I did your recipe and all the jars sealed great. Several days later all the jars started to pop. Why is this happening.
Hi Annette, if the jars lids are popping up (instead of popping in), there’s a problem and I would throw out those jars. If the jars are making a large popping noise and the lids are now indenting in, that’s what they are supposed to do.
Hi, I was wondering if I can substitute citric acid for the lemon juice? I think it would be 1/4 tsp per tbsp lemon juice so 4 tsp citric acid? If I do, do I need to replace the liquid in the recipe? Thanks
Hello Valerie, I don’t know the answer to this one.
Did anyone half and seed prior to roasting? Seems it would be easier to deal with then after cooked.
Hi Cheryl, the outside of the bell pepper needs to be almost completely blackened, which is easier to do without drying out or overcooking the inside if the pepper is whole.
I have begun halving and seeding before broiling and it is quite a bit easier for me. Also there is less tearing of the blackened peppers when trying to get seeds out of them. Just watch the broiler a little more closely.
if my lids have not popped, can I put the jars back on water to “reseal” them?
Yes, you can put them back in a boiling hot water bath for 10 minutes.
I really want to try this so for shopping purposes, how many peppers approx is 4 pounds? I am guessing 12-14?
Hi Susan, it all depends on the size of the peppers. Hard to say.
I bought 14 huge peppers. All that work and it only made 2 jars. Large 700 ml jars but still. Prob will not do this again
I was wondering what size bottle of lemon juice you used. Thanks
Hello Deborah. 1 cup equals 8 ounces. So, you’ll need at least an 8-ounce bottle of lemon juice.
Hi there, I followed your recipe but ended up with a lot of left over marinade, so I roasted more peppers to use up the marinade – and with all the peppers, it worked out to about 8 pints. i followed the instructions for water bath preserving them, but I’m worried that maybe the proportions will be off since I spread the marinade into more jars. What do you think?
Hi Marni, as long as you are covering the cooked bell pepper strips with the marinade in the jars, you’re fine.
I had the same issue – lots of extra marinade and I’m out of peppers. Perhaps I packed the jars too full? Otherwise the directions were super easy to follow!
I prepared this recipe last night but realized after the process was finished ” I forgot to add the salt!” Did I ruin them?
Hi Cindy, no, you didn’t ruin them. They just won’t be as flavorful as they would be if you had added salt. Remember to sprinkle salt on them when it comes time to eat them.
Can I use any kind of vinegar or just white ty
You could use apple cider vinegar, as long as it is 5% acetic acid.
I have a question… I have done a lot of canning this year and it seems that the only jars that have not kept their seal was the red peppers.. Does anyone know how this might effect the red peppers or should I just toss them out because of them popping their seals?
Hi Terry, with a low acid food such as red bell peppers, even in the marinade, if the seal is popped I would toss it. A water bath can help the jars seal better in the future. Did you water bath them? If you did, and they still haven’t kept their seal, that’s not a good sign. The exception in canning is with high sugar foods like jams. The sugar alone will kill the bacteria. But in this case, all you are going on is the acid.
Can I half the recipe? I’m using chili peppers & want to include seeds/ innards for the heat.
Hi Carol, Yes, you can halve the recipe. I also suggest looking at our pickled jalapenos recipe if you are planning on preserving chili peppers.
Hi! I just canned three pint jars of my home grown peppers using this recipe. I can’t wait to try them! I did have some leftover marinade; perhaps I packed the peppers tighter like when you pickle them. I was wondering if I could save the marinade for a later batch? My grandma reuses her pickle brine by refrigerating it then bringing it to a boil before use, and I was wondering if I could do the same with this marinade. Hoping to make some more!
Hi Aubrey, sure, just chill the unused marinade and reboil when you want to can again.
I did exactly as the recipe called to do, I went to put the first jar in and the bottom of my jar broke off and I had peppers and garlic and olive oil floating in my water bath. ahhhh! so I was kind of nervous to do the other jars. Do you think I did something wrong or was it a fluke? this is the first time I ever had that happen to me. Any suggestions?
Hi Gail, that does happen sometimes, even to the most experienced canners. It’s a mess! It might be due to a flaw in the jar. Or perhaps the side of the jar was touching a hot part of the pan instead of being suspended by a rack. It’s usually a temperature difference that can cause the cracking. If you put hot glass into cold water it may crack. If you put a cold glass into hot water it may crack. Make sure you are using good quality mason jars.
I just tried this recipe. I followed the instructions very closely, however a tiny amount of liquid leaked out while they were boiling. All of the jars seem well-sealed, so I can’t figure out which one leaked. (I did 6 half pints). The tops are popped in, and no liquid comes out when I turn them upside-down. Should I be worried? I’m giving them as Christmas gifts, but re-canning them would be A LOT of work.
