21 Comments

  1. Edith

    This is a delicious stew and was a good way to use some of the root vegetables from our winter CSA share. The only change I made was in step 6 rather than pushing the vegetables through a strainer, I put them in a food processor along with some of the broth. This thickened the sauce and retained all the flavor. Just a thought.

  2. Peter

    Could I do this as a root vegetable stew sans the lamb or any other meat? From the ingredients, I suspect you could still get bold flavor without meat.

    • Elise

      Hi Peter, given that the root vegetables are roasted first, you would still have a lot of flavor in this stew. If you try it without meat, please let us know how it turns out for you!

  3. Elizabeth Duckworth

    My mother taught me this recipe back in 1960 when she was helping me learn to fix inexpensive meals for my husband and myself when we were going to college and living in the housing for married students.
    The only thing that has changed is the price of Lamb Shanks. It once was about the cheapest meat you could buy at a cost of about 19 cents per shank, plus so many people had a small garden, the rest could be free, especially if you invited them for dinner!
    55 years later I am still fixing this dish, my husband is still enjoying it, my mother is still alive. I think the only thing I do a little differently is when I add the meat back to the pot to simmer and warm up (step 7) I then add my gremolata on top of the meat, it seems that just those few minutes will take away the “rawness” of the garlic and lemon, for us it works better.

  4. patricia

    made this using a pressure cooker. turned out great! thank you for this recipe

  5. Jeanne Morales

    I am from Sacramento however now live about 40 miles in a village from Guadajara Mexico. We have lamb shanks but no rutabagas, parsnips or turnips. Lots of carrots. I love the winter root veggies. What could I use instead? Also I would add a little of barley to the dish.

    If you don’t have root vegetables, I would just skip them. The lamb will still be great. ~Elise

  6. Georgia

    Elise — I’m writing this on Saturday of the “Blizzard of 2010/Super Bowl weekend”. Pre-blizzard, my husband and I labored over what to have on this snowy evening in front of a crackling fire. We settled on this one and it DELIVERED. It was deeply flavorful and the meat melted in the mouth. As for the roasted vegetable component, I’ve never heard of this technique of roasting vegetables separately then adding them to a stew, but it really worked well. I’d be interested in knowing if this technique is in any way traditional for a stew. Anyway, I would highly recommend to others to take this extra step, which I didn’t find to be much of a chore. Thanks for the recipe. It’s a keeper.

    Hi Georgia, roasting the vegetables separately is a chef technique for bringing out more of the flavor that you get when caramelization occurs from the roasting. So glad you agree it’s worth the effort! ~Elise

  7. athina

    Wow! This was the most tender meat I have ever eaten! I loved the flavor of the roasted root veggies.
    Question though- towards the end,(after the solids are pushed through the strainer) when you direct us to bring the sauce to a boil, would you recommend reducing the sauce at all? thought that maybe it would concentrate the flavor of the sauce just a bit. the sauce was a beautiful rich brown sauce, but didn’t have as deep of a flavor as I’d expected. I enjoyed the gremolata topping,and felt it complemented the lamb beautifully. It might be helpful to let people know, that they should ask the butcher to cut the shanks into pieces- (versus trying it at home with a chef’ knife) nice fall recipe!

    If you want to reduce the sauce further, sure, why not? So glad you liked the stew. ~Elise

  8. Susan Vibert

    Delicious as well as easy to assemble and prepare. Have been looking for a good lamb shank recipe and this is it. Did not have chicken stock but substituted roasted chicken demi-glace….about a full tablespoon….in addition to 1 cup beef stock and 2 cups of homemade, salt-free vegetable stock. Most would need to add extra salt, but I monitor my sodium intake. I also used the zest from the entire orange to give it a bit more bite which I believe eliminated the need for additional salt. In addition, after removing the parsnips and carrots from the roasting pan, I left the turnips in for another 25 minutes so that they became slightly crispy and semi-caramelized.
    As I adore Moroccan food, next time I’ll add sulfa-free apricots, golden raisins and a few tangy green olives, which flavors will add to the orange zest.
    Thank you so very much for this wonderful recipe.

  9. Brad

    So we made this dish as the virgin recipe for our new dutch oven and it was absolutely amazing. We got a nice loaf of bread to dip in it as well and mmmmmmm good!

  10. Nate

    I like that added step of roasting the veggies. Usually you see recipes that call for just stewing and then straining the veggies. But what will you have then, besides meat and strained veggies?

    Thanks for posting this!

  11. Sudu Roy

    Last weekend was a snowy blizzard blast here in the northeast. Thanks to your recipe, it worked well to keep us nice and warm! I used some Welch’s grape juice (instead of the wine) and it turned a bit syrupy and sweet (should have listened to you) which I didn’t like. But the veggies were so perfect with lamb, I am going to do this a few more times before the winter ends. Pls have more such recipes coming!

  12. Paul

    If you have trouble finding lamb try a mid-east market. If there is a mosque in your area you can find great bargains in the Halal butcher shop.

  13. Jesse

    Hi Elise, I made the stew and loved it. I’d forgotten how wonderful roasted turnips and rutabagas are!

    The gremolata wasn’t very much to our taste, though. Maybe next time I’d boil or roast the garlic lightly to cut the harshness a bit…

  14. Janice Hicks

    This was sooOoooo good! Okay, even with my odd substitution of Welch’s grape juice for the dry red wine and a sliced sweet potato and Irish potato for the rutabaga, which dear husband did not find at the local market.
    This was the first time I’ve ever cooked parsnips or turnips. Very satisfying. Thank you again for all you do and all you share of what you do in your kitchen.

  15. Monica

    I made this recipe last night and it was truly amazing. The broth alone is worth the work that goes into it. I used a regular pot (not a Dutch oven) and it turned out great. Can’t wait for the leftovers tonight!

  16. John

    This recipe sounded wonderful, but being in the midst of Post Holiday Spending Financial Recovery Season, I decided to take your suggestion and make it using a chuck roast. It turned out beautifully. Perhaps the best beef stew I’ve ever made, though that may be because I was craving root veggies at the time.

  17. Nick

    For those from the UK who were wondering: rutabaga = swede

  18. Laurie

    This looks almost exactly like the dish I used to serve in a restaurant about 10 years ago. My sous chef had lived in Italy for a while and I vaguely remember learning this dish from her. We served it with tomato – lemon gremolada sprinkled over the top and on creamy polenta in a big bowl. It was fabulous! I had forgotten all about that dish until just now. I think we threw in some fresh thyme, and rosemary also.

  19. Angela

    And it’s local! I work for Superior Farms, right up the road from you in Dixon. Your recipe looks amazing. If your readers would like lamb info or if you’re interested in other recipes, visit http://www.superiorfarms.com.

  20. Joe G

    This seems like a lot of effort for a stew. I think the whole point is to minimize the number of pots and cooking methods. I’m okay with browning the meat, removing it and browning the carrots, onions and garlic, but why not brown the other vegetables then also instead of baking? If I attempt this, that’s the way I’m doing it so that I still get some type of char on the vegetables and they pick up the flavor of the meat, garlic and onion early on. Stew is about tender meat, large vegetable chunks to retain their shape and flavor, and simplicity.

    Hi Joe, roasting the vegetables brings out a lot of their flavor. This stew does have a few extra steps, but as a frequent stew-maker of all sorts of stews, I assure you, it is worth the effort. The first vegetables that get browned end up being pushed through a sieve to make the sauce. The roasted vegetables retain their shape and consistency by being cooked separately. There are, by the way, other lamb stews on this site, using different methods. ~Elise

Post a comment

Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.