15 Comments

  1. Cindy Su

    I was looking at another lamb stew recipe and so “accidentally” bought lamb shank instead of lamb shoulder but actually it turned out really delicious! The marrow in the lamb shank bones added quite a bit of flavor, so I’m happy for the “mistake”!

  2. Kira

    I made this fabulous stew recipe and added a roasted green pepper and used Ancho and Chipotle chili instead of smoked paprika and red pepper flakes for a more smokey Southwest flavor. I added just a hint of cinnamon too. Delish!

    Thanks Elise ~ this is just what I was looking for ~ a lamb stew with butternut squash. Love your website. One of my favorite recipes is your Dad’s Fisherman Stew. It’s quick and super tasty.

  3. Vicky

    Thought that I had some lamb for stew, but didn’t. So I made this with pork stew meat instead. The only other change that I made was to double the amount of garbanzo beans cuz we are big fans. It was delicious the first day, and amazing the second day! It was a great send-off for the last butternut squash from our CSA. Thanks, Elise.

  4. kimberly

    Made this last week. Didn’t have mint but followed the rest of the recipe. Everyone loved it – will definitely be repeating this one during the winter.

  5. Hannah

    Thanks Elise, this inspired me yesterday (I’m incapable of actually following a recipe!), and was delicious with cinnamon instead of mint.

  6. Alaska Girl

    Can I make this with caribou or moose instead of lamb?

    Why not? If you try it, let us know how it turns out. ~Elise

  7. Deb

    What can I substitute for the Garbanzo Beans, my husband is allergic, maybe white beans?

    Sounds good to me. ~Elise

  8. Sandy

    Thanks so much for this recipe. I made it yesterday and it was very tasty.

  9. Julie

    I made this for dinner tonight (only I have to admit I used pork stew meat since that was what I had on hand). I’m currently living in Germany and it is pretty easy to come by pork stew meat here! I also substituted curry for the cayenne (again, what I had on hand) and served the stew over batsami rice. We all enjoyed it and found that the longer it sat the better it tasted!

  10. Elise

    Hi Mina,

    That should have been perfect. There is much more flavor when the pieces are bone-in. And by the time the cooking is done the meat should be falling off the bone.


    Notice: Undefined variable: post in /web/sites/simplyrecipes.com/wp-content/themes/simply/lib/ads.php on line 397

    Notice: Trying to get property of non-object in /web/sites/simplyrecipes.com/wp-content/themes/simply/lib/ads.php on line 397
  11. Mina

    OHHHHHHHh. We had the butcher cut the lamb shoulder and he left it on the bone — and there wasn’t that much meat to cut off the bone so we left it on and cooked it that way. I don’t think it was as good. But it is pretty tasty!

  12. Elise

    Hi Mina,

    Leave some meat on the bones, cut the rest into 1-inch cubes, make sure you cook both the meat and the bones as much flavor comes out of those bones.

  13. Mina Y.

    Do you cut the lamb into cubes and leave it on the bone?

  14. Rachel

    Mmm, I tried this last night and it was wonderful! I think I put a bit too much cayenne in there (it was HOT) but I happen to like it that way. :-) Thanks for sharing. I LOVE your website.

  15. Andrea Middleton

    Hey, what about interpreting this recipe for a slow cooker? Any ideas?

Post a comment

Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.