Best Meat Subscription Boxes

Butcher Box is our top pick

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Composite of a piece of steak with spices and a rosemary sprig.

Simply Eats / Designed by Amelia Manley

Getting high-quality meat delivered right to your door is something that was out of reach just a few years ago. But these days, dozens of companies offer meat delivery services and subscription boxes. It can actually be hard to wade through the options.

We've taken a deep dive to find some of the best meat subscription boxes out there so you can choose one that works for you.

Best Meat Subscription Boxes of 2021

Best Overall: Butcher Box

Butcher Box

Butcher Box

Why We Chose It: Butcher Box offers high-quality meats in a variety of cuts and sizes and delivers that meat via subscriptions.

Pros
100 percent grass-fed, grass-finished beef
Regular, scheduled deliveries
Boxes combine favorites and new offerings
Easy to adjust plans

Cons
Not easy to select what's in each box
Can’t order less than 8–9 pounds at a time

Butcher Box is a meat delivery service that offers high-quality meat in a few preset box sizes. You can also make a custom box and customize delivery times to fit your needs. It offers everything from ground beef to filet mignon and also includes wild-caught seafood, humanely raised pork, and organic chicken.

Butcher Box subscriptions range in price, but the classic subscription box offers 8–11 pounds of meat, or about 24 meals, for $129. For a little extra money each month, you can order the custom box to get more flexibility in the meats you receive. You can upgrade or downgrade your subscription at any point and add some basic customizations to your box of meat, although the best value is found by having flexible options.

Butcher Box ships your meat flash-frozen in eco-friendly boxes that are designed to keep it at the perfect temperature until you transfer it to your fridge or freezer. While the company's product offerings are less than some of the other companies featured here, it offers great value for the quality and reliable delivery with solid customer reviews.

Best Organic: Greensbury

Greensbury

Greensbury

Why We Chose It: If you’re looking for organic meat delivered to your door, you can’t go wrong with Greensbury, which has a wide range of high-quality meats in completely customizable and preset packages.

Pros
100 percent organic meat and seafood
Offers subscriptions and one-off purchases
Variety of special offerings

Cons
Price is a little higher than other services
Number of options can be a bit overwhelming

Founded in 2007, Greensbury offers individual packages that you can purchase down to individual cuts. You can also bundle items together for savings or sign up for its subscription options to save even more. The only way to order Greensbury is through its website, and there is a 10 percent discount on your first order.

Beyond individual groceries, the packs are where the true value is. The Whole30 Meal Planner Pack is priced at $129 with the aforementioned discount and is very popular, offering about 10 pounds of organic meat. For shipping, Greensbury flash-freezes and vacuum-packs its products for best deliverability and ships them in eco-friendly packaging. That packaging ensures that the meat will keep well in your freezer for up to 12 months.

Company founder Todd Horowitz has been in the meat and seafood industry for decades, and the company has excellent customer reviews.

Best for Meat and Seafood: Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks

Why We Chose It: Omaha Steaks has been providing high-quality meat and seafood for 100 years.

Pros
Wide variety of options for both meat and seafood
Combination packages available
Long history of quality

Cons
Not all organic
Tracing the source can be difficult

Omaha Steaks has evolved over the years and now offers a wide range of products beyond just beef. It is a family-run business with deep roots in cattle raising. There is a wide assortment of choices, with everything from ground beef to premium cuts, and all sorts of seafood options such as lobster and salmon.

While you can order individual steaks or cuts from Omaha Steaks, the company does encourage you to bundle items together to save money and map out a full meal plan. That means you can couple steaks with some seafood and even some sides like potatoes au gratin for a really special meal. For example, the Ultimate Family Surf & Turf is $174.99 and contains four filet mignons, four Maine lobster tail halves, four hash browns, seasoning, and four individual cheesecake samplers.

Omaha Steaks delivers frozen meat and offers free shipping on most packages.

Best Exotic Meat: Fossil Farms

Fossil Farms

Fossil Farms

Why We Chose It: Fossil Farms has an amazing selection of exotic, fun, and delicious meats.

