Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
What vinegar would you recommend to substitute the red wine vinegar? Thanks!
First, I just wanted to tell you I love your site. Second this is one of my favorite sandwiches, mmmm!!!!
Nice recipe! I better love to make sandwiches.. I’m curious, could we make the Mozzarella with a manual way, without buying them from the store?
Hi Irene, Mozzarella is traditionally made from the milk of water buffalo. (See Wikipedia on mozzarella.) I don’t know anyone who makes it at home, but if you are interested in cheese making, I’m sure you can find some good books on the subject. ~Elise
This was THE BEST sandwich I’ve had in a long time! Easy, simple, and fresh! I loaded on the mayo and felt great about it. ;) Thanks!
Is there another alternative to arugula? I live on the equator in South East Asia and we don’t have access to this kind of produce (which bugs me to bits).
Try fresh spinach, or some fresh lettuce-like green that you can eat raw that is slightly peppery or bitter. Nasturtium leaves would work too, if you grow those flowers there. ~Elise
I made this last week for dinner. My husband and I enjoyed the sandwiches so much, we had it again the following night for dinner.
Okay, so I’m a vegetarian and I love experimenting with different foods and this looks perfect! The photo makes my mouth water and my stomach growl in agony waiting to be fed this.
I love these sandwiches. Try putting some basil pesto with the mozzarella, really yummy.
My daughter just started working at Panera Breads and is now bringing home all kinds of breads and pastries. I hated to let the Focaccia go to waste (instead it went to waist!) so I searched on line for recipes and found this one.
The grocery store didn’t have Argula all by itself, so I used organic baby greens. I also used Caponata (an italian eggplant dip/spread) instead of the mayonnaise…just because I saw it in the store and it looked yummy. My husband adored this recipe, and so did I. I really like the idea of Dinner Sandwiches, Madeline. I may steal that idea. Elise, I am now going to go searching for more of your recipes!
We made this for a pot luck but used olive oil instead of mayo. Half the sandwiches were made with smoked mozzarella. It was easy, yummy, and a hit. We’ll be making these again for our selves. Thanks so much for such a great simply recipe.
Made this tonight along with your oven fried chips and spinach. I substituted the spinach for the arugula. Please thank your Dad for me… it was excellent!!
I tried the recipe with oil packed sundried tomatoes instead of regular tomatoes. I’m still drooling over how good it was!!
That sandwhich looks great! I have had a lot of luck with growing Arugula in my window. I just put a post on an easy to make focaccia recipe. It is really easy to make and given the difference fresh bread makes in a sandwhich, definitely worth the effort!
Delicious. Reminds me of my mom’s “dinner sandwich” for those hot summer days, although she would use water and balsalmic vinegar to marinate.
Actually, as kids my grandma made us something similar for breakfasts before we walked off to school– often eaten while walking to school (but she hated it when we did that). The difference there was that the bread was (homemade) toasted whole wheat, buttered (so no mayo), and a fried egg replaced the lettuce. The egg was what we called “over hard,” meaning the yolk was fully cooked (solid); I don’t know if “over hard” is a term anyone other than grandma and mom ever used. I hate to think of the cholesterol content of that, but it was wonderful.
Thanks for bringing back the memories. Got to make this for my wife and kids tonight, especially since it will be 100 degrees today.
Hi Trishinomaha – keep saying how handsome my dad is and he’ll keep cooking forever! He loves reading comments like that. ;-)
Ethan and Dennis – aioli would work, some really good olive oil too
Regarding growing arugula in a pot. Never tried. We can’t get rid of the stuff. We ignored our patch for years and it reseeded itself over the entire garden. It is a very hardy plant, I would say, go for it.
Mayonnaise!!!! Its gotta be a nice drizzle of olive oil…..
John: Yes, any veggie or herb can be grown in a pot. Be careful of your fertilizing & watering (check a garden book on containers, or ‘square-foot-gardening’). My Mom used to grow tomatoes in the house (use a small art brush to polinate the flowers), and we’d have hot-house tomatoes in winter!
Elise can you grow arugula in a pot??? I don’t have a yard, I grow some herbs in the pot and would love to grow arugula if it will survive. I know it’s so expensive everytime I bought it at Wholefoods.