Buying Guides

Best Scotch of the Month Clubs

Jump into the world of scotch or try some new bottles

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Cocktail with cinnamon on rim of glass

Kevin Trimmer / Getty Images

Smoky. Fruity. Peaty. Heavy. Char. Cask. Single malt. The world of Scotch Whisky is rife with enough descriptors to make one’s head spin, leaving many scratching their heads about where to begin to find a scotch that suits them. And, if you’ve already tried all the bottles at your local liquor store, how can you find more interesting and unique flavors without striking out? A scotch of the month club delivers the best scotches for all types of drinkers, from newbies to experienced scotch tasters, right to your door.

You do not need to visit Scotland to taste the best scotches in the world. The best of the scotch of the month clubs offer these selections directly to you, no passport required. With varying levels of membership and with your budget in mind, a club will set you up with a curated dram every month, quarter, or with the ability to purchase on-demand. A subscription gives you the opportunity to broaden your palate from bottles picked by experts in the scotch field. Continue reading for more about the best scotch of the month clubs.

Best Scotch of the Month Clubs of 2021

Best Overall: Flaviar

Flaviar

Flaviar

Why We Chose It: Flaviar ticks all the boxes for the best overall scotch of the month club. With a wide range of scotches from both well-known and boutique brands, this subscription offers the most variety for exploring new bottles with a fun, welcoming vibe.

What We Like
Subscription includes three tasting samples (1.5ml) plus one full-sized bottle every quarter
Exclusive spirits made just for purchase through Flaviar
Access to live and virtual tastings
Members-only pricing for purchasing bottles a la carte

What We Don’t Like
Subscription is only offered quarterly
Not available in every state

Flaviar is our best overall scotch of the month club with its extensive and varied scotch subscription. With a team dedicated to helping you learn more about scotch, Flaviar members receive detailed tasting notes, along with access to exclusive spirits not available to the public and live and virtual tasting sessions. Flaviar even throws in a concrete coaster to make sure you’re not leaving rings on the coffee table.

Memberships start at $95 per quarter, with an option to purchase a full year at $300. You can cancel any time, and subscriptions include free shipping. Note that Flaviar does not ship to several states.

Best Value: Pour More

Pour More

Pour More

Why We Chose It: Pour More's subscriptions start at just $55. Even though it’s the lowest starting price point of all the companies, you still have access to online educational materials and a cocktail recipe every month.

What We Like
More affordable than other clubs
Three levels of membership
Access to online educational materials and detailed scotch descriptions
Monthly cocktail recipe for your bottle

What We Don’t Like
Shipping costs extra
Cannot order single bottles

With a trio of membership levels based on the type of scotch you would like to receive every month, Pour More is an affordable option with its starting price of $55 per delivery. With a membership, you'll be able to learn more about scotch via online materials, and each delivery includes tasting notes and a cocktail recipe. Unlike most scotch of the month clubs, Pour More even sells scotch accessories such as a clear ice cube mold. There are also options to receive bottles monthly or bimonthly, and buying upfront will save you additional money. You can cancel your subscription at any time.

Shipping costs are not included, and you do not have the ability to purchase single bottles on-demand. Pour More does not ship to Alabama, Massachusetts, Mississippi, or Utah.

Best for Beginners: Taster’s Club

Taster’s Club

Taster’s Club

Why We Chose It: With a robust Scotch 101 online curriculum and the ability to commit to only a limited-time subscription, Taster’s Club is a good choice for those new to scotch.

What We Like
One full-sized bottle per month
Tasting, history, and distillery notes
Access to a digital Scotch 101 curriculum
Ability to switch clubs and/or join a pro club
Ability to purchase a second full-sized bottle of that month’s offering

What We Don’t Like
Pro membership is double the cost

For the novice scotch drinker, having access to a whole curriculum for the spirit makes Taster’s Club the best choice for beginners. On top of that, members receive tasting, history, and distillery notes with every shipment, and each full-sized bottle is carefully selected to showcase the broad range of distilleries across Scotland.

