READER QUESTION: I almost always use salted butter instead of unsalted when I bake, and then I cut down on the salt used in the recipe. I'm usually happy with how things turn out, but I'm wondering -- is there a good reason for me to switch to the unsalted?
Thank you for such a great question! I know a lot of folks get confused when choosing butter for a recipe. Many recipes call for unsalted but lately, I'm seeing more and more recipes using salted butter and ... well, how to decide?!
The simple answer is I do think unsalted is typically the best choice, and here's why:
- It's true that more recipes than not call for unsalted butter and until you've made something a few times, why go off script right out of the gate?
- It's much, much easier to taste your dough and add a little extra salt if need be but you can't take it away. So I think it's a sanity-saver to use unsalted and adjust the salt levels if necessary.
- Different brands of butter contain different amounts of salt; if you use unsalted butter and add your own salt, then you'll get more consistent results.
As for as how the recipe will actually turn out, either choice is just fine! Your cakes will rise just the same and your scones will be equally flaky — it's more an issue of flavor.
-Megan Gordon, Marketing Director and lover of all baked goods
P.S. Have a question you’d like answered? Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org