Pros
Large selection of exotic meats, from kangaroo to yak
Discovery box option for in-season meat
Prepared foods available

Cons
Expensive cuts of beef

Fossil Farms is a true pioneer in finding sustainable options beyond cattle and red meat, offering quality, farm-raised wild game, game birds, and exotic meats. Beyond supplying restaurants, it ships directly to consumers as well.

Fossil Farms offers a wide range of options for buying its meat. You can purchase individual cuts, which can be on the pricier side due to the exotic nature of the meats, or try the discovery boxes, which include a range of items. You lose the option to completely customize it, but you get some really fun mixes of products. A one-time purchase of a discovery box costs $250, or you can save a bit if you subscribe to a multi-box subscription.

You can place your order on the company’s website or over the phone. Meat is flash-frozen and delivered via UPS.

Best for Cured Meats: Carnivore Club

Carnivore Club

Carnivore Club

Why We Chose It: Carnivore Club is a subscription service that focuses on cured meats and charcuterie board offerings.

Pros
Rotating boxes of high-quality charcuterie
Good price point for charcuterie
Rabid fanbase of charcuterie lovers

Cons
Limited offerings
Company history not detailed online

A subscription service just for cured meats? Yes, please. Carnivore Club offers two basic subscriptions: The Classic Box can be ordered one-time or on a subscription model for about $40 per box, while the Snack Box is a fun option that substitutes in cured meat snacks like beef jerky for about $30 per box. You can also order some items a la carte, but the boxes are the most popular items that Carnivore Club offers.

Carnivore Club has a strong online following. Everything is shipped fresh, not frozen, and prices are lower than other meat subscription services. Beyond the boxes, Carnivore Club encourages gifting its products. And, it sells the accessories needed to make a great charcuterie board like cutting boards and knives.

Best for Gifts: Holy Grail Steak Co.

Holy Grail

Holy Grail

Why We Chose It: For meat lovers, Holy Grail offers some truly special offerings such as wagyu beef.

Pros
Incredible quality and interesting offerings
Blog gives tips on cooking steak

Cons
Expensive
Not for everyday meals

Holy Grail gives consumers access to some of the most premium cuts of meat out there. Many of these cuts, like mouth-watering wagyu beef, are generally only available at top-tier steakhouses.

To keep these steaks in top shape during shipping, Holy Grail uses a vacuum seal method for sealing and freezing them at -30 degrees Fahrenheit to ensure there’s no degradation of quality. The shop offers free shipping on any order over $200.

These steaks are expensive, but they’re great for gifting or for special occasions.

Final Verdict

There are many options when choosing a meat subscription service, and the best one depends on your needs. For consistent quality and delivery, it’s hard to beat Butcher Box’s offerings. These boxes offer competitive pricing and you are getting top-quality meat. If you are looking to customize your meat deliveries more than what Butcher Box offers, check out Greensbury, which allows you to really pick and choose some of the options for delivery.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do Meat Subscription Boxes Ship Fresh Meat?

Meat subscription boxes almost all ship flash-frozen meat, which is essential to ensuring that the meat retains its quality. Once at your home, the meat should be transferred immediately to your freezer for longer storage or you can thaw it in the fridge for use right away. Depending on the company and products you order, there are slightly different storage and thawing instructions.

How Much Do Meat Subscription Boxes Cost?

The cost of meat subscription boxes varies greatly from $40 per month to several hundred dollars for some gift boxes. If you are looking to feed a family, you can normally find a subscription box that contains many meals for less than $10 per meal. That might mean an upfront cost of a few hundred dollars, but you’ll have quality meat for a few weeks.

Are Meat Subscription Boxes Worth It?

There are some packages that offer high-quality meat that might not be available in your area, so it can absolutely be worth it to get quality meat delivered to your door. That said, some delivery companies pad their offerings with items like chicken breasts, which can be just as easily purchased at a grocery store.

Are Meat Subscription Boxes Sustainable?

Companies that ship meat are laser-focused on ensuring they are doing so in a sustainable way. Packaging is almost always recyclable and some companies even offer compostable shipping for easy reuse.

Methodology

We researched 20 meat subscription boxes and considered the products they offer, pricing, and customer reviews. Packaging, shipping costs, and sustainability were also taken into account before we pared down the options to the companies on our list.

Continue to 5 of 6 below.