Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Have never used or even tasted artichokes until recently when I had a cup of artichoke soup at a restaurant. Loved it and decided to try making at home, this was the first recipe that popped up when I did a search, so off I went. Just finished cutting out the hearts, man-oh-man that was a LOT of work! Takes all the fun out of eating! Getting ready to cook now so still no idea how it will come out, but judging by most of the comments, I would say the odds of a successful outcome are poor. Plus, I can’t help but wonder at the wisdom/validity of the admonition “We do not recommend using frozen artichoke hearts for this soup, as frozen hearts are treated in an acidic solution, changing the flavor of the soup”. That acidic solution is citric acid, which (other than salt) is the only other ingredient in most frozen and canned artichoke hearts. The process for prepping fresh hearts includes using plenty of lemon juice to mitigate oxidation. Lemon juice is essentially citric acid. So … why is it OK to use lemon juice (citric acid) but not OK to use frozen/canned hearts with added citric acid?
Hi Terry, Good question! I tried making it with frozen artichokes hearts and it didn’t taste good. I think there’s just too much citric acid in the frozen hearts compared to the gentle acidifying that you do while you prep the fresh artichokes.
Wow – this was a lot of work, expensive and not that great! I ended up with a flavorful soup that is really watery. I think 12 cups of stock is way too much – maybe 8? Not quite sure what to do — simmer it down? add a thickener? give up?
Hi, Janey! I’m so sorry you weren’t happy with how this recipe turned out! I like your idea of simmering it on the stovetop to cook it down. I think that should work really well. Hope that helps!
I am allergic to Onions, Garlic, Leeks and Potatoes. Any suggestions for altering the recipes above? I usually am pretty creative but these ingredients seem to dominate here.
Boy, I’d be thinking about another recipe. Maybe just steam the artichokes and enjoy them as is?
I made this soup for guests the other night and
it really was not that good. Even tho I used
more artichokes; fresh, not canned or frozen;
and less potatoes than called for in the recipe
the universal comment was it tasted like potato
soup. I used non salted butter and low sodium
chicken stock, so it definitely needed salt to
boost the flavor. We ended up adding salt, lots
of pepper, and lemon juice to mask the overwhelming potato flavor. I probably won’t try this recipe again.
It’s essential to use the artichoke water from steaming the artichokes before cutting up the hearts. Condense the artichoke broth to one cup by simmering. The soup should be a lovely pale green. Canned and frozen will not compare to fresh.
I’ve used this recipe several times with great success! It’s my favorite, by far, and I love the ambiance of the Shadowbrook. If you ever get a chance to eat there, I highly recommend it. They use frozen artichoke hearts, which are easier to come by when you live not so close to the coast. :)
Shadowbrook (Capitola) Creamy Artichoke Soup
(or 2-8.5 oz.
cans, drained) Frozen artichoke hearts
or 2 sm. Potatoes, peeled and sliced
1/2 med. Onion, peeled and sliced
1 1/2 Celery stocks, chopped
1/2 med. Leek (white only), sliced
1 clove Garlic, finely chopped (optional)
3 Cups Chicken or vegetable stock
or 2 Tbsp. Fresh minced flat-leaf Italian parsley
1/3 Tsp. Dried oregano
1/2 Tsp. Dried basil
3 Tbsp. Butter
2 Tbsp. Flour
1/2 Tsp. Half and Half
1/2 Cup Heavy cream
1/2 Tsp. Salt
1/2 Tsp. Pepper
1-2 Tsp. Fresh lemon juice
Directions: Cook vegetables, including frozen artichoke hearts if used, in water until soft, approx 10-12 minutes. Drain. In blender, purée cooked vegetables (add canned artichoke hearts here, if used) and optional garlic. Return to pot. Add the herbs and stock. Sim-mer for 20 minutes.
Make a roux with the melted butter and flour over medium heat. Add the half and half, stirring until smooth. Add to soup. Add the heavy cream. Bring soup back up to boil and season with salt, pepper and fresh lemon juice to taste. To thin soup, add half and half. To thicken, add more roux.
Strain through a fine strainer or colander. Makes about 6-8 ounce servings.