No worries if the jars are well-sealed. ~Elise
Can vegetable oil be used to store the peppers instead of olive? I know olive tastes better but I am poor!
Sure! You can use vegetable oil instead of olive oil. ~Elise
I just canned a batch and I’m really excited about them! I have a question, though. I’ve heard that canning peppers can be dangerous if not done properly, and I used half pint jars instead of the full pint jars in the recipe. I doubt this is a problem, but I wanted to make sure. What do you think? Am I just splitting hairs?
Half-pint jars will work fine. ~Elise
Hi there, I’ve just used your recipe for roasted red peppers and have a question. After I had boiled the jars in a large saucepan for 15 min, i cooled them a bit then placed them on my table, but the marinade had yellow butter-like layer floating on top? Is this normal, it doesnt look right to me and I dont see that on your visuals?
Sounds like a layer of fat. It’s probably just the olive oil that has emulsified with some of the other ingredients. ~Elise
This is a fantastic recipe. My family tried it two years ago and loved having tasty red peppers for sandwiches and salads in the middle of winter. So much better than a sad hothouse tomato. Last year we put up 6 jars when we found a killer deal on local peppers. Thanks for sharing this, its on my list of fantastic can’t live without recipes!
I tried the recipe with both red and yellow peppers. It not only looks good, also tastes great! Thank you very much for the recipe.
I just tried this recipe for the first time and I was wondering if you use all of the marinade?
I ended up with quite a bit left after putting the peppers in the jars. Are they still okay to leave on the shelf?
It was a while ago, but I don’t remember having leftover marinade. I think you should be fine even with some left over. ~Elise
I love roasted veggies and the amazing flavors that result. I saw that someone asked about a jar that didn’t seal. I’m not an expert at canning but I do know that some are safe to re-seal and eat, others aren’t. I wouldn’t try to re-process bell peppers; instead I’d refrigerate them and eat within a couple of weeks.
I have frozen jars with an inch of head space and the liquid didn’t expand evenly when it froze and I ended up with a cracked jar. I leave a little more than an inch now, making sure it’s about 3/4 inch below the lowest point of the lid. I have more room than I need, but no more broken jars.
Looks awesome!!! I have a question about the consistency and taste of the marinade…
You use 1 cup olive oil, 2 cups white vinegaer and 1 cup lemon juice. So what does the marinade taste like – I am guessing that it like an oil and vinegaer salad dressing but I am not sure if the canning dulls the vinegar so you have more of an oil based marinade? I tend to tamper with amounts when I cook and wanted your thoughts on this.
Thanks and can’t wait to make.
Canning does not dull the vinegar. Also, you should not tamper with the amounts or proportions of this recipe if you intend to store for any length of time. If you plan to eat up right away and store in the fridge, no problem, improvise away. But for long term storage, you need enough vinegar to effectively retard any harmful bacteria. ~Elise
Thank you for such a wonderful blog! I’ve been reading it for a while now, and I’ve had lots of success with your delicious recipes. I made this recipe and processed them for longer storage, but one of the jars didn’t seal. Can I freeze the jar to keep it longer, since I didn’t have plans to use the peppers too soon?
Great question, I don’t know. Some foods freeze better than others and I don’t know how marinated cooked bell peppers would do. I do know that if you try it, you should have at least an inch of head room in the jar so when the liquid in the jar expands as it freezes it doesn’t break the jar. ~Elise
I just made these today, so easy! I came home from visiting my Dad with a big bag of peppers and I personally hate them but my husband loves them. So I roasted and jarred them up for him today. Thanks for the recipe! It’s really well explained.
Here in Serbia we use peppers in a lot of different ways – one of the all time favourites is the “roasted peppers salad”: roasted and peeled whole red peppers (we usually use the pointed tip ones, since they look nicer on the serving plate) are left in a marinade of vegetable oil, vinegar, garlic and fresh parsley. Yummy!
If you can swing it, throw those bad boys on the grill to char! You will end up with luscious, smoky-flavored peppers that are divine!
The University of Minnesota Cooperative Extension office has a WONDERFUL Marinated Red Peppers recipe on their website (for canning).
Yes, grilling is an excellent way to get more flavor! BTW, The Univ of Minn’s marinated peppers recipe is the same as Michigan State’s, which is the basis for this recipe. ~Elise
I have been really wanting to try canning and this recipe sounds fantastic! One question, I thought for canning vegetables, you need to use a pressure cooker. Do you need to use a pressure cooker for the peppers or does the lemon juice used work? I’m scared to use a pressure cooker and thought jams would be an easy thing to try. Thanks!
Hi Nat, you need a pressure canner when canning low acid vegetables in a low acid state. These bell peppers are soaked in a high acid vinegar and lemon juice-based marinade. Because of the high acidity, you can safely process them through a water bath. ~Elise
I just roasted a big batch of peppers to make ajvar (an eggplant pepper spread).
