Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
The global popularity of takeout and delivery pizza can’t be overstated, as countless people make these cheesy, saucy pies regular elements of their dining rotation. However, plenty of serious pizza fanatics instead choose to make their own versions at home, which gives them total control over the ingredients, the sauce-to-cheese-to-toppings ratio, and the overall quality of this beloved treat.
Creating your own pizza doesn’t require much in terms of specialty equipment. Aside from a well-calibrated oven or grill, you’ll just need a high-quality pizza stone to ensure even heat distribution and your preferred level of char. Don't think of pizza stones as a unitasker though—they come in handy for making bread and other baked goods, and some can also be used as a griddle.
These top pizza stones represent the best of the category, and we’ve pointed out exactly what makes each version worth it.
Best Overall: Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan
If you’re shopping for cast iron, then you really can’t do better than a Lodge product. This brand has been in the cast iron game since the late 19th century, and its skillets and pans boast such long-lasting strength that they’re regularly passed down from generation to generation.
Cast iron excels at heat retention and a preheated pan will ensure a crisp crust without inopportune burnt spots, so it makes sense that a cast iron baking pan would amply succeed at the delicate art of pizza-making. This 14-inch baking pan provides enough space for even a large, or unevenly shaped, homemade pie. The cast iron both allows the top and interior of the pizza to cook evenly, and pulls away moisture from the dough, which leaves you with a crisp and beautifully charred crust.
The pan comes pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, so you’ll be able to get to work on your pizza project as soon as it arrives. Also, this features loop handles on either side, which gives you the opportunity to easily slide the pizza in and out of the oven without risking a nasty burn.
Best Overall, Runner-Up: Solido #1 Pizza Stone
Rectangular pizza stones prove useful for shoppers with smaller ovens or unusually shaped ovens, and Solido’s #1 Pizza Stone is frequently lauded as one of the very best versions.
Cordierite stone, a mineral famous for its ability to withstand high levels of heat without causing thermal shock, serves as the #1 Pizza Stone’s key ingredient. Also, Solido designs these pizza stones with a "heat spiral” on the bottom. This is a piece of internal construction that allows the pizza stone to heat faster. and to cook the inside of the pizza dough and the toppings at the center of the pie without singing the exterior crust or the toppings on the perimeter.
In addition to the oven, this 14 x 16-inch pizza stone, which weighs 13 pounds, can also be used on your outdoor grill since it can handle temperatures up to 1,150 degrees. The stone does need to be wiped down after use and never left to soak in the sink.
Best Budget: Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper Pizza Pan
Fans of crispy, thin-crust pizza, with its high level of crunch and little doughiness to speak of, will find their perfect pizza stone match in the Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper Pizza Pan
This lightweight, perforated steel pan can easily replace a classic pizza stone. The 14-inch pizza pan features a lowered center with raised lip, which prevents dough and toppings from sliding around and potentially leaking into your oven. The holes allow heat to reach the bottom crust, giving you the perfectly crispy slice.
Also, the Wilton pan is a highly effective tool for cooking frozen pizzas in terms of its shape, size, and heat conductivity. Reviewers celebrate the pan for its relatively easy cleaning capacity. It can be put in the dishwasher, though Wilton recommends hand washing to protect the nonstick coating.
Best High-End: All-Clad Specialty 2-Piece Pizza Stone
All-Clad’s professional-caliber cookware products hold positions of high esteem among enthusiastic home cooks and career chefs alike, and this attractively and cleverly designed pizza stone is no exception to that rule.
This 2-piece set consists of a 13-inch round pizza stone made of natural soapstone and a stainless-steel carrying tray. The pizza stone itself disperses even, thorough heat and leaves the crust with an enviably crisp bottom and edges. The stainless tray with two handles allows you to easily transport the stone (and, of course, the pizza) to the table.
If you’d rather not grapple with a knife and a serving spatula when you’re ready to dig into your pie, then you’ll appreciate the included All-Clad pizza cutter.
Best for the Grill: Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone
Grilled pizzas find themselves trendier than ever these days. They’re easy to make on a gas or charcoal grill, and they come out with appealingly charred crusts and perfectly melty cheese.
If you’re eager to give grilled pizzas a try, then you’ll want a pizza stone that’s specifically oriented toward this style of cooking, like the Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone. This ceramic pan can endure temperatures up to 900 degrees, and its sturdy construction and scratch-proof coating render it ideal for grilling. This comes in both a 14-inch and a 16-inch size, for large or extra-large pizzas.
This dishwasher-safe stone can also be used to make pizzas in the oven, but its grill skills shouldn’t be overlooked.
Related: The Best Grills
Best Steel: Baking Steel The Original Baking Steel
The Original Baking Steel greatly benefits from its versatility. While steel isn’t as popular as stone for pizza pans, its speedy heat conductivity allows you to bake your pizzas quicker than you might with a classic pizza stone, while still achieving an ideal pizza crust.
At only 0.25-inch thick, the Original Baking Steel counts among the thinnest steel baking pan on the market, but its substantial 16-pound weight effectively allows the oven’s heat to spread throughout the pie and cook it to perfection. When not in use, the 14 x 16-inch steel can be stored in your oven, where it will help maintain the heat while you cook. This adaptable tool can also be used as a griddle for making bacon, burgers, and a wide range of other dishes.
Best for Convection Ovens: Breville 13-Inch Pizza Stone
Convection ovens are somewhat controversial appliances. Devotees love the quick and even cooking enabled by a convection oven’s internal fans and exhaust system, while naysayers point out their more delicate construction and the adjustments necessary for everyday recipes.
That’s why it’s helpful for convection oven users to purchase cookware particularly developed for convection oven compatibility, and the Breville 13-inch pizza stone provides an excellent example of one of these pans. Breville designed it to work well with its Smart Oven collection of convection toaster ovens, and its porous baking surface results in foolproof crispy pizza crusts.
Related: The Best Toaster Ovens
Lodge's 14-inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan (view at Amazon) can be used literally anywhere you would want to cook a pizza, whether it's an induction cooktop or a campfire. If you're looking for a better heat conductor or traditional pizza stone, the Solido #1 Pizza Stone (view at Amazon) is a great choice.
Why Trust Simply Recipes?
Taylor Tobin is a freelance journalist who specializes in recipe testing and deep dives into popular dishes and ingredients. She regularly uses a wide range of cookware to try out new recipes and to execute old favorites, and the pandemic shutdowns inspired her to try making her own pizzas for the first time. Her cast iron baking pan has served her and her pizzas well thus far, but for the sake of experimentation, she’s also excited to add a steel pan to her collection.
Read Next: The Best Air Fryers