here, not any specific ratio or variety.

Bring out your good olive oil for this salad, and if you have any fancy salt, use it here, too. A little crunchy finishing salt sprinkled over the salad right before you serve is a nice touch. You can also add a little black or red pepper if you want to jazz things up.

Think of this as a main course salad on hot summer days. It is best served chilled with a loaf of good bread, along with an easy drinking white wine, rose or pilsner beer.

Frutti di Mare Seafood Salad Recipe

  • Prep time: 20 minutes
  • Cook time: 20 minutes
  • Yield: Serves 6-8.

Be sure to follow the steps in order, so all the seafood is properly cooked and the broth becomes nice and flavorful.

Ingredients

Poaching Broth:

  • 4 cups water
  • 1 cup white wine or chicken stock
  • 2 teaspoons salt
  • 2-3 bay leaves
  • 1 teaspoon cracked black pepper
  • 1 small onion, roughly chopped

Salad:

  • 2 celery stalks
  • 1 large yellow or orange bell pepper
  • 1 pound tomatoes
  • 1/2 cup chives
  • 1 pound small cocktail shrimp
  • 1 pound small clams in shell
  • 1/2 pound bay scallops
  • 1/2 pound calamari, cut into rings
  • 1/4 cup high-quality olive oil, or more to taste
  • Juice of 1-2 lemons
  • Salt and black pepper to taste

Method

1 Put all the poaching broth ingredients together in a medium pot, cover and bring to a boil. Turn off the heat to let the flavors steep while you cut the veggies.

2 While the poaching broth is steeping, dice the yellow pepper, seed and dice the tomatoes and slice the celery stalks very thin. Chop the chives. Juice the lemons and remove any seeds. Put the diced peppers, tomatoes and celery into very large bowl. Most cocktail shrimp are pre-cleaned and cooked, so you you can put them in the bowl, too.

3 Bring the poaching broth back to a boil and add all the clams. Boil 3-4 minutes, or until the clams all open up. As soon as you see each clam open, fish it out and set it aside. Remove the meat and put in the bowl with the veggies. Turn off the heat and put the scallops in the poaching water. Cover the pot and let stand for 3-4 minutes. Fish out the scallops and put into the bowl.

4 Bring the broth to a boil once more. Add the calamari rings and boil 30 seconds to 1 minute, then pour the contents of the pot into a strainer set over a bowl. You can save the broth or discard it. Pick out all the calamari rings and add to the bowl.

5 To finish, add the olive oil and a little salt and half the lemon juice. Mix well and taste. Add more olive oil, lemon and salt until you get the flavors you want: The salad should be glistening with oil, briny and tart with lemon. Finally, mix in the chives and chill. This salad is better a few hours after it's made.

Hello! All photos and content are copyright protected. Please do not use our photos without prior written permission. If you wish to republish this recipe, please rewrite the recipe in your own unique words and link back to the source recipe here on Simply Recipes. Thank you!

Follow on Bloglovin

Links:

Linguini ai Frutti di Mare - from Bell'Alimento
Seafood Salad with Creamy Tarragon Dressing - from Leite's Culinaria
Asian Lobster and Mango Salad - from Rasa Malaysia
Frutti di Mare Risotto - from Hunter Angler Gardener Cook

frutti-di-mare-b.jpg

7 Comments

  1. Debbie

    I’ve made this salad for about 35 years and never without fresh garlic. This looks delicious but I would leave out the chives, add the garlic. Fresh lemon and ev olive oil are essential.

  2. Melissa

    This looks awsome! Look forward to trying it! :)

  3. Ron

    Being from Babylon Long Island originally, this made my mouth water for the good old days of The Babylon Docks and waterfront. Now that I live in Tucson Arizona, I still make this salad for friends. I do use plenty of lemon juice and a bit of lime juice as well and lots of garlic. only a bit of salt and pepper. Oh yes. And when I can get it, I do add some thinly sliced scungilli. And here is a trick you might add. put a bit of lemon juice into the poaching liquid. it not only adds some great flavor, but tenderizes the calamari and scungilli. In the old days we used to “cook” the scallops in lime juice instead of the poaching liquid, but i do not do that any longer. And yes, we can get some very good seafood here in Tucson if you just know where to go for it.

  4. Sarah

    I can imagine eating this on my patio with a nice white wine and some crusty bread with butter.
    Now if only the weather in Vancouver would cooperate….

  5. Rossella

    Dear God this is remarkably adherent to the Italian original (like most Italian, and not Italian American, recipes in this outstanding blog) only I suggest not to put “lots of garlic” as Ron said, for this will easily overwhelm the fragrant freshness of some of the seafood (like mussels, if using). A dash of powered garlic or a whole garlic rubbed with energy on the inside of the serving bowl (and then discarded, for extra delicate palates) will prove more than sufficient.
    This salad is done for leftovers, and the day after it is even better than just made: if you cover it in garlic the following day the aroma will have doubled, leaving your mouth bitter (even if vampire-proof).
    I would skip the chives and go for some parsley and – as mentioned – no more than a single garlic clove (powdered, sliced or else). Ciao!

  6. Peter

    I remember just how wonderful the Frutti di Mare was in Italy!!! Yours appears to be nearly identical.

    However, a serious question: What would be your personal recommendation if only frozen seafood ingredients are available? a) won’t be as good, but still worth it or b) don’t even bother?

    BTW – A truly outstanding site. Thank you for your efforts. Even the stuff I don’t try, I really enjoy reading about and getting ideas from.

    I’ve used frozen calamari and shrimp with good results, but the scallops need to be fresh. ~Hank

  7. Salvador Antonacci

    OMG! This is remarkable, its like an Italian original. Great presentation. thank you.

Post a comment

Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.

Some HTML is OK. URLs are automatically converted to links. Line breaks are automatically converted to paragraphs. The following HTML tags are allowed: a, abbr, acronym, b, blockquote, cite, code, del, em, i, q, strike, strong