The cream of artichoke soup from Duarte’s is my absolute favorite. They also have a really great cream of chili soup. My dad grew up in Pescadero, and our family still lives in the area, so we go there whenever we can. FYI: the Duarte’s are Portuguese, not Italian, so their name is pronounced Due-art, not Due-art-tay, like many people make the mistake of doing. It’s just one of those things that gets annoying if you’re a local and know better :)
Love, love Duarte’s cream of artichoke soup. Also love to get ½ artichoke and ½ cream of chili mixed together- soooo good! I would love to have their recipe!!
May I use sour cream in place of the cream?
I’ve never tried it. If you do, let us know how it turns out. ~Elise
Elice, this is an elegant soup, a perfect start to a spring dinner party or a light meal. Baby artichokes and spring onions are at my farmers market so I substituted. I found I used half the butter and no cream like miche above. Even lighted up it was good enough to add to my recipe book with 5 stars. Thank you!
Oh yum! Thank you so much for this recipe Elise. I served it as a starter for our Easter dinner and everyone just loved it.
This is a lovely artichoke soup. It was the perfect starter course for a dinner party of eight. I modified the recipe, but only slightly. I felt it needed to be just a bit thicker (not much) so I added two beurre manie balls (about 2T butter-flour mixed together. I make these up and keep them in the freezer for just this purpose). I also added a few drops of hot sauce to kick it up just a tad. At service time, I added a dollop of thick, homemade creme fraiche and a few small Parmesan croutons (again homemade) to each serving. Artichokes are pricey in NH this time of year but I can’t resist taking advantage of them when they are in season (counter to localvore trends). They are not only tasty but beautiful to look at in the bowl on my table before they go into the soup pot. Thanks for this recipe Elise.
Go Duarte’s! I’m an Azorean Portuguese NorCal native and Pescadero is awesome; it’s the best place to get away from the valley or the city and find great food. Artichoke soup there is great, as well as at Cunha’s country store in Half Moon Bay. Thanks for the recipe. Azoreans rock the Bay!
I saw that one reviewer used frozen artichokes for this recipe. I am wondering if the canned variety packed in water would work?
In my opinion this recipe wouldn’t even be worth attempting with canned artichokes. ~Elise
Hi Elise! I have my own recipe to cook this soup and my family like it. But it’s boring to make the same for years. Yesterday cooked yours Artichoke soup and it was delicious. Thanks a lot for sharing the recipe.
I made this tonight with 10 baby artichokes (10 for $1 in my ‘hood today!) and about 8 cups of broth. That seemed to be perfect. I also thought 12 was too much. It is not too thick – it is honestly just right! Also, I used half the butter (for sauteeing) and no cream – this being post-holidays and everything. It is still very rich and velvety w/o the addition of the fat. Thanks for sharing the recipe, Elise.
It does seem excessive, doesn’t it? But, that’s the recipe as it appeared in the NYT. I cut the whole thing in half and used 6 cups of stock and 3 instead of 5 large globe artichoke hearts.
I haven’t tried the recipe but 12 cups of stock seems very excessive to me compared to other recipes. Suzanne
No problem with making it on Monday night for serving on Wed. Just don’t bring it to a boil, but heat it to right before simmering.
Do you think that this would keep OK if I made this tonight (Monday) for dinner on Wednesday? I don’t want to compromise flavor or texture. I was thinking about storing the puree in the fridge until then and adding the cream and butter when reheating.
Thanks for the advice! I’m still a novice cook and oftentimes don’t know what I’m doing…
Just for you, and for others who might be curious, I made this soup today using a bag of frozen artichoke hearts from Trader Joe’s.
I halved the recipe, as the frozen hearts are from artichokes that are much smaller than what we would typically buy fresh.
The frozen artichoke hearts are treated with citric acid (vitamin C actually) to help preserve their color. This flavor comes through in the soup. To counteract the acidic flavor you need to add some sugar to the soup. I added a couple of tablespoons to achieve the proper balance.
The frozen artichokes include some leaves as well as the thistley choke. So, after you purée the soup, you definitely need to put it through a strainer.
The verdict? The soup was good, but not glorious. Doesn’t approach the original.