Will be making this next weekend for a Patriots party here in Mass. Worked in Louisville 2 years ago and had this dish, will be serving this along with bbq ribs
It seems odd to cook the chicken thighs with the skin on. Doesn’t it make the stew greasy? I am cooking it now and curious to taste it!
Can you make this and then freeze to serve the following weekend? I’m having a Kentucky Derby Party but will be out of town until the day before.
Hi Libba, I haven’t tried freezing it but I don’t see why it wouldn’t work.
How about adding locally raised Wild Boar? It’s so lean and absolutely delicious!
Wondering if anyone has made this and frozen part of it for another day, a month or so out? I’ve had great luck freezing my huge batches of bean soup, in freezer bags laid out flat so they defrost fast.
I am in the 2 hour simmer part of this recipe now! Not looking forward to removing the bones and not sure how I’ll do it, but will figure it out. Won’t they be hot? I plan to bring it to a Derby party tomorrow. I’ll finish the cooking tonight – will it be ok in the fridge overnight and then reheated? Or should I put it in a crock pot on low all night?
Yes, it will be okay in the fridge overnight and then reheated. ~Elise
About the okra question… I was raised in Louisville, KY, home of the Kentucky Derby, and now reside in a little hamlet called Georgetown, KY. I have made and/or eaten burgoo from all over the state for decades, and though I have not tried your recipe, it looks very tasty. Burgoo is like BBQ, it’s different, but familiar, from region to region. For the meats, I’ve always used a combination of pork, beef, and chicken (despite our local moniker of “roadkill stew” for this delicious concoction!). Now, back to the okra. It will not be at all slimy if done right. I dump a 1 lb bag of frozen, sliced okra into the pot before the long cook (several hours). The okra will disintegrate and thus add an amazing thickness to the broth that is the essence of true burgoo. I also add the lima beans at this time so their tough skins can soften. The corn should be added towards the very end of the cooking time. Instead of, or in combination with, the worcestershire sauce, experiment with a half bottle or more of BBQ sauce… it really perks up the broth! Thanks for a great site! Jean
Is this significantly different from New Brunswick stew? It’s something I’m familiar with from Tennessee, and this hits all the notes–including commenters who mention that older recipes call for game (esp. rabbit). Even the lima beans, and people who like to cook it til it’s sludge! Even the Tabasco sauce…
I think burgoo is typically served at a large gathering, and would typically have more than one type of meat in it. ~Elise
I made this the other night I browned everything and then threw it all in my 7q crockpot over night on high for 7h ( because my dh woke up for work at 6 and he always wakes me up with his noise so i asked him to turn it on low and I got up at 9) and low for 3 ad hrs I also got up at 4am( thats just when I woke in the night) to take the meat off the bone) I used a pork tenderloin cause it was 1/2 price, stewing beef and chicken thighs. I also used kidney beans because I didn’t have any lima on hand. my dh has not eaten anything but this for the past 4 days. I have even cooked other yummy things and he only wants to eat this. I think I used about 1/4 c worcestershire sauce and I also put in a few drops of liquid smoke and a sweet potato instead of a white one. Just made more sense to me being a southern dish. I am going out this week to get some more meat to make it again!
We don’t have lima beans in New Zealand, but I’m trying canned Cannellini beans in my stew tonight – it smells divine and I still have an hour to wait…. I wonder if lima beans are the same as what we call “broad beans”? This is my favouritist recipe site on earth – I have a stack of printed recipes and forward them onto Mum. Thanks Elise.
Hi Carissa, broad beans, also known as fava beans, are different from lima beans, but you can use them in this recipe in place of the lima beans, as long as you shuck them from their pods, boil them separately first, then remove the outer peel, before adding them to the stew. ~Elise
Is there any chance of seeing a Snapping Turtle soup pop up on here anytime soon?
Great question! Although terrapin soup has been on distinguished menus for decades (a hundred years ago) I have no plans to make for Simply Recipes. My go-to guy for game Hank Shaw is not fond of cleaning turtle, and I don’t think we have many snapping turtles here in Northern California. ~Elise
Elise that is wonderful historical recipe. I would love to make this for some of my friend this weekend. But they don’t eat beef. Can I substitute it with lamb or can I just make it with only pork and chicken. Thank you.
According to other commenters mutton is traditional, so I assume lamb would be an excellent substitution. ~Elise
Grew up in southwest Indiana, and Burgoo was popular late summer fare – like the writer from Illinois, cooked in kettles over a fire at big family and church gatherings – yummy! My question/comment – we always put in a cheesecloth laden with spices to simmer in the stew (maybe this is called the “cat”? – I cannot remeber). Any idea what spices to include?
So love this recipe! I am adding it to my next menu planner….. Question – we only use white meat chicken, since it would no doubt dry out cooking it as long as the dark meat, when should I add it? If the meats and chicken cook for roughly 2 hrs, maybe 1/2 of that? Thanks for all of the fabulous recipes Elise!
Good question, no idea on the answer. I don’t put chicken breast meat in stews unless it’s with the rest of the chicken. The dark meat from the thighs and legs is what works in a stew like this. They’re more flavorful. ~Elise
I made this for dinner tonight. It was quite good. I added some tarragon, bay leaves, and tomato paste. I used fresh corn rather than frozen. I prepped it this morning and let it cook in the slow cooker all day. Served it with french bread. What a wonderful, and easy, dinner. Very tasty. Thanks!
I made this stew last night for my Sunday meal today. I’m having my mother make some mashed potatoes so we can dump the stew over it. They are going to look at me very strangely when I tell them what it is.
While I was cooking, I must have gone through a half loaf of bread soaking up the broth and stuffing my face…it oughta be REAL good today.
Elise, this is the best looking recipe for Burgoo I’ve seen yet! I think it’s the meats used, as most recipes call for wild meat. Plus..you have Lima beans it in..my favorite! .
re lima beans, Often the problem people have with the texture is because they don’t cook them long enough. Frozen lima’s take about 25-30 minutes, minimum, to cook through, otherwise the texture is hard or crumbly. Cooked long enough, they are as creamy as cannelini or other beans. They are a perfect addition to stew or soups that take a longer time to cook because they get so soft yet still hold their shape.
Andrea @ Fork Fingers Chopsticks: You said you would be swapping okra for the lima beans…good idea! Is it better to use fresh or frozen okra? I have used it a few times, but I remember that one version is rather slimy, and I don’t like slimy food!! Thanks for the suggestion.
I think okra, fresh or frozen, still cooks up slimy, doesn’t it? ~Elise
Gorgeous photos! Thanks for the intro to burgoo. I’ll be adding in okra and swaping out the lima beans with another. Maybe cannellini? Or, is that complete sacrilege?
I’m guessing that anything goes with this stew. Cannellini, why not? ~Elise
Sounds delish! One thing though. When is the garlic added, when browning the veggies?
Good catch! Thank you. Right before you add the meat. I’ve adjusted the recipe. ~Elise
I was born and raised in KY and ate burgoo all of my life. Of course, our local burgoo may have had squirrel, turtle or rabbit in it. But beef, chicken and pork work. Also, you might try adding a can of beer. Yum!
I see squirrel mentioned a lot in articles about burgoo, as well as venison and possum. Thanks for the beer idea! ~Elise
Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.