I used this recipe as a base, and tweaked it to suit my personal preferences. I was very pleased with the results.
• Same amount of olive oil• 1 medium onion, SMALL diced (I decided to reduce the amount of onion based on some of the other comments, and I was glad that I did).• Same amount of brown sugar• Same amount of Balsamic vinegar• Same amount of salt• Decreased pepper to ¼ tsp• Same amount of sour cream• Same amount of mayo• Added 3 slices of diced precooked bacon (I added the bacon after the onions were cooked for 20 minutes)• I doubled the Worcestershire sauce• Instead of garlic powder, I used dried garlic from a mill, a bit more “fresher” and not so fine in texture• I mixed the garlic and Worcestershire sauce into the sour cream/mayo before adding the onion/bacon• Chilled for one hour – taste tested – good. Waited another hour and tasted great!• I used this to stuff mini bell peppers and celery
Have fun with this one. I plan to experiment with other dried herbs in place of the garlic.
I made this as a raw veggie dip. I altered it to make it dairy-free for my daughter, using vegan mayo and non-dairy “sour cream”. There were way too many onions, for my personal liking (it was so chunky, it didn’t even look like dip, but more like onions in a thick sauce), so I used a strainer to remove them–after leaving it in the fridge overnight, so that the wonderful caramelized onion flavor throughly permeated the dip.
I’ve got only one question.For how long can you keep it in the fridge?
Hi George, I’m guessing a week or less.
Wonderful! We made this dip this afternoon. We used 2 1/2 onions and it was a lot of onion, but the dip was savory and sweet. Ate with Wavy Lays. What a treat!
This is good, notably more tastey than the Lipton’s freeze-dried recipe. However, it’s a dip for chips in front of a TV football game, not a dinner party appetizer; don’t think the significant extra effort is really warranted. Slightly different: Ruffles used to be the best, but lately they are mostly crumbs–in a 16oz bag, you get about 20 decent-sized chips and the rest are just bits, suitable only for baked chicken pieces. I did a comparison with Lay’s Wavy chips, which were a lot better for dipping.
It’s hard to find ingredients in Japan, so I was really happy to find this recipe. I made it twice in one weekend and both times everyone ate the entire batch. It’s fantastic! Thank you!
We made this dip yesterday for a pot luck supper at a friend’s house, and it was amazing! Made it exactly as written except for adding a couple of tablespoons of gorgonzola crumbles. It was stupendous! Oh, we also sprinkled smoked paprika and some chopped parsley on the top for a garnish. Every little bit was eaten. We brought Ruffles as well as unsalted Tim’s Cascade potato chips, which are crunchy and sturdy little scoopers. Another great recipe! Thanks, Elise!
I can smell the onions caramelizing already. Seems that this dip would be almost sweet, and might go really well with veggie chips like carrot, zucchini and sweet potato. I can’t wait to try it!
This was a great recipe for Super Bowl Sunday! I made some home made potato chips with it. I also substituted Greek yogurt for the sour cream to cut the calories a bit. I also had a lot of extra so I added pork chops, broccoli, parmesan cheese, and egg noodles to make a casserole concoction that has made a great lunch all week! :)
Oh no, but Oh yes! Thank you for this. I can’t get the onion soup mix here in Sweden and it’s a definite childhood comfort food of mine. My family actually sends me packets and now my kids eat it just like I did, with a too large scoop that ends up breaking the chip. But it’s so addictive you just have to try and scoop it up anyway, even though you know the chip will break. I will have to give this a try.
Hmmm_ I LOVE onion dip and will definitely try this as one of my FIRST attempts with using my new KitchenAid hardware… lol :-)
I will be putting the onions into the processor to make them a bit smaller before cooking. I do not think I would like having big pieces of onion in my dip, but I bet THAT is what a LOT of you really like about onion dip; the texture of the onions. Me?… more of a ‘smoothie’ kind of guy… lol
Yes, I KNOW that cooked onions can be ‘mushed down’ manually, but I love using gadgets_ hee hee.
Elise, thank you SO much for sharing!
Michel J. Gaudet
this was my contribution to the superbowl. It were awesome!
I have had the packet kind of dip you mention before and love the flavor, but never make it because of the salt content in those spice packets. I never thought to make it myself with fresh onions; thanks for the inspiration!
Also, just as a related aside, I’ve had a lot of luck making similar dips with nonfat Greek-style yogurt. It has a similar tang to sour cream, it’s loaded with protein, and it’s fat free.
