Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Great recipe.I was in a hurry, so I did 6 hours @ 280 degrees. On a Weber gas grill, apple chips, water pan. It hit 190 degrees internal–I went with that. Wrapped, sat for 1 hour.Just amazing.Next time, I’ll do bone-in, like the Eastern NC boys. With pepper flake/vinegar sauce. Sweet slaw, sweet tea. It’s like having dessert for the main course. Just wish I had the NC recipe for cornbread sticks.
Great roast thanks for sharing
Great recipe. Easy to follow!
How do I reheat my ribs without drying them out??
Hi, L! Emma here, managing editor for Simply Recipes. I’d recommend putting your ribs (or pulled pork shoulder) in a baking dish, covering loosely with foil, and warming in a 300F oven. If you have some leftover cooking liquid, toss that with the pulled pork if it seems dry. If you’re doing ribs, you might want to baste them with a little more BBQ sauce. Enjoy!
Tried for the first time last week. Came out really good had to finish in the oven,trying again this weekend. I think I’ve got the bugs worked out looking forward to perfection this time. Great for first timer like me. Thanks
Delicious recipe! Had a six pounder and it only took 5.5 hours to smoke to perfection. No oven time, kept the heat at 230*.
Was your butt boneless? I’m just wondering since I had my 6 lb on for 9hrs at about 225 & It wasn’t fall off the bone as before when I’ve cooked them. I’m finishing up in the oven. Thanks. BTW I’m teaching myself to grill, since my husband has never done it. (:
so ive followed the steps as said. my problem was with a 4lb shoulder @250 for 6hrs on the grill and only opening every hr to check the smoke/bowl of water the middle was not cooking at all. transfered to the oven @300 for roughly an hour and a half and still the center wasnt cooking… i dunno what yall have done differently but this hasnt worked out in my favor! started at noon and still cooking!
Man oh man I be telling you, this is a great method! To think my husband wanted to ditch the BBQ we got with the house. He’s liking it now!
Looks wonderful. Wish mine was fall off the bone, but it wasn’t. Cooked by indirect heat for 7 hours. Maybe it wasnt long enough? I let it rest too. Didnt finish in the oven. Does that make the difference? Cooked at 250-275
I’ve always wanted to try smoking meat but have never found such an exptensive how to when using a grill, thanks! Multiple family members of mine own Green Eggs and they have all this equipment to go with it, don’t get me wrong, it’s delicious but I wouldn’t want to invest all that money into something I’m not even sure I’ll enjoy doing.
Anywho, to the point: one thing I do have a question about it the size. I love the bark of the meat, do you think I could take a 4 lb butt, cut it in half and smoke 2 smaller butts for half the time? I’d like to get more bark and not have to be glued to my house as long.
Hi Catherine, good question! I think smoking smaller butts may take less time, but not half the time. No idea on the specifics though, you’ll have to experiment!
I have made this recipe twice. Used both rubs each time, and all I can say is THANK YOU. I followed the recipe to the letter, and I cannot tell you how superb both came out.
Made my Pork Shoulder yesterday. It was spot on! started it at 1:00 after marinating over night but I used a dry and a fresh herb rub, all the herbs from my garden. ( Purple basil, Fresh oregano, Parsley, Fresh garlic minced fine, and a little Lemon basil, olive oil, splash of red wine. For the dry part; Paprika, cumin, fennel seeds,& red chilly flakes ( a little pat of butter.) Blended all together and rubbed all over. (24hrs) I used chicory wood chips. Then followed your steps. I did not finish in the oven, I was not pressed for time. I did loosely cover the shoulder with foil. (just a top) Then I shut the grill and at 6PM my husband and I were in our glory! Definitely going to do again. Thanks for the yummy tip!
This was May first try at this followed your plan exactly as peresented here, turned out perfect! Running out to buy another roast to cook for our friends now that we have more confidence. Thank you
When i cant bbq or bear to use the propane bbq for 6 & 1/2 hrs i make mine in the oven…I like to put Montreal seasoning on the skin side up & seasoning salt& pepper on all sides,, wrap it tight as I can in tinfoil.. Poke 1 hole in the top, so it doesn’t bust on a side from thebsteam expanding. &put it in a roasting pan skin side & poked hole up!..in a 500 degree oven & turn it to 450for 30 minutes to sear it a little then turn it to down to 300& cook for 6 hours,, this is for the 8 lb roast, comes out a carmalized&fall aprart deliciousness!
