Pecan Pie

What’s your favorite Thanksgiving pie? Mine is a toss up between apple, pumpkin, and pecan pie. In fact, I love them all so much I make one of each for our T-day feast. (It seems like everyone in our family has their favorite, and if I don’t make them all someone will run to the store to fill the gap!)

Pecans are native to North America, so it is entirely fitting that a pecan pie would make an annual appearance at Thanksgiving along with our other native foodstuffs like turkey, pumpkin, and cranberries. Pecan pie itself though, is a more recent invention. It became popular through the marketing efforts of Karo in the 1930s, to help sell their corn syrup, a necessary ingredient in the pie.

Most pecan pie recipes I’ve found call for 2 cups of sugar—one cup of corn syrup plus one cup of either granulated or brown sugar. I find that just a bit too sweet for my taste, so I’ve dropped the sugar down by half a cup. Feel free to reduce further or add more to your taste. The molasses, butter and vanilla bring out the wonderful flavor of the pecans. Nuts go rancid with storage, so make sure you are using the freshest of pecans for this pie!

Recipe updated Nov 21, 2014, originally posted 2005

Follow on Pinterest

Pecan Pie Recipe

  • Prep time: 15 minutes
  • Cook time: 1 hour, 15 minutes
  • Yield: Serves 8

Ingredients

  • 1 9-inch pie shell, frozen (freeze for half an hour if freshly made) (I recommend our easy, flaky, sour cream pie crust)
  • 2 cups pecans, coarsely chopped (save a few whole pecan halves to create a decoration on the surface of the pie if you want)
  • 3 eggs, slightly beaten
  • 1 cup light corn syrup
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 1 Tbsp molasses
  • 4 Tbsp butter, melted
  • 2 Tbsp flour
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 2 teaspoon vanilla

Method

1 Preheat oven to 350°F. In a small bowl vigorously mix together the eggs, brown sugar, corn syrup, molasses, melted butter, flour, vanilla, salt, until smooth. (No need for a mixer, you can beat by hand using a wooden spoon.)

pecan-pie-300-1 pecan-pie-300-2

2 Spread the chopped pecans over the bottom of a frozen pie shell. Pour the filling over the pecans. Don't worry about burying the pecans, they will rise to the surface. (If you have reserved a few whole pecan halves, you can use them to arrange them on the surface in a decorative pattern. Just dip them below the wet filling and let them rise again so they get coated with the filling.)

Bake at 350°F for 30 minutes. After 30 minutes tent the pie loosely with aluminum foil to prevent the crust and pecans from getting too browned. Bake for another 40 to 50 minutes until the filling has set. The pie should be just barely wiggly in the center.

pecan-pie-300-3

4 Remove from oven and let cool completely. Note that the pie will be puffed up a bit when you first take it out of the oven, it will settle as it cools.

Hello! All photos and content are copyright protected. Please do not use our photos without prior written permission. If you wish to republish this recipe, please rewrite the recipe in your own unique words and link back to the source recipe here on Simply Recipes. Thank you!

Follow on Pinterest

Links:

Deep Dish Pecan Pie from Matt Bites

Grandmotherhood and pecan pie from Lisa Fain, our Homesick Texan

Pecan Pie Muffins from Miss Amy at Tasty Kitchen

Maple Pecan Pie from Nic of Baking Bites

Chocolate Espresso Pecan Pie from Use Real Butter

Pecan Pie

107 Comments

  1. ginny

    Okay, that was very, very easy to put together, and I took a picture of the results and posted it on my blog. The only thing I forgot was to put some whole pecans on the top as a garnish. I was lucky to find fresh ones with good flavor, and the pie looks like it’s supposed to look, so we only have to wait until after dinner to find out if I did it right.

    Also, I threw a dollop of molasses in the mix for my pumpkin pies, because I saw that mentioned somewhere else. We’ll see how those turn out as well.