I roasted them by the broiler method, turning until blistered and the skin charred all over. Because of the amount of peppers, I just popped them into an enamel roasting pan and placed the lid on. You could drape the pan with a towel to hold the heat longer, but this method works really well if you’ve got a couple of pans of peppers to broil or roast.
Easy and the roaster holds all the juice.
OK, now this is weird. I canned roasted red peppers almost exactly the way Boaz does just yesterday. I thought, “Hmmm…I bet Elise would like it if I did this recipe for Simply Recipes.” So I went on your site and…
Wow. Looks like we were on the same wavelength, eh?
PS – I also did a massive round of fire-roasted jalapenos the same way. Muy picante!
This looks great. When I roast pepper them into paper sandwich bags instead of a bowl to steam. Works well.
I usually put chiles into small paper bags when I roast them. But when I did that with the bell peppers, they let out so much juice, it made a mess. So I think the better solution, at least for me, with bell peppers is to put them in a glass bowl and cover. That way all of the juice is caught, and can even be added to the marinade. ~Elise
These look wonderful. Can I substitute fresh lemon juice, or is the bottled juice essential? Thanks for what I’m sure is another keeper recipe!
Bottled lemon juice is recommended because it has consistent acidity. That said, the lemons from our tree (not the Meyers) are quite acidic, so I have no problem using those. It sort of depends on the lemon. Early season lemons are more acidic (good) than late season. Don’t use Meyers. ~Elise
Used some of these with some white beans and lemon to make an awesome dip for veggies and chips. Tomorrow they will adorn a simple lentil salad. =)
I enjoyed a Caprese sandwich today. Roasted peppers, buffala (the best) mozzarella, fresh basil…and took it over the top with some thinly sliced prosciutto.
A little extra virgin…a splash of good red wine vin…oh, marone a mi…so good.
I make roasted red peppers every week – usually about 4 large peppers at a time. Here in Venezuela I can get nice red peppers almost year-round. I cut up the peppers – slice off the very botton so they are stable, then slice down each side leaving the core and seeds in one piece to be thrown out. I put the peppers skin side up, topped with finely chopped garlic and drizzled with olive oil, in pyrex dishes in a counter top convection oven at broil. When the skins look blistery and a bit black I cover the dishes and let them cool while the skins loosen. Then I peel off the skins and save the pepper slices in the fridge in the remaining oil-garlic-pepper juice mixture from the cooking pans. It’s gotten to be a routine which isn’t very time consuming and can be done while I am cooking other things.
My experience with roasting peppers in Naples has taught me to place the broiled peppers in a paper bag and closed the top. Works wonders.
I love to freeze all kinds of roasted peppers: red bell, poblano, jalapeno–that way I have them at the ready when pulling together a quick pizza, sandwich, or want a little something extra to add to soup.
Marinating them imparts a nice bit of flavor, giving them a head start for appetizers and salads. A great way to enjoy them in the months ahead.
I routinely make roasted bell peppers (here in Israel the colored bell peppers are significantly cheaper than they are in the US), but I use a different method. I begin the evening before I want to begin the marinating process.
1. I place all of my peppers on a large oven sheet covered with a double layer of foil. I will usually uses around 2 kg of peppers of different colors (I like to mix yellow and red ones).
2. I place the sheet in the oven, and turn it on 400 degrees F (~200 degrees C). I leave the oven on for about 60-75 minutes. The house will get a wonderful roasted pepper smell, and the peppers will be blackened in spots.
3. Turn off the oven and leave the pan with the peppers in the oven overnight.
4. In the morning, take the peppers out of the oven. The steam in the oven will have loosened the skins of the peppers.
5. Working over a colander placed over a bowl to catch the pepper liquids, peel the peppers. Make sure to discard the seeds. The peppers will exude about 1-2 cups of flavorful liquid that will be part of the marinade. Do not wash the peppers — this will wash off some roasted flavors. This step is a little messy, so I keep some paper towels to wipe my hands periodically. Do not worry if a few seeds remain.
6. Prepare a marinade: mix 1 cup vinegar with one cup of collected pepper juices. Add spices as you please (I like to put a bay leaf and a couple of cloves). Bring to a boil.
7. While the marinade is being brought to a boil, start layering the peppers in a large, clean, jar. Between the layers of peppers add sliced garlic, to taste. I like a lot of garlic so I use about 7-8 cloves.
8. Pour the hot marinade over the peppers, making sure to cover them all. Close the jar and refrigerate for at least 24 hours. The flavors improve over time, and the peppers will keep for several weeks (I’ve kept them for about two months with no problems).
Notice that this method does not require any salt or olive oil.
An alternative method for removing the skins after blistering is to put the peppers in a sealable plastic freezer bag. The steam really builds up and makes the skins very easy to peel off.
Thanks for the recipe, will definitely be trying this.
Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.