Make that 8 hours like 8am to 4pm from start to pulling it out of the oven, let it rest for 30 minutes, drain(save juices if u want to make gravy),&shred.. I make green chili burritos, enchiladas, and BBQ sandwiches all out of the same roast .. Or just whip up the gravy and eat it on the meat !
Great job! I followed your recipe and it was superb! I gave you 5 stars, what else can I say.
A little hint. You can easily add an internal thermometer to your grill. They are readily available as replacement equipment but all you need to do is have a hole the size of the thermometer stem, stick the new thermometer into the hole and secure it with the included bolt.
Well worth the bother and very easy to control the temp inside your grill box.
I use mine all the time for rotisserie grilled chicken @ a perfect 400*. Better than store bought and you can use your own rubs making the chicken your own creation.
sounds good to me, i was suprised to see you mention “santa maria style” rub. is this also good on tri tip?
Yes, it is designed for a tri tip, but you can also use it on a pork shoulder roast. ~Elise
That is a nice looking butt, great bark, almost better looking bark then alot of smokers I have used. If you go the Materbilt route make sure you inspect the door before you take it out of the store, some have hadith door alignment. I wouldo recommend the digital thermostat . Keep in mind It may be off by as much as 10 to 20 degrees so you need to test it with a QUALITY thermometer and adjust the reading in your mind accordingly. As for smoke, rule of thumb, a handfull of chips an hr for the first three hours. At hour 4 to 7 (dependng on size and color (get a barrst) pull meat out and wrap in heavy foil for remainder of cook time. this is for a cook temp of 225, a 7 to 9 lb butt should be good to go in 12 to 14 hrs. let it come to about 205 degrees…you will be rewarded. You can also cook the butt a bit hotter, 350 for 4 to 6 hours again depending. Myron Mixon does his competition pulled pork in this manner tender and not quite as juicy I think.
You might also try using a couple of disposable aluminum pans to aid in clean up and to collect drippings to make an awesome sauce with real smoke flavoring. The size I use come in packs of two. If you use the pans you can simply use one for helping to maintain a lower temperature by putting water in it as suggested. In the other use a roasting rack to hold the meat up out of the liquid and use apple juice in this pan, a half gallon bottle of juice will do and the apple juice will pick up the smokey flavor from the drippings as well as from just being in the grill. Use as much as possible under the meat, just so the meat isn’t sitting in the juice, more can be added later if needed, and if the other pan is directly over the heat put some apple juice in the water in it too or just use apple juice instead of water, but be aware it can raise the boiling point and thus the grill temperature slightly. If you are spending the time and money a couple of more dollars for a bottle of juice is well spent.
After the meat is removed from the grill take the pan of apple juice and drippings and put in a separator and let sit until the oil and fat form a layer on top. Pour off the broth into a pot or large pan and add a can of tomato paste, a little can will probably be enough but depending on taste you might want to use two small cans of paste. Boil to reduce liquid content by about half the initial volume or until sauce thickens as much as you want. Or for a milder taste and just more sauce use a thickener such as corn starch instead of reducing the sauce as much. Let your own taste be the guide. If you don’t have a separator put the juices in a pot and let it cool and separate and then pour and spoon off the oil and fat.
Depending on the rub and personal taste, you may want to sweeten the sauce with some brown sugar(white sugar will work) or it might need a touch of salt. Of course you should feel free to add any other spices but I’d recommend going lightly on them until you taste the reduced sauce as they could seem stronger after the sauce reduces. And you can divide it and make a sauce selection by adding more sugar, mustard, hot pepper, pepper sauce, or whatever you wish to each portion as desired.
Great tips, thank you! ~Elise
Great post, Elise. I love smoked meats but can’t afford to lose the deck space to another piece of equipment. This method is do-able.