  2. deb

    Elise, I had to let you know that I made the pecan pie using your recipe and it was fabulous! Best pecan pie I’ve ever tasted and I’m going to make it again to take to Mom’s for Christmas but will double the recipe for two pies. Thanks again for sharing your recipe. It’s a keeper :))

  3. kerrie

    This pie is fabulous and easy! I highly recommend!

  4. Noory

    HEY this is the best pecan pie ever!! try it!! byee

  5. raquel

    I made this yesterday. My first pecan pie and it turned out beautifully. I followed the pie crust tutorial and was so pleased with the result.
    I wasn’t a fan of pecan pie until the smell filled my whole house, making my guests ooh and ah.
    Thanks again, Elise.

  6. Tina

    Mmmm…. this pecan pie was delicious and SO easy to make! The molasses is a very interesting twist. I was browsing the internet for the “perfect pecan pie” recipe for Thanksgiving and cringed every time I saw one cup of corn syrup and one cup of sugar on the list of ingredients. I love your site and should have known to look here first! :-)

  7. jonathan

    Love it. May try substituting the vanilla with a little bourbon….I do declare (how “Southern” of me).

    I’ll bet some chocolate would be nice, too.

  8. Christine

    Hi Elise,
    I’d love to make this pie but can’t tolerate corn syrup. Do you suppose the recipe would work if the corn syrup was omitted entirely?
    Thanks.

    Hi Christine, great question. I have no idea how it would work if you omitted the corn syrup. Corn syrup is an invert sugar that has wonderful baking properties, which is why it is called for in recipes like this. You might try looking up corn syrup substitute in Google and seeing what people recommend. Or, as another commenter suggests in a Canadian recipe, you might substitute the corn syrup for maple syrup. If you do, add a couple more tablespoons of flour to the filling mix. ~Elise

    • anonymous

      If you’re interested in a no corn syrup recipe, I’ve been making one that just uses brown and white sugar (1.5 cups light brown, 1/2 cup white sugar). Google “Utterly Deadly Southern Pecan Pie” for the recipe. The only change is that I rarely use the cast iron skillet for a pan (did it once and it was great, but a pain to transport).

      Not meaning to compete with this one, sounds delicious! I just also don’t like to use corn syrup (and just don’t happen to have it around, unlike sugars).

  9. Leslie

    Hi! I love your website. It’s one of my goto’s for recipes and ideas. I loved this pecan pie when I made it, but because it has so little sugar, I garnished it with some coarsly chopped pecan pralines. it was WONDERFUL! I also added a dash of maple extract so that the pralines and pie would marry well (I use the extract6 in my praline mixture)

  10. katie

    I made this for Thanksgiving yesterday and it didn’t last the day. People went for seconds. Awesome and simple recipe.

  11. krista

    This pie is absolutely perfect. I don’t feel nearly as bad after eating a piece.

  12. Lynne

    This did turn out quite well. I think I overcooked it a bit so do watch it. I didn’t chop the pecans as they were small. I would make it again!

  13. Christian

    I liked the idea of having a less sweet pecan pie. I didn’t have quite enough corn syrup so I substituted in some sugar free pancake syrup, the pie came out wonderfully! My husband took it to work and the guys said pecan pie is too sweet to eat, but once they tried it, they were very impressed! I am passing this recipe on to other family members! Thank you for such an enjoyable recipe!!!!

  14. allyson

    I just wanted to add another thumbs up for this pie. I made it for my family last night (super easy!) and everyone Loved it. I Absolutely love that it’s not super sweet.

  15. arusha

    Can I substitute corn syrup with something else? We do not get corn syrup here.

    what is mollasses? please explain. how does it look?

    thanks

  16. Ajoa

    Hi Arusha,

    You can substitute corn syrup with golden syrup, and molasses with dark treacle.

  17. joann

    I have not been making pecan pie very long and every expierenced person says you must bake till it does not shake this drives me crazy , is this really true?

    Don’t know about that. My pecan pie wiggles a bit when I take it out of the oven, sort of like jello. I think a little wobble is to be expected. ~Elise

  18. Lori

    Pecan Pie:

    No doubt this recipe will produce a perfect pecan pie, but I have experimented and would like to share my recipe with others on this fabulous website. Here in Quebec, we are producers (and connesuoirs) of all sorts of maple products.

