Grilled Oysters

I know for sure that Hog Island doesn't put their oysters on a bed of rice! But the rice helps steady the oysters and prevents the flavorful sauce and juices from spilling. Of course, I only used rice because I didn't have any rock salt in the house. You can use either, or if you're able to balance the oysters on the grill grates, go for it!

  • Yield: Makes 16 oysters

Ingredients

  • 16 whole live oysters
  • 2 cloves garlic, finely minced
  • 3 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
  • 3 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 1 teaspoon lemon juice
  • 1/2 teaspoon chili pepper flakes (or substitute with dashes of Tabasco)
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • cracked black pepper to taste
  • 1 tablespoon finely minced parsley

Method

Heat a small sauce pan over medium-low heat. When hot, add the olive oil and the butter. Add the garlic and saute until fragrant, about 30 seconds. Add the lemon juice, chili pepper flakes, salt, pepper and parsley. Turn off heat.

How to grill oysters
If you can find large, fat oysters, you can place the oysters directly on the grill grates. It's best to wear long, sturdy BBQ gloves so you can handle the oysters by hand instead of using tongs, spoons or spatula.

However, if the oysters are small and flat, you'll run the risk of spilling its valuable, flavorful juices as well as the garlic-butter sauce.

You can do what I've done, which is to place the oysters on a bed of rock salt or rice in a small pan -- and then placing the entire pan inside the grill or under a broiler. This steadies the oysters and prevents them from wobbling.

If you are a shuckmeister
Shuck the oysters, spoon a little sauce in each oyster. Place oysters on a very hot, preheated grill, cover and cook for 5-6 minutes or until the edges of oysters curl slightly.

If you can't shuck
Place the oysters, cup side up on a very hot, preheated grill, cover and cook for 1 minute. The oysters should now be slightly open. Quickly remove the oysters.

Hold an oyster with an oven mitt and use a shucking knife (or a clean screwdriver if you don't have one) to pry open the oyster. It should easily open.

Spoon sauce into each oyster and return oysters to the grill. Cover and grill 4-5 minutes.

Click on the comments you'd like to print with your recipe. Grayed out comments will not print.

Comments

  • jolie

    Hi elise, what is the alternative for grilling the oyster? can I still use this recipe and oven it? thanks

    • Elise

      Hi Jolie, this really is a recipe for grilled oysters. If you want to cook oysters in the oven, I suggest doing a Google search for baked oysters.

  • holli

    These turned out amazing! I had 12 oysters and lost one but I found doubling the recipe was helpful I also made some more sauce for some grilled shrimp. we shared with a friend and he said they were better than his favorite restaurant for oysters.

  • Marilyn Adams

    I was weaned on oysters and the recipe looks good, BUT…….. They must be put on the grill with the cup side on the bottom! Cupped side on the grill. Because when they open, that nice cupped shell will keep all the juices in. Nectar of the gods!

  • J Smith

    Wow, I was just thinking that my brother & I needed to grill another batch of oysters next month. This is great inspiration. Last January we did 4 dozen and 4 different toppings because oysters were so inexpensive. We decided our fav was a topping with red wine vinegar, worcestershire, parsley, cayenne, red pepper flakes, black pepper, cooked bacon, a bit of horseradish & lemon juice and sauteed shallots and garlic.

  • Tracy (Amuse-bouche for Two)

    To help in the shucking department, you can also put the oysters into the freezer for about 5 minutes. Insert the knife into the shucking end, twist, and pop…you’ve got an open oyster.

  • Anna

    I didn’t grow up eating oysters, but I’m trying to cultivate a taste for them now as they are really healthy and a great source of zinc. I’m lucky to have a great cultivated oyster business nearby so I can buy them the local farmer’s market.

    We’ve been making some long drives lately and to pass the time I’ve been listening to an audio recording of Mark Kurlansky’s book The Big Oyster: History on the Half Shell. Like Kurlansky’s other books, Cod: A Biography of a Fish that Changed the World and Salt, this book about oysters is fascinating.

    Thanks for the recommendation. I love Kurlansky’s books! ~Elise