Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Just made this recipe exactly as written but doubled. I beat the sugar and butter for a long time, and once the eggs were in beat it longer. I’m on about my 8th pan (1 tsp. each) and they are delicious, beautiful, and a perfect contribution to book club tonight.
I baked for 8 minutes, turned the pan and baked for another 4 minutes. They are picture perfect. Nice job!
These are absolutely fabulous! Thank you so much for the recipe. Made them with coconut oil instead of butter and I cut down sugar for 30 g (I converted the ingredients in metric measures). They turned out amazing. I wonder how they would turn out if substitute egg with “chia egg”.. will let you know if I try them for my vegan friends.
Hi. Did you substitute the chia egg in the recipe yet? Really curious about that
i am vegan and was about to sub the egg for aquafaba… did you ever try the chia? i would think that would make it super seedy. please let us know your outcome!!
Andrea, aquafaba would be worth a shot for sure! Good thinking.
Wow, these are unbelievably delicious – and I don’t even like sesame seeds! I made 53 wafers, and the cooking time was only 8-9 minutes.
I too love/hate you for this addicting recipe. I add a tablespoon of molasses to the recipe instead of vanilla. We ate these in Charleston and we’re addicted to them. Found your recipe and have been making double recipes ever since. I keep a container of them in the freezer at all times.
Whole Foods has sesame seeds in bulk, too.
Can i use oil instead of butter? If so, than how much?
I’d be wary to try it, since I think it would result in a runny batter. You can give it a shot, subbing the same amount of oil for butter, but we can’t guarantee the results. Good luck!
Here where I live in Mexico City, amaranth is readily available and is practically a staple ingredient of traditional snacks and baked goods. It’s got a subtle nutty flavor and tons of fiber and protein. Substituting half of the benne seeds for puffed amaranth in this recipe worked great, yielding a somewhat lighter cookie than the original (both in flavor and texture). I’ve also substituted the wheat flour for amaranth with good results. Thanks so much for sharing this wonderful recipe!
Great suggestion, Lynna – thank you. I just made these yesterday, too! Can’t wait to try them using amaranth.
just a tip, if using amaranth-the amaranth toasts (and burns!) much more quickly than the sesame seeds, so I add it when the sesame seeds are about half done toasting.
Made these for school bake sale and everyone loved them.
Sounds yummy. For those not near Asian or Indian grocery stores, you can purchase sesame seeds bulk from Nuts.com: Organic 3.49 a lb, non-organic 2.79 a lb. Unhulled available too.
I made these cookies with half of the sugar being palm sugar with wonderful results!I can’t tell you how glad I am to have found your site.
Every recipe I have tried is a winner.
As a “displaced” Charlestonian I try and bring the flavor of the city where ever I live. Benne wafers are the most popular request, even over she crab soup! Though the beauty of the benne wafer is its simplicity I have in the past tried half-dipping them with milk, dark and white chocolate; they were just okay. Not one to mess with tradition, I did anyway. This season I got a little crazy and added a nice rich cocoa powder. Whooo! That did it. The toasted seed along with the brown sugar engages the chocolate to create a full flavor that begs to be paired with a nice heavy red wine! Start easy and increase if you are not sure how “chocolaty” you want, but the darker the better in my opinion.
I too am addicted to these cookies.I have found that if I let them “rest” for 5 minutes or so before trying to get them off the baking sheet it works much better.
May I thank and curse you at the same time? I’m going to have to run 5 extra miles tomorrow…please step away from the cookies…ok, so how do you get the cookies off of the sheet? I also had a devil of a time setting the cookies free, I used an oiled cookie sheet, and I had to chisel those poor cookies off! Do you oil the parchment?
I can only imagine how difficult it would be to pry the cookies off of an oiled cookie sheet! You definitely want to use parchment paper (do not oil it) or silpat sheets. On the good side, maybe you burned a few calories? ~Steve-Anna
These were so tasty, except they stuck to the baking tray terribly even though I oiled them, and also even when I used chilled batter, and also even when I used two different kinds of trays. Do I need to use butter to grease the trays, not oil? I’ve never had this problem before with any other cookie dough. The crumbs were super tasty though, and still totally good sprinkled over ice cream or breakfast porridge!
Hi Zo, the best solution is to use parchment paper or silpat sheets. Parchment paper works beautifully, and you can reuse the sheets several times. I’m glad you found a way to enjoy the broken bits! ~Steve-Anna
I just baked these this morning. I made the batter last night and baked one pan, finding the cookies a bit chewy and way too big. I let the batter refrigerate over night and tried again this morning with perfect results!! Thanks to the stiffness of the chilled dough, I was able to roll the dough into tiny little balls, resulting in cookies about the size of a quarter after baked. They are so cute, and perfectly bite-sized. Thank you so much for the recipe!!
I made the wafers today and was quite surprised how unique tasting these were and almost addicting. It has to be the well toasted sesame seeds which give a very distinct flavor and the touch of fresh lemon juice. Thank you.
I made these today for our book club meeting tomorrow. We read the book South of Broad and these cookies were mentioned in the book. Being from the north originally I had never heard of Benne Wafers. I thought they might be fun to have at the book club. I did find that 15 min is way too long to cook these. Ten min is more realistic in my oven. Unfortunately I burned the first two batches but this recipe makes a ton of cookies since you only use tsp size portions. Decided I am really not a fan of these. I couldn’t find the sesame seeds except in the spice isle of the grocery store so these are a bit pricey to make!
Easy to find them in the health food stores in the bulk section
I searched for the recipe after reading South of Broad, too! Mine came out too chewy in the center, but I’m going to try again.
Hope the second time’s a charm. I’d say try either making the wafers a little smaller, or reduce the oven temp a smidge and bake them a little longer. Thanks for reading and baking with us. Charleston is such a wonderful city, and we’re glad you searched out this recipe.
This reminds me of an Indian recipe for a sesame and molasses snack made as flat squares called chikki or made into little balls called ladoos. I was very amused to only find sesame in the spice aisle in US supermarkets. In India it’s bought in much larger quantities so found around the lentils and grains. Indian stores in the US probably stock it in bulk too.
I just made these today, and I was SO pleased!! They reminded me of the “sesame snap” wafers you can buy. Delicious to a fault (is it really a fault?). Thanks!
@ Barbara Ruby – You can get mass quantities of sesame seeds at any Asian market. They’re WAY less expensive than in the spice section at the grocery store, too. :)
@Steve-Anna – I just made this recipe this morning, and the flavor is TDF. I have a question tho – the recipe as written is NOT a dough – it’s VERY liquidy. I added more flour to make it more dough-like, but then the cookies didn’t flatten out as much as those in the pictures here. Is the liquidy-ness (new word, LOL) normal, and if so, how far apart do you space the cookies? I’m using Sil-Pat sheets.
I used salted butter and omitted the salt in this recipe, and it workedout fine. :)
You’re right, the recipe is not “dough like”. The way I’ve dealt with the “liquid-yness” is to chill the batter before dropping the spoonfuls of batter on the silpat sheets or parchment paper. Use only a true teaspoon size of batter, and yes, do leave a few inches between each for them to spread. I usually get a dozen on one cookie sheet. They come out lookling more like a flat cracker than a plump cookie.
Glad you like the flavor, and thanks for the tip to buy the seeds at an Asian market – great suggestion! ~Steve-Anna
These are delicious, I cannot stop eating them! Thank you for sharing this recipe.