    Pecan Pie, Quebec-Style

    1 cup Grade A maple syrup*
    2 cups chopped pecan pieces
    4 level tbsp flour
    2 eggs, beaten
    1 tsp vanilla

    Whisk the syrup and flour together to get out the lumps. Add the remaining ingredients.

    Pour into a 9” shallow pie shell, whether homeade or bought.

    Bake at 350 degrees F for about 40 min. The filling should rise and when jiggled, the pie should feel solid. Extra attention should be made not to burn the pecans by over-baking.
    * inferior / lighter syrups won’t taste right-the syrup should be a golden brown colour

    Enjoy!!

  19. DawnsRecipes

    I can’t believe I haven’t commented on this recipe yet! I made this for my Dad last year at Thanksgiving and wanted to make it for him again. He loves pecan pie, and this has to be the best version there is! I’ll be making it for him again this year.

    Thanks!

  20. Denise

    I’ve never made a Pecan Pie, but have already printed this one out to make for Thanksgiving.
    I have this beautiful glass, fluted tart dish and was wondering if I could use that instead of a regular pie pan?

    As long as the glass is ceramic or pyrex, it should work. Un-tempered glass could more easily crack with the high oven temperatures. ~Elise

  21. Alaina

    WOW! I made your recipe instead of our usual pecan pie recipe that called for 2 cups sugar and 1/3 cup butter, and it made the world of difference in flavor. I didn’t realize all this time with my old recipe that I wasn’t tasting the pecans, all I was tasting was sugar! I give this recipe 5 stars, 6 if I could :)
    PS- it was such a hit at Thanksgiving I had to e-mail your URL to 3 people that fell in love with pecans all over again

  22. Christine

    Thanks for this recipe! It was easy and taste WONDERFUL! Big holiday hit.

  23. charlotte

    After having numerous tries at making a good pecan pie we happened on your recipe and made one and I must say it was the best we’ve ever made and is as good as any I’ve ever tasted. We only had the dark Karo and and it was very good. Can’t wait to make one with the light Karo to see if it comes out with a lighter colored filling. Thumbs up to anyone wanting to try this. If you can’t make a good one with this recipe you might want to try making a cake and give up on the pies.

  24. Carly

    I’ve made this pie for the past few years for Thanksgiving and Christmas for my family. It is, by far, the best pecan pie that any of us have ever had. I do add a tiny bit of dark rum along with the vanilla, which we all love. This pie is AMAZING!!!

  25. Ashley

    I know I am way late on posting but I made this pecan pie with my Husband in mind. He does not like super sweet pecan pie. To my surprise my Father raved about how it was as good as the pecan pie he remembered my Grandmother making.
    Later he told my older sister that hers was good but mine was better =)

  26. Trish

    Hi Elise,

    First off, GREAT pie. I made it today, and even my fiance (who claims to not like pecans) enjoyed it!

    That said, I noticed that mine was pretty shallow. Is that usual? I seem to remember the last one I baked being thicker, but that was four years ago.

    Hi Trish, it is a little shallow. If you do try increasing the filling ingredients, please let me know how it works out for you. ~Elise

  27. Dunja

    Super delicious Pecan Pie. I made this recipe last Thanksgiving and it was so awesome, best Pecan Pie I have ever had and I had a lot since I love them so much. Less sweet but real proof that less is more!

    Also, Lori, I will try your Quebec Pecan Pie, it sounds delicious and I love Maple syrup, I used to go to Vermont on vacation and they have great MS too!

    Another winner Elise, Thanks!

  28. Dunja

    Ok, follow up here. I made the “Quebec Pecan Pie” Lori suggested in this comment section and here are the results.
    IT was super easy to make and it baked great too. The flavor is great but where it comes in for me is the texture, I went exactly by the recipe instructions and the pie looks, smells, tastes great but the texture is a little like gummy. I prefer my PP rather creamy and moist and this one is rather firm and dry. But if you like the texture this way then this pie is a winner too. I think for my part I will stick with Elise’s PP recipe.

