I make this all the time. Family loves it! I make it as it is written.
Elise, this has become one of my favorite “go to” reciptes. Love it, fun to make, and it makes the kitchen smell like an Indian restaurant.
Hiya Keith! I’m so glad you like it!
Discovered this recipe a couple of days ago in your newsletter. Made it today… one word: FANTASTIC!!! Thankyou so much for so many easy and delicious dishes!
We have had this several times now and it’s a favorite. Last night, I messed up the proportions and ended up with very (very!) salty curry, so I quickly added some potatoes and a bit more water to even it out a bit. I cooked a whole-grain rice blend to go with it, with frozen peas in the rice. The combo of the peas and potatoes in addition to the normal, great flavors was particularly lovely. I used to “stretch” the sauce by adding garbanzo beans to a bit less chicken than called for, and that’s good, too. But from now on, it’s potatoes for me. :) Thank you for this recipe!
Does this freeze well? We love it, by the way – thanks!
Hi Ailbhe, I don’t know, I haven’t tried freezing it. But if you do, please let us know how it works for you.
I found you on Pinterest. Lucky thing! This is absolutely fantastic! Used half sweet and half hot curry. Wow. Will make it again and again! I’ll be checking out your other recipes!
Do you leave the oil in the pan after you remove the chicken?
Hi Carm, yes, you leave any residual oil in the pan after you remove the chicken.
What size Dutch oven would you recommend for this amount? Is 5qts enough or do you recommend 8qts?
We used a 5 1/2 quart pot and there was plenty of room.
Made this Amazing Curry last night and my husband and I both LOVED it! It was so satisfying. I used natural peanut butter and added honey at the very end, instead of sugar. I also roasted butternut squash as a side veggie, but ended up mixing it in on my plate – it was the perfect compliment. If I feel inclined to a vegetarian meal one night, I might use the squash instead of the chicken. Thanks for the recipe, your site is my go-to when I’m in need of a new recipe.
This was awesome, thank you!
Could you sub almond flour for a gluten free option? or just omit the flour? Just wondering, trying to adapt this for a friend who is allergic. Thanks!
Hi Michelle, I think rice flour might be a better option, as it is starchy, like regular flour.
SO good. Very, very flavorful. I have tried a few curry dishes from other sides in which needed much more seasonings/spices added to them, to make them not so bland in taste.I actually used organic extra firm tofu instead of the chicken and it seemed to taste just fine. I also added about tablespoon more peanut butter. I served it over long grain brown rice.
Thanks for the tasty recipe!
This is fantastic. All those extra bits at the end really set it off. Its instantly become my third favourite chicken dish from your site : the Moroccan tagine with lemon and olives which I have SO many times, and the Fesenjan, with pomegranate molasses and walnuts and now this. Ive even blogged the fesenjan (http://18.104.22.168/~sharonmi/persian-delight/Love your recipes.Going to try the basil /coconut next…!
Excellent! Do not omit the mint, it really makes the dish. My three young kids devoured this and asked if I would make it again soon.
Great recipe! I added onions and kabocha squash for substance, and it was delicious. I didn’t think the sauce would thicken up, but it did due to the floured chicken prior to panfrying. The sauce was at the right consistency, which is amazing, and it was very complex and layered (partially due to the curry we used: Zanzibar Curry Powder from Savory Spice). We ate with a white and brown mix of basmati rice because the flavor isn’t too forward like jasmine rice. Soooooo comforting after a single digit day in Colorado :)
This was very good! Delicious combination of flavors. I made it pretty much as given, though I didn’t have any mint, and I also substituted jalapenos for the serranos. Curry powder and peanut butter from Trader Joe’s. And yes, it took more like an hour to prep – but very much worth it!
This was amazing. My first attempt at curry and now I want to make more! Next I’ll try the basil coconut curry recipe you have on here. Thanks for a winning meal!!
I’ve never found a recipe on your site that I didn’t love – until now. This sounded so good, and with all the rave reviews, I had high hopes. I followed the recipe exactly, but the results were a little disappointing. It seemed to us that the peanut butter overwhelmed everything else, and that it was all just a little “flat”. There are different curry powders, so maybe that’s part of the problem (I used a yellow curry). Also the sauce was too thick – but I probably should have removed more of the excess flour/curry mixture from the chicken pieces before frying, or added more broth.
