10 Recipes to Use Up A Carton of Mushrooms

Got a carton of mushrooms you need to cook, stat? We have recipes! Even stubborn mushroom haters will love a few of these gems.

We’ve been talkin’ mushrooms here at Simply Recipes lately: how to select and store them, plus how to prep them. Now it’s time to get cooking! If you have a full or partial carton of mushrooms you’d like to tackle, these recipes won’t disappoint.

Recipes
Want groceries delivered to your door?
Shop the ingredients for these recipes right here!
Add Menu to Shopping List
Mushrooms on toast with egg

Did someone say breakfast for dinner? If your pantry is lean, this is an utterly satisfying meal that comes together in less than 30 minutes. You can even sauté the mushrooms a day ahead.

Add to Shopping List
Moo Goo Gai Pan Chicken on a white plate with rice

We don’t need no stinkin’ takeout! This one’s great for those on the fence about mushrooms, because there’s a bunch of other colorful and appealing veggies in the mix—plus chicken—in a savory-sweet sauce.

Add to Shopping List
Vegetarian Quesadilla Recipe -close up of cheese and mushroom quesadillas stacked on top of each other with a jar of red salsa in the background.

Corn tortillas make these not only gluten-free, but nice and crispy! And mushrooms make classic cheese quesadillas more filling and nutritious. You can make the quesadillas in the microwave or griddle them on the stove.

Add to Shopping List
Joe's Special Scrambled Eggs with Spinach, Beef, and Mushrooms

Ground beef, spinach, and mushrooms cooked quickly in a skillet make this comfort food supreme. Use baby spinach and sliced mushrooms, and your prep work will be virtually non-existent.

Add to Shopping List
Marsala Glazed Mushrooms

In the mood for a giant pile of mushrooms? Make these, and have them on hand to top chicken or pork cutlets, grilled steak, or a gob of oozy polenta. You could even make this recipe, and freeze it! Don’t have Marsala? Use chicken stock, port, sherry, or red or white wine instead.

Add to Shopping List
How to Make Vegetable Fried Rice

Sub one or two cups of chopped mushrooms for another vegetable in this tasty kitchen-sink fried rice. It’s perfect for cooking down what’s hanging out in your crisper drawer. Add the mushrooms in step one, when you add all of the other veggies, and then continue on with the recipe as written.

Add to Shopping List
Risotto with Mushrooms - white bowls filed creamy mushroom risotto

Miso and soy sauce make this an umami-rich risotto that’s incredibly hands-off, thanks to your Instant Pot. And it includes a hack that lets you do two-thirds of the steps up to two hours ahead.

Add to Shopping List
Mushroom Quiche

My sister-in-law brought me a mushroom quiche shortly after I came home from the hospital with my brand new daughter. I inhaled about half the quiche in one sitting. This recipe is slightly decadent, but still good for you because, um, mushrooms! Make it for the people you love, whether they are new mothers or just in need of a pick-me-up.

Add to Shopping List
Pot Sticker Stir Fry

Love pot stickers, but don’t want to mess with shaping them? This stir-fry is just the filling part! It’s a Paleo recipe, but even non-Paleo cooks who love dumplings will fall for it. The recipe calls for shiitake mushrooms, but you could easily sub creminis or white mushrooms.

Add to Shopping List
Kale Mushroom Cheddar Bake

Somewhere between a strata and savory bread pudding, this cozy casserole is packed with good-for-you veggies and topped with melty, yum-for-you cheese.

Add to Shopping List

Products We Love

This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Simply Recipes. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.

Sara Bir

Sara Bir a graduate of The Culinary Institute of America and the author of two cookbooks: The Fruit Forager’s Companion and Tasting Ohio. Past gigs include leading chocolate factory tours, slinging street cart sausages, and writing pop music criticism. Sara skates with her local roller derby team as Carrion the Librarian.

More from Sara

7 Comments

No Image10 Recipes to Use Up A Carton of Mushrooms

  1. Fred

    LOVE IT

  2. Mark Ferguson

    Where’s the soup/bisque recipe? That’s my go-to with “extra” mushrooms (is there such a thing?)

  3. Richard Goodman

    Nice article about mushrooms

    Show Replies (1)
  4. Linda Fullerton

    They all look yummy!

  5. Tarre

    :(
    The recipes look fantastic and I plan to try them all. But, you said “Let’s talk mushrooms.” I was excited. The H Mart by my house always has at least a dozen different kinds of fresh mushrooms. I don’t know what they are since packaging is not in English, or what to do with them. Instead you just gave recipes. They look good but we didn’t “talk mushrooms.”

    Show Replies (1)