  29. Athina

    I have ALWAYS found pecan pie to be sickeningly sweet-not this recipe! The ingredients in this recipe enhance the flavor of the pecans greatly, and the result is a pecan pie to die for!!! You can actually taste the pecans- not that corn syrupy sweetness…

  30. Barbara Diner

    I am wondering if there is any modifications for this recipe to consider for baking it in high altitude?

    Hello Barbara, I do not bake at high altitude and do not have advice to give you on this subject. ~Elise

  31. Elizabeth

    For years we have made a pecan pie with no syrup. It is really good. The pecans just rise to the top.

    1 cup pecan halves
    1 lb (2 1/2 cups) brown sugar
    1/4 cup flour
    1/2 tsp. salt
    1 pie crust (either deep dish or 12″)
    1/2 cup milk
    1 1/2 tsp. vanilla
    3 eggs
    1 stick butter, melted

    Preheat oven to 325 degrees.

    Line pie crust with pecans. Combine sugars, flour and salt. Add milk, vanilla and butter. Beat at low speed. Add eggs 1 at a time. Pour into prepared crust.

    Bake 1 hr 15 minutes.

  32. Jennie

    WOW! This was the easiest pie to make (I made two at one time!)and it’s the prettiest pie I have ever made. Thanks! (Oh..and delicious)

  33. Kate

    Thanks for this recipe, Elise. It’s definitely a keeper. I made it when you first published it, last year, and this year. In fact, I just baked three of them.
    Happy thanksgiving and thanks for keeping me pecan-pie-happy.

  34. Sarah

    I finally have made a beautiful pie! This pie was so simple to make, yet the final result was superb. Delicious and just the right amount of sweetness. I brought it for Thanksgiving last month and it was a complete smash! Thanks for helping give me the appearance of being a fabulous baker and for boosting my confidence in the kitchen! :)

  35. MaryAlecia

    I love Lori, the Goddess who submitted the Quebec-style Pecan Pie recipe. It is the most amazing pie on the face of the planet. Everyone should make this pie. And I _KNOW_ that maple syrup is expensive right now, but it’s seriously worth it. Thank you so much!

  36. meliss

    If you put chocolate chips in there, or on top while it’s still warm if you’re not a big fan of all that sweetness, it is soooo delicious, like tollhouse pie!

  37. Chloe

    When I make pecan pies, they rise during the baking process but when I take them out of the oven, they cave in and look sunken. Any tips for keeping them plump and full when removed from the oven?

    Hi Chloe, what is making the pie plump is the leavening from the eggs in the pie filling. Like a soufflé, the filling when first baked will rise, and then fall as it cools. This is just normal, to be expected. ~Elise

  38. MB

    This was an absolute winner!! We do not have corn syrup where I live, so I replaced it with a cup of grade-A maple syrup, and it was SO delicious. I also used the recipe for the almond-flour crust – VERY good.
    This is by far the best thing I have EVER baked – and I bake a lot!

  39. gaby

    I made this for my dad’s birthday and it was superb! I also made the crust using the butter crust recipe suggested on this blog and it was also perfect. I would definitely make this pie again. yummy!! I love this website :)

  40. Alena

    I happened to have some karo and some blackstrap given to me by a cooking friend who moved. I was totally relieved to find a recipe that used such traditional ingredients! Only thing I had to buy was a crust, and viola! PIE!

  41. Sarah

    Has anyone tried substituting the corn syrup for maple syrup? I’ve never cooked with corn syrup and am wondering if they are similar enough to just make a straight substitution… Thanks!

    Corn syrup and maple syrup have different chemical properties, so in general you can’t substitute them without consequences. What the results would be in this case I don’t know. ~Elise

  42. Sarah

    Update: I went ahead and made this with maple syrup instead of corn syrup, omitted the molasses and added an extra egg – it turned out fantastic. Not too sweet, just the right amount of maple flavour, a nice twist on a classic.