A subscription to the Scotch Club is $94 a month, and, once you’ve mastered that, the Scotch Pro Club, which ships one rare bottle monthly, is $199 per delivery. The only downside is that if you do not enjoy that month’s shipment, you’re stuck with a full-sized bottle.

Shipping is free for both clubs and members can cancel at any time. Taster’s Club does not ship to Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Hawaii, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Dakota, Oklahoma, and Utah.

Best for Experienced Scotch Drinkers: The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

Why We Chose It: For scotch drinkers looking for rare and unique bottles, alongside opportunities to attend tasting events, The Scotch Malt Whisky Society is the best option for experienced scotch drinkers.

What We Like
Three levels of membership
Single malt whisky not available to the public
Robust online community
Many opportunities for tasting events

What We Don’t Like
Subscription service and bottle purchases only available to members
Shipping is not included

For the scotch drinker looking for a more unique selection, check out The Scotch Malt Whisky Society. Membership for this online community is $99 a year, with an option to purchase a yearly membership plus a discounted bottle from its selection at $140, $190, and $280. Additionally, it offers a bottle of the month subscription that will cost an additional $90-$200 per month.

The Scotch Malt Whisky Society selects and bottles its own exclusive single malt, single cask whiskies to create rare and unique offerings that you can’t get in any store. The community is the heart of this program, with many opportunities for members-only tastings and events throughout the year, both in the U.S. and internationally. There's also a member referral program, along with the option to cancel at any time.

Best for Membership Options: Mash&Grape

Mash&Grape

Mash&Grape

Why We Chose It: Mash&Grape has several subscription options on offer.

What We Like
You can choose how often you want deliveries
One full-sized bottle delivered every month
Tasting notes and detailed information included in the shipment
Shipping dates are flexible

What We Don’t Like
No price break on buying options

If you’re looking for flexible subscription options as well as bottles of scotch from world-class small distillers and independent bottlers, Mash&Grape is a good choice. Subscriptions are available in three-, six-, or 12-month increments, with a recurring option as well.

Every month, subscribers receive one full-sized bottle for $79, making this the second-lowest option from all categories. Included with the shipment are tasting notes and detailed information about the bottle. Mash&Grape even offers some flexibility if you’d like to change a shipping date.

Unfortunately, there is no price break if you pay upfront or decide to purchase more months or a recurring subscription. Shipping is extra and Mash&Grape does not deliver to several states.

Final Verdict

Finding the right scotch is made even easier with a scotch of the month club. Choose your price range, shipment frequency, and even the type of scotch you’re interested in tasting. Flaviar stands out among the clubs for variety in the box, as well as its inclusion of extras and exclusive products, while Pour More makes it easy on your wallet to dip into the world of scotch with an entry-level membership.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are Scotch of the Month Clubs?

Scotch of the month clubs deliver tasting- and full-sized bottles of scotch at regular intervals, generally monthly or quarterly. Most include information about each scotch, and others throw in extras such as access to an online community, discounts on additional bottles, and various accessories.

Are Scotch of the Month Clubs Good for Beginners?

A Scotch of the Month Club provides newcomers to the world of scotch the opportunity to receive smaller bottles and get lots of tasting notes and information on scotch sent by experts. Depending on the club, you can try out a range of scotches to discover which ones suit your tastes.

How Much Do Scotch of the Month Clubs Cost?

Scotch of the month clubs range in price from around $55 per delivery up to $200 or more, depending on which one you choose and what is included.

How We Chose the Best Scotch of the Month Clubs

We researched several scotch of the month clubs and considered factors including frequency of deliveries, variety of scotches (both well-known brands and small-batch or boutique brands), member reviews, and membership perks. We also looked at cost and tried to include a range of options to suit a variety of scotch drinkers' budgets.

Continue to 5 of 5 below.