Buying Guides

Best Baking Subscription Boxes

Homemade Bakers Club is our top choice

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Close up of a baker making bread with olives in it

Peter Dazeley / Getty Images

Nothing beats homemade fresh baked goods and dessert, but the vast choices of what to make can seem overwhelming. In addition, sometimes you don’t have all the ingredients for the baked goods or simply want something different.

Joining a baking subscription box service solves all that by offering you frequent recipes on a rotating basis along with all the pre-measured ingredients. Think of it like a meal kit, but with delightful baked goods as the outcome instead. Continue reading for our top recommendations.

Best Baking Subscription Boxes of 2021

Best Overall: Homemade Bakers Club

Homemade Bakers Club

Homemade Bakers Club

Why We Chose It: This service offers warm and friendly seasonal recipes that are accessible and familiar but still have variety to keep them interesting long term.

Pros
Video tutorial for each recipe
Reasonably priced
Ability to substitute with cinnamon rolls

Cons
Seasonal recipes require more perishable items

If you are new to baking subscription boxes, look no further than the fun and creative Homemade Bakers Club, which offers a monthly subscription box with all the shelf-stable ingredients needed to make baked goods. Homemade Bakers Club is one of the only companies that has a video on its website for each recipe, making it stand out for user-friendliness. Expect a box filled with most of the ingredients needed for your treats, as well as the recipe itself with baking tips and equipment like parchment paper, toothpicks, cupcake liners, and other products to help with your baking. You do need to provide perishable items like eggs, butter, milk, and fruit for some recipes. But you’ll be sent reminder emails two to three times throughout the month to let you know what ingredients you need to pick up at the grocery store.

Past baked goods offered in the club include coconut cream pie cupcakes, peach cobbler cookies, mint cheesecake brownies, peppermint bark fudge cookies, and pineapple upside-down cake. If you don’t like one month’s offering, you can always skip the month or swap out the item with the club's signature cinnamon roll kit.

Monthly subscriptions start at $28.95 if you pay month-to-month, with cheaper options if you prepay for three, six, or 12 months.

Best for Kids: Baketivity

Baketivity

Baketivity

Why We Chose It: Baketivity specifically gears its recipes and instructions for kids and families, so everyone can join in on the fun.

Pros
Kid-friendly recipes
Illustrated, step-by-step instructions
Educational component

Cons
Slightly pricier for what you get
Recipes aren’t super adventurous

If you have little ones that are interested in baking, Baketivity is the best baking box for your family. Each box is specified geared toward kids aged 4 to 10 with fun recipes and colorful, step-by-step instructions. All ingredients pre-measured out and vacuum-sealed for freshness. Each box also includes mini educational lessons to keep your child occupied while the baked goods are in the oven. And each subscription comes with a kid-sized chef hat and apron.

Past baking projects included granola bars, cake pops, chocolate chunk cookies, cinnamon buns, whoopie pie, bagels, and red velvet cupcakes. Expect seasonal recipes during the holidays like peppermint trifles, gingerbread cookies, and cinnamon snickerdoodles. Baketivity even offers a special virtual summer baking camp, which includes a live Zoom class and four baking kits during July and four different baking kits for the month of August.

Monthly subscriptions start at $32.95 if you pay month-to-month, with less expensive options if you subscribe for three, six, or 12 months.

Best Guilt-Free Baking: Foodstirs

Foodstirs

Foodstirs

Why We Chose It: Foodstirs offers baking projects with less sugar and sustainable, organic, NON-GMO ingredients.

Pros
Less sugar, organic ingredients
Fun projects
Reasonably priced

Cons
Recipes tend to be less sophisticated
Kits are customized box mixes

Desserts inherently aren’t the best thing for you. But you can feel a little better about your treats when you pick Foodstirs. Each baking box has a baking mix filled with sustainable, organic, NON-GMO fair-trade ingredients with nothing artificial. And it uses a unique sweetener blend of natural ingredients so each recipe uses 25 percent less sugar than comparable baked goods. Each box comes with the baking mix and frosting mix, as well as any specialty equipment like a cookie cutter, piping bag and tips, reusable silicone baking pan, and plant-based dye and/or sprinkles packets.

Foodstirs' subscription box comes every two months and is one of the more budget-friendly subscriptions. The recipes are geared toward kids or nostalgic kid-at-heart adults. The 2021 schedule for boxes includes unicorn treat pops, donuts, sandy surfboard sugar cookies, rainbow pancakes, spooky spider whoopie pie, and snowflake swirl donuts. Past boxes have included Sparkly Apple Bites, Pumpkin Spice Cookie Sandwiches, and Pancake Art.

Bimonthly subscriptions start at $25.99 if you pay for one kit, with lower-cost options if you prepay for three or six kits.

Best for Cookies: Fresh Baked Cookie Crate

Fresh Baked Cookie Crate

Fresh Baked Cookie Crate

Why We Chose It: If cookies are all you want to bake (and who can blame you?) then Fresh Baked Cookie Crate, with its unique cookie recipes, is the baking box for you.