  43. Michelle

    This recipe looks great. Can honey be substituted for corn syrup? I have a friend who has a corn allergy.

    No, honey cannot be substituted for corn syrup in this recipe. ~Elise

  44. MaryAlecia

    I love your blog, and refer to it often for new ideas. We’ve made the maple syrup version of the pecan pie two years in a row now. It’s absolutely amazing. This year i’ve added some freshly grated cinnamon, hand delivered from India! My boyfriend’s father has his own sugar bush, so we use his maple syrup, too. Only for the super special guests since it’s so much work to make! But any high quality syrup will do. It’s a fabulous recipe!

  45. Elizabeth

    I made this Pecan pie yesterday. Easy to put together. I cooked it for the exact time it needed & made sure the crust didn’t burn with putting foil on it. I took it out of the oven and the top is hard. Is it supposed to be like that?

    Yes, it’s supposed to be like that. Not all the way through of course, but the surface, especially since it’s covered with pecans, will likely be a little hard. ~Elise

  46. Lesley

    I made this pecan pie for Christmas and it was very well received. Several in my family said it was the best they’d ever had! Definitely one for the recipe box.

    After reading a few comments that the filling didn’t fill the 9-inch pie crust completely, I decided to increase all the filling ingredients by half (except the butter) and it turned out wonderfully in my 9.5-inch pie pan.

    Thanks for the wonderful recipe! Love your site.

  47. Nick

    I found that the molasses was a bad idea. I’m a college aged guy and I can say that I never tasted it before. The molasses smelled like pancake syrup but once baked, it was like burnt licorice. It smelled good but tasted like smokey pancake syrup.

    Although I may have burned it. (unlikey because the texture was great) I am fairly inexerienced in pie baking but I would suggest omitting the molasses. I tried it again without the flour and molasses and it was just like grandma’s.

    Good learning experience though. :)

  48. Joy Smith

    I have always hated the sickingly sweet taste of pecan pie and found your recipe, FINALLY! It turned out just wonderful! Thanks so much. And I don’t know why there are some here posting their sickingly sweet recipes, as if they can compete, sorry, this one wins hands down!

  49. KJohnson

    Let me just say…this was DELICIOUS! I have been playing around with your recipes and love every one of them!

  50. BarbDr

    I made this one last year for Thanksgiving, and it was such a hit I’m making it again this year. In my opinion the molasses is a perfect flavor for this pie, but then I love molasses.

  51. Priscilla

    Made the pie exactly as directed and it turned out GREAT! It’s so easy to make! Thank you for the great recipe!

  52. Becky

    I saw a recipe using Agave Nectar in place of corn syrup. I have not tried it yet, but it sounded like a good alternative.

  53. Brenda Scott

    I am so looking forward to making this pie for my step-son. I love pecan pie but since being a diabetic I am not allowed to eat this. But if anyone ever comes out with a tasty Pecan Pie for type 2 diabetes, I would love to have the recipe.

  54. Jim Price

    I like to sub 1 cup maple syrup for the corn syrup.

  55. Mom In The Sierras!

    Really delicious pie!!! Thank you so much!

  56. Kat Skinner

    For so many people without teeth but love pecan pie. I put about 3/4 of the pecans in a food processer until relatively fine & mix into the filling before baking, using the remaining pecans to decorate the pie. It requires no extra liquid & the flavor of the pecans is more intense– even those with teeth say it’s better that way.

  57. Sheila

    Was just wondering if you could mix half dark and half light syrup and the molasses..would it mess up texture?

    I don’t think it would change the texture. It will likely change the flavor though. Dark corn syrup will taste more of caramel. I’m guessing it will still be good. ~Elise

  58. Pia

    This pie is off the hook. so so good. I add a splash of bourbon and a handful of semi-sweet chocolate chips before I pour in the filling and people love it. Thanks for the recipe!

  59. Sheila

    Forgot to ask on other question. Would this be good to make the night before Thanksgiving? Should it go in the fridge over night? If so, can it be heated in the oven the next day or is it good cold?