Tried this dip today for a super bowl party. It was much sweeter than I thought it would be. Might skip the brown sugar altogether the next time. It was considered okay at the party, not great. Might also try some other savory flavors to enhance the dip.
I cannot believe how good this dip is!! Good thing we aren’t having a party for the big game — I get to keep it all to myself!! Will definitely add some crisp bacon next time.
I made this, did a side-by-side with the recipe on the Lipton’s envelope. Elise’s won the taste test. As one of my tasters commented, “Oh, yeah–this is definitely better. But come on–it’s onion dip! Do we really care? When we’re just trying to watch football?”
Yummy, I followed the instructions and viola it turned out great. But my son is allergic to mayo so I may try it with ranch dressing as a substitute.
And… now I can’t button my pants.
Thanks, Elise. Thanks.
I also have made Alton Brown’s Onion Dip, but I doubled the amount of onions. I will have to try this version. It seems to be right on the money! I was skeptical of the mayo until I made the dip. The mayo smooths out the sour cream and adds a great dimension to the taste.
imagine. dipping bacon in this. whoa. (i’ve made alton brown’s version of this dip and topped it with crispy shallots which really are beyond easy to make. a nice textural contrast.)
I made this exactly as written and liked it a lot. But what really made it sing for me was adding about a teaspoon of horseradish.
In coming up with the following recipe I found that using a lot of onion resulted in a sweeter flavor profile than I was after. So Elise I suspect yours is a little on the sweet side for me but I completely agree that it must be accompanied by Ruffles. :-) Re: Susan’s question about omitting the mayo, I often replace half or more of the mayo called for in a recipe with yogurt, but I thought the flavor was off in the dip when replacing all of the mayo.
1 tablespoon olive oil1/2 yellow onion diced fine1/4 teaspoon kosher salt1 cup sour cream (light or low fat is fine but not non fat)3 tablespoons mayonnaise3 tablespoons plain yogurt (I like Greek)1/2 teaspoon garlic powder1 tsp onion powder1/4 teaspoon ground pepper1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
In a saute pan over medium heat add oil, heat and add onions and 1/4 tsp salt. Cook the onions until they are caramelized, about 20 minutes. Remove from heat and set aside to cool. Mix the rest of the ingredients, and then add the cooled onions. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours, preferably overnight, and stir again before serving.
I agree with Elise the addition of the mayo gives the dip another quick and easy dimension of flavour.
You can use plain yogurt in place of the mayo, it gives a bit of tartness that balances nicely with the sweetness of the onions. I also use the low fat sour cream.
I really enjoy your recipes and have tried several. Thanks so much for all you do!
Oh, my. I think I need to make this, though I’m likely to use just sour cream. Which leads me to ask, does the mayo really add that much to justify buying it just for this? yes, I can be persuaded, it’s just not something I normally have on hand.
You can try it without. I like it with the mayo. It does add flavor. ~Elise
Favorite dipping technique:
I slowly push the ruffle chip vertically into the onion dip then ever so carefully and gently I pull it straight up so the dip grabs the ridges of the chip. This method insures you don’t break your chip in the dip, and others are not aghast at how much you take if you try the more selfish “scoop” technique.
Now this is what I’m talking about! YUM! I bet leftover dip (if there is any!) would be really good on a baked potato. So many times better than the onion soup mix dip!
My family has slathered their Ruffles Potato Chips with an Onion Dip so simple it is not worthy of Simply Recipes. Four generations have been given the task on holidays to mix 2 – 8 ounce blocks of cream cheese (softened) with about a fourth of a medium yellow onion(grated in the smallest blades of the grater so it almost juiced), garlic salt or garlic powder to taste (this generation uses a 1/2 teaspoon of garlic salt), and enough milk to give the “dipping” consistency (add it a little at a time). Christmas Eve parties rates a sprinkling of paprika & bright green parsley flakes. The dip doesn’t last long but you will taste the onion for days!
This sounds like just the sort thing to experiment on people with the game this Sunday. We’ve never made it from scratch, but looks too easy and delicious to resist! I might add a sprinkle of smoked paprika on the top for color when serving.
I agree that sliced onions in mine make it messy, will try chopped and the brown sugar next time. I do add some minced Chipotle chiles and a bit of the Adobo sauce since we love it spicy here. 3 cheers for Ruffles, the best!
I’ve made a similar onion dip by Ina Garten. It’s good, but she doesn’t suggest you chop the onions….just slice….it’s messy to eat but SO delicious. I love how you eat your onion dip with Ruffle Potato Chips. That’s the only way my husband thinks onion dip should be eaten. Classic!
Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.