Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
This was My first time eating Butternut Squash and with this recipe, it will be a weekly item to eat! Thank You For This Easy Recipe!
I have made this recipe for several different events now and everyone LOVES it! By far my favorite side dish to make because it’s so easy and so delicious. I added some rosemary along with the thyme today too, really good!
Trader Joes sells butternut squash already peeled and cut. Hope this helps.
I have totally fallen in love with butternut squash!!! But I to dislike how long it takes to peel. This is what i do. Cut it in half carefully. DO NOT PEEL. (scoop out all seeds to save for baking and snacking on later.) Turn 2 halved pieces cut side down on greased cookie sheet. Bake @ 350 for 20-30 min. Let cool. Then easily slice the outer skin off before finishing up whatever recipe you like.
I wanted to use our home-grown butternut for Thanksgiving Dinner at my in-laws this year, but the stovetop wasn’t going to be available. So I followed this recipe up through step #2, browning the squash. I refrigerated the browned squash in a stonewear baking dish. Thanksgiving Day, it went in my mother-in-law’s oven and came out delicious! It takes about an hour at 350.
I’m not sure it was worth this extra effort, but to peel it I first boiled the whole squash for about 2-3 minutes and then transferred it to ice water. The peel was cooked soft, easy to remove with a veggie peeler. The meat was still hard, so little was wasted with the peeling.
I made this and two other recipes of yours for Thanksgiving. Everything came out awesome and were complete hits!
I’ve been reading your blog for a while but had never made anything before. I collect recipes. When I chose recipes to try for the holiday it just so happened that three were from you.
Thanks so much! Keep doing what you do, you’re great!
This recipe rocks! (as do other recipes from your site that we’ve tried) Actually, today you’ve been our personal “chef”. For lunch, I made the tuna salad sandwich, then for dinner, I cooked sole piccata with butternut squash. All from your site – with great success. No left over. Thanks Elise!
I’ve never made butternut squash before. This was very good. I bought a package of squash at the store that was already cut up (!), so that was great! Used fresh thyme. I made this after Thanksgiving. My guests really liked it!
I made this for Thanksgiving dinner yesterday and it was a hit! It was one of the prettiest things on the table, and a nice flavor compliment to all the other turkey day dishes.
It’s so good I’m planning to make it one of my rotating “go-to” fall dishes.
This was a good dish and really easy. I like the squash when its roasted and a little crispy on the outsides and still somewhat firm inside. I will try and use less butter next time, just for diet reasons. Thanks, great recipe!
Can I use margarine instead of butter?
“Browned butter” requires butter, as what you are browning are the milk solids within the butter. Margarine is just solidified vegetable oil without any milk solids. Of course if you try it anyway, please let us know how it turns out. ~Elise
Re: reheating, I made this in the morning and took it to a friend’s for a potluck tonight. I reheated it there in the oven, and it was definitely a hit! I almost wish I’d browned the butter a little more, to get extra flavor, but it was my first time trying and I was deathly afraid of burning it. Next time.
Yum. Just made this for dinner, and it was fantastic. Butternut squash is my favorite squash, but I have never made it on the stove top before. This was so handy since I was making steaks in the cast iron, so my oven was at 500, and that would turn my precious squash into blackened crisps.Delicious, and as always, pretty easy! Thank you.
I thought two aspects were especially important:
(1) Having a *sharp* vegetable peeler really makes your work a lot easier. And by “a lot easier” I mean “almost makes it effortless.” I used a dull, old fashioned peeler (the kind with the serrated edges) and it took forever.
(2) Watch the tenderness of the squash. My final product came out mushy because I didn’t test it until too late. I prefer firm yet tender squash. With my mistake, I should have just pureed it, added some chicken stock or cream and made a soup.
Is there a good way to reheat this dish? I’d like to take it to a friend’s for Thanksgiving dinner.
Microwave? Haven’t tried reheating it, but it’s squash, and squash reheats well. ~Elise
Fabulous tips on browning butter. I too have needed to restart due to burnt butter.
Just last week I roasted local organic butternut squash with sage in a brown butter balsamic sauce. Trick- add the vinegar off heat since it will bubble up.
Mmmm…maybe this would be good with sweet potatoes, too?
This is a “can’t miss” recipe. I use a small amount of Herbs de Provence instead of thyme, but the concept is the same.
Even kids love this dish. You can make a lovely soup out of any leftovers with very little effort and a touch of chicken or turkey stock.
Oh, man. Let me tell you that this is awesome. I also do this with sweet potatoes and add a little crispy bacon at the end. It is awesome over a spinach filled ravioli with a little goat cheese crumbled in, too. This is one of the most versatile recipes you’ll use. It can stuff pasta, chicken breast, and is great as a stand alone side dish. Try a little rosemary, too.
Any tips on dicing up butternut squash? I’ve found it is pretty hard to cut up which is why I thought it was normally cooked whole.
Your dicing looks pretty beautiful though.
And the browned butter is just. MMM.
Here’s a guide to how to peel and cut a butternut squash. ~Elise