    Yes, it is a great make-ahead pie. You should put it in the fridge overnight. You can let it come to room temp, or serve it chilled. ~Elise

  60. Teah Petersen

    This is too funny – I needed to find a pecan pie recipe and I thought Let me search for it on simply recipes…And it was the first post. Thank You So Much!!! I love your site and Pinch My Salt (which led me to you). You guys are fabulous! Hearts! (And lots of gratefulness for you!)

  61. Kelly

    I made this for Thanksgiving yesterday (a day in advance). This was my favorite item and the best pecan pie I have ever made. Thank you so much!

  62. Raney

    Well I have to say, you must like the taste of molasses to really enjoy this pie. It was stronger then I expected. Probably will go back to old recipe. Thanks anyway!

  63. Nicole

    This was my first attempt at a pecan pie from scratch (I followed the butter crust recipe as well) and it turned out great. I followed the advice of a reviewer and increased the filling recipe by 1/2. I think it would have been far too shallow for my 9 inch pie place otherwise, and would even consider doubling it in the future. It was definitely less sweet than the pecan pie I am accustomed to (although I have to say I do like the sickeningly sweet version just as well) and it was a hit at thanksgiving. I was surprised by how easy it was to make! Rolling out the dough for the crust and attempting to make it look attractive around the edges, was by far the most challenging part. Will use again when I am trying to please a crowd that may not appreciate the overly sweet taste of a more traditional pecan pie. I agree, the molasses taste is evident so if you are not a fan, this pie may not be for you.

  64. Johanna

    I made this pecan pie for Thanksgiving last week and it turned out beautifully and tasted great! I’ve had horrible success with pecan pie in the past, they have never turned out well for some reason. Being that pecan is my husband’s favorite pie I tried again and am glad I did. Thanks!

  65. Jeanne

    Can this be made with a grahm cracker crust?

    I don’t see why not. ~Elise

  66. Laurie

    This looks delicious!! Do you think it would be okay to add some chocolate chips to the mix?

    Sure, why not? ~Elise

  67. Danielle

    This is the best pecan pie recipe. I am not much of a baker but this pie turned out perfectly the 1st and 2nd times made. I love it because it’s not teeth-hurting sweet. Instead you get to enjoy the flavor of the pecans. I lived in MS for 3 years and this most closely resembles the delicious homemade pie Miss Bell, our neighbor with her own pecan tree, would make for us.

    Thanks for sharing the recipe. It’s already a family favorite.

  68. Lisa

    I use organic brown rice syrup as a substitute for corn syrup — it is delicious and works well.

  69. Jed

    Just served this for Christmas. It was fantastic, a big improvement on the standard Pecan Pie recipe.

  70. alicia

    made this for christmas dessert. it was easy to make, not too sweet, and simply delicious! i typically do not like pecan pie, but your recipe was delicious!

    thank you!

  71. Barb

    I am always interested in different versions of pecan pie and I like the idea of a not-so-sweet pie. I don’t have molasses, however, so if I leave it out do I need to add anything in its place? I do plan to add some chocolate chips since that’s the only way my kids will eat pecan pie.

    Molasses is what gives brown sugar its flavor. So if you don’t have any molasses, make sure your are using dark brown sugar, and then up the amount of sugar by 2 or 3 tablespoons. ~Elise

  72. Nikki

    Agave syrup makes an excellent substitute for corn syrup if you want to use a healthier sweetener.

  73. Daisy

    Delicious and easy to put together. For the second pie I ran out of light corn syrup so I replaced the corn syrup AND the molasses with ALAGA cane syrup and it was also very tasty.

  74. Kelly

    Perfect! This was the first pecan pie I have ever made and got rave reviews. I only used a scant tablespoon of molasses so the flavor would be a bit more subtle. Thanks for a great pie, Elise!

  75. Angie

    My girlfriend wanted me to show her how to make a pecan pie so I pulled this recipe to use. I am not a big pecan pie fan normally but this is an amazing recipe. It is absolutely perfect as is and I would not substitute one thing in your recipe. I loved it.