Pros
Creative and unique cookie recipes
Includes a silicone baking mat
Add on “fun surprises” bonus

Cons
Cookie recipes may not appeal to everyone

Fresh-baked cookies are often the first thing we all learn to bake. So, it only makes sense that you might want to subscribe to an all cookie baking box service. Fresh Baked Cookie Crate delivers these sweet goods via monthly kits for innovative and creative cookies. Each box comes with all the pre-measured ingredients vacuum sealed for freshness with a focus on artisan and organic ingredients. The boxes will yield 24, 2-inch cookies, though you can upgrade to the four dozen cookie box if you prefer bigger batches. You can also upgrade the box for an extra $5 to 10 to get surprises with two or three cookie-themed items like cookie scented candles, fun t-shirts, kitchen supplies, or bath products, making the kit a great gift. These upgrades include products worth $50 or more.

Past cookies boxes have included Nutella apple butter Linzer cookies, honey roasted peanut butter cup cookies, carrot cake sandwich cookies, banana nut bread cookies, candied bacon chocolate chip cookies, and crème brulee cookies. Shipping is free and all boxes are created and shipped immediately to ensure freshness. Skipping a month is easy by sending an email.

Monthly subscriptions start at $29.99 if you pay month-to-month, with less expensive options if you prepay for three, six, or 12 months.

Best for Bread Baking: Breadista

Breadista

Breadista

Why We Chose It: Bread baking is a specific form of baking different from desserts, and Breadista’s delivers with all the crusty goodness you want for bakery-style bread at home.

Pros
Homemade, fresh-baked bread
Boxes include jams and extras
Organic ingredients when possible

Cons
More pricey than traditional baking subscriptions

Baking bread can seem like a daunting task for the novice, but Breadista solves this by offering up monthly bread baking boxes focusing on European-style bread. Included in each box is the bread baking mix with pre-measured ingredients (along with the yeast) for the specific loaf or roll of bread, as well as step-by-step instructions. Breadista tries to use organic ingredients whenever possible. You’ll also get baking paper, a jar of jam or preserves, plus a bonus gift like a cutting board, tote bag, or serrated knife. Most recipes only call for water as an addition, though a few will need other basic pantry staples like olive oil or butter.

Past bread offered in the club includes Dinkelweck (a German spelt roll), Wurzelbrot (a rustic type bread), Almweck (a German rye and spice bread), Goldkruste (a whole wheat bread filled with flax and sesame seeds), Kantonsbrot (a classic Swiss loaf), and Fougasse (a French herb bread).

Monthly subscriptions start at $44.90 for a one-month subscription, with cheaper options if you sign up for three or six months,

Best Patisserie: Red Velvet NYC

Red Velvet NYC

Red Velvet NYC

Why We Chose It: Red Velvet NYC has boxes and recipes that yield sophisticated patisserie-style desserts, all made in your own home.

Pros
Recipes are sophisticated and beautiful
Two boxes a month

Cons
Some recipes require advanced baking skills
No discount for longer, prepaid subscriptions

If you’re adventurous in the kitchen and want to stretch yourself a bit, Red Velvet NYC is the baking box subscription for you. The recipes cover beginner, moderate, and advanced baking projects. The resulting baked goods are something you would find at a fancy gourmet patisserie and are Pinterest/Instagram worthy. Kits include nearly every ingredient needed for the project except for eggs. However, you will need some specialty baking equipment for these projects, all of which are listed on the website for the recipe. You can also purchase most of the equipment from Red Velvet NYC. The recipe for each kit is also available on the website.

Past baked goods offered in the club include molten lava cake, French macarons with raspberry preserves, flourless chocolate pecan cookies, chocolate chip cookies with EVOO and sea salt, coconut macaroons with ruby chocolate, matcha swirl cookies, chai spiced Bundt cake with cinnamon streusel, and crème brulee. Each box is also available individually and the skill level is listed for the baking project.

Monthly subscriptions on the website start at $49 for two boxes with an option to cancel or skip anytime.

Final Verdict

Baking subscription boxes are a fun choice for folks who want to bake new things every month but don’t know what to bake, how to bake, or just want homemade fresh baked goods with minimal effort. We recommend Homemade Bakers Club because its recipes are creative and easy to make. Its online tutorials make baking accessible for everyone, and the ability to swap out cinnamon rolls for a monthly box gives flexibility that other subscription services do not have.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do Baking Subscription Boxes Work?

Baking subscription boxes are ingredient baking kits that arrive at your home on a regular basis, often monthly and sometimes twice a month, depending on the company. Each kit contains most of the ingredients as well as the instructions for a baking project. Most kits require you to provide some perishable items like eggs, butter, or milk.

What Typically Comes in a Baking Subscription Box?

Baking subscription boxes include pre-measured ingredients for the baking project and step-by-step instructions and a description and additional information about the recipe. Some baking subscription boxes come with bonus content and gifts like aprons, baking mats, parchment paper for your project, or a jar of jam.

How Much Do Baking Subscription Boxes Cost?

The typical baking subscription box ranges in price from $26 to $45, with most running about $30 per month.

Are Baking Subscription Boxes Worth It? 

You can easily spend more than $30 on raw ingredients to bake something, though you also often will have left ingredients to use for future projects. If you love to bake but don't have the time to find a recipe or grocery shop, then baking subscription boxes are definitely worth it. But if you are an experienced baker with a pantry full of baking ingredients, baking subscription boxes might not be worth it for you.

Methodology

We researched numerous articles, reviews, and companies across the internet to find the best baking subscription boxes. A number of criteria came into play, including the type of recipes offered, flexibility in subscription, range of baked goods available each month, ease of using the kit, and the creativity involved in each recipe. A big element in deciding this list was a particular “wow” factor when looking at the resulting baked goods, both on the company site and their social media feed to see customers' final products.

Continue to 5 of 6 below.