  76. Jen

    Great recipe! I am now on a mission to find a pecan pie cake recipe. Can anyone help me out?

  77. ToniLynn

    Easy peasy pie and wonderful! I love molasses, so this recipe caught my eye. So glad it did…my mom’s pecan pie was always my favorite, but this one is a little better (sorry, Mom!). Thanks for the yummy recipe.

  78. katy

    I tried to make this pie and the top got hard, but the inside was runny before it cooled… Did I do something wrong?

    You should let it cool all the way, it should firm up once cooled. ~Elise

  79. Ana

    This was my first time baking a pecan pie and I was a little nervous, but once I did it, I realized there is nothing to be nervous about. This is the easiest pie I’ve ever baked! Well, I couldn’t wait for the pie to cool completely, so after I took it out of the oven, I started cutting slice for myself but I quickly realized that I HAD to wait for it to cool down. Just as word of advice for anyone who is going to bake a pecan pie for the first time, let the pie cool completely (even though it will be a great tease to smell and see the pie sitting there). If you cut the pie right away after taking it out of the oven, the top layer of the pie will be hard and browned but the inside will be runny (don’t worry, the batter is cooked fully through). The pie inside just needs to cool down and harden a little bit. This pecan pie was the best pie I ever had, and I will never have to look for another recipe again.

  80. srah

    I’d like to make this for Thanksgiving. How well does this pie “keep”? Do you think if I made it Tuesday night it would still be good by Thursday?

    Usually we make our Thanksgiving pies (including this pecan pie) one day ahead. But I think you could make this two days ahead without a problem. ~Elise

  81. Jen

    I’m going to attempt to make this, but am a little nervous of the results because of the prior comments about the pronounced molasses flavor, esspecially because all I have is blackstrap molasses… which is alot more robust then light molasses. Maybe I should replace with maple sugar to stay on the safe side? I’m baking this for a all-time pecan pie lover and hoping for the results to be better than any pecan pie they’ve ever tasted, but not sure about the whole molasses factor. What would you suggest I do? I really like this recipe because of the lessoned amount of sugar.

    The pie filling only uses one tablespoon of molasses. If you are concerned about the flavor, why don’t you cut it down to one teaspoon? You can increase the corn syrup by 2 teaspoons then. Just don’t use molasses AND maple syrup. It will be a waste of maple syrup. Its more delicate flavor may be overwhelmed by even a smaller amount of molasses. ~Elise

  82. Hannah

    Just ate my first piece and WOW! Just what I was looking for…my mom and I wanted a pie full of pecans and without that standard layer of goo and this is it. Like the others have commented it’s not overtly sweet (thankfully) but absolutely divine with a scoop of ice cream. I made it with the butter crust that I am now obsessed with (since I discovered this site with the rustic onion tart)and it did seem to saturate the middle of the pie’s crust but it stood to the transfer to the plate and then my mouth! You’re the Best Thanks!

  83. Kym

    I am trying to make this for the first time and I was wondering if you could sub the butter for margarine? Will it have the same effect and flavor?

    I don’t cook with margarine, so don’t know what to tell you. ~Elise

  84. April G.

    I halved this recipe to make mini pies in a muffin tin. I didn’t have vanilla so used bourbon. I only made 6 mini pies, but there was enough filling left to do 12. Just in case anyone wants to try the same thing!

    I haven’t tried them yet but they smell amazing!

  85. Kristi

    Thanksgiving hit! Served this to picky in-laws yesterday, and noticed they kept the other half of the pie for themselves when sending home the leftovers! I like everything healthier, so made these changes (but didn’t tell my meat and potato loving in-laws):
    -increased pecans to 2 cups
    -substituted brown rice syrup for the corn syrup
    -used whole wheat pastry flour
    -substituted evaporated cane juice (unrefined granulated sugar) for brown sugar
    -increased molasses to 1.5 tablespoons (because of the sugar substitution)
    Next time I will try to make it vegan by substituting olive oil for the butter and whipped flax meal/water for the eggs. The pecans and molasses have such great flavor, I’m sure it will work! Thank you!

  86. Caitlin

    This pie was amazing :) I recieved so many compliments on it! Thank you for sharing!

  87. Alecia

    OMG this recipe was so simple and O SO Good! My husband is going to eat the whole thing by himself.

  88. Tucker

    This recipe is amazing. I made it 2 times so far, and everyone loves it. I’m making a third one today for a holiday party, and probably another one for Christmas. Very, very simple as well.

  89. arunie

    Will the crust get soggy if I don’t pre-bake it?
    thanks,
    A

    We have not had a problem with soggy-ness. ~Elise

  90. onyi

    I have never made a pecan pie but looking forward to making one. I went browsing the internet looking “my” perfect recipe, one that recommends less sweetness and i found your. I am eager to try it…however, can i make it without egg or less egg because the smell of egg in pasteries put me off

    This recipe requires egg. ~Elise

  91. Rose Guieb

    Would it be ok to use a pre-made graham cracker crust. I dont like the crust of traditional pies.

    That would be worth a try. If you do try it, please let us know how it turns out for you. I love graham-cracker crusts. ~Elise

  92. Maria

    Just wondering if using a frozen pie crust, do you need to bake it first, or will it bake with the pie?

    No, you do not pre-bake the crust for this pie recipe. ~Elise

  93. sandra

    Help….my pecan pie filling keeps coming out soupy….any suggestions?

    Make sure you are using real, fresh eggs, not an egg substitute. And don’t forget the flour. Measure all ingredients well. ~Elise

  94. Raishah

    Hi Elise,

    this looks amazing!
    just wanted to know if i need to toast the pecans first?

    thx!

    • Elise

      Hi Raishah, no, no need to toast the pecans first. They’ll get toasted enough in the oven when you cook the pie!

      • Raishah

        thanks, Elise! i made this the other day for my friend’s do and it was a BIG hit! real easy to make and super tasty! <3 will be making this again :)

  95. J

    I made this for Thanksgiving 2013! It has been requested this year! Excellent recipe!!

  96. Leslie

    I love pecan pie, it’s my favorite. My grandma would make me the small pies when I was little. That looks tasty.

  97. Steve

    My recipe is actually pretty similar; same idea to cut the sweetness. I would suggest browning the butter. I’ve also added 1/2 teaspoon of apple cider vinegar, which is the secret ingredient in Food Network’s best pie recipe

  98. Sarah

    This has been my go to recipe for the past few years for pecan pie! My family absolutely loves it. That being said, I noticed that the photos and look of this page have changed since the last time I was here. The recipe listed didn’t change did it? I wish I had written it down or printed it out, now. Also, You used to have a link to a different pie crust which had become my favorite. Could you please share that link again? Thanks so much for any assistance!

    • Elise

      Hi Sarah, I didn’t think the pie had enough filling in it, so I increased the overall amount of filling. As for the pie crust, I am recommending the sour cream pie crust these days because it’s so flaky and good, and hard to mess up! The original pie crust recipe I recommended was this one: http://www.simplyrecipes.com/recipes/all_butter_crust_for_sweet_and_savory_pies_pate_brisee/ It’s also an excellent pie crust recipe, but it can take a bit of practice to master.

      • Sarah

        Thanks Elise! That is the one I was talking about. :) As long as the new recipe tastes the same (and there is even more of the filling), I’m all for it. I’m also printing it and adding it to my actual cookbook now.

  99. Emily @ Life on Food

    My mom is allergic to nuts so I grew up never experiencing pecan pie. Now it is one of my favorites.

  100. Samantha

    Is there a substitute for the corn syrup? Please!?

    • Elise

      Hello Samantha, if you read the comments you’ll find several that people have left who have substituted other ingredients for the corn syrup.

Post a comment

Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.

Some HTML is OK. URLs are automatically converted to links. Line breaks are automatically converted to paragraphs. The following HTML tags are allowed: a, abbr, acronym, b, blockquote, cite, code, del, em, i, q, strike, strong