However, it was good enough to try again – next time I will decrease the amount of flour and peanut butter (and maybe try a different brand), and increase the curry. Also, I must say it was better left over.
Dear Sir or MadamI am interested in cooking. So I visited your site because I want to reference the cooking.Your recipe is easy to understand.I want to cook while watching your recipe.I would be grateful if you could answer my question.What kind of rice matches Chicken Peanut Curry?I am looking forward to hearing from you.
Hello Yuina, I would recommend a long grain rice, such as basmati.
I don’t know if you will post this since it seems all the posters that are shown are ones that love the dish. I made it per your instructions and was very disappointed. I really did not care for the dish at all. Don’t mean to offend anyone but it just was not to my liking, which is odd since I love curry and I love peanut butter. Obviously, I will not be preparing this dish again. Sorry!
I have to say I also was disappointed. It’s not that it was bad or inedible or anything. It is just not nearly as flavorful as I thought it was going to be. I love all the ingredients individually – so I thought this was going to be fantastic but alas….no. It seems to be missing something. Maybe I needed to use a different curry? I don’t know. I followed the recipe as written with the exception of using different types of hot pepper since I couldn’t find serranos. Anyway, I expected better.
This is awesome. The chicken was so tender and juicy. I did add about 1 1/2 cups more chicken broth since it was kind of thick, to thin it out. This will definitely go into my printed collection of favorite recipes. Me and hubby likes spicy but daughter does not so we added a good sprinkle of hot pepper flakes over our plate. We served over hot Jasmine rice. The only thing that surprised me was the prep time was more like an hour instead of 15 minutes. There is a lot of chopping, grating, etc. so unless you are a professional chef you will need more than 15 minutes prep time. This is one of my favorite sites. Rarely do I ever make a recipe from Elise we don’t absolutely love. Keep them coming!
Outstanding!! Forgot to toss the chicken in the curry and still quite good, but now I get to make it again!!
The recipe looks great. If I wanted to add some vegetables, what would you suggest?
We just made this for dinner and were very pleased! Thank you as always for sharing delicious recipes.
Could I toss it all into a Crock Pot and expect the same results?
Rarely can you toss recipe ingredients into a slow cooker and come out with the same result as a stove top recipe. There is a lot of flavor that comes from browning the meat first as well as the vegetables. That said, you can cook this on the stove to that point, and then put it in a slow cooker, no idea on the timing though.
Perfect recipe to satisfy ‘True Indian’ taste buds.
I made this with less chicken and the addition of chick peas — yummy! Thanks.
I’m going to make this with tofu, vegetables and veggie broth for a delicious vegan dinner! The sauce sounds delicious!
How can I turn this into a soup? Just decrease the amount of chicken an increase the liquid?
Love this recipe. However, a quick question: I’d like to make a tofu version of this, but I’m a newcomer to vegetarian cooking. Do any of you have suggestions for incorporating tofu instead of chicken?
I used chicken and tofu. But you can use tofu and vegetable broth. I used firm tofu, drained it, then cubed it. I gently tossed the tofu with the seasoned flour. Then I gently fried it in olive oil just to brown it a bit. I took it out of the pan and continued with the rest of the recipe. I added the tofu towards the very end. I didn’t want it to crumble much. I thought the tofu was a nice addition, you might consider adding some vegetables. This recipe is really tasty, be sure to add all the seasonings at the end. I’m not a fan of mint so I skipped that. This recipe is worth the effort.
Thanks so much! I’m excited to try this version.
This was a winner, Elyse. I made it tonight and served it over baked Arborio. As good as it was, I must agree with Paz’s comment of years ago: mint, curry and cilantro are not West African. i would have expected more cumin and hot chilies than the Asian influence. A good fusion, though.
…”the inspiration for this recipe comes from a West African soup recipe…”
Hi Paul, glad you liked it! I first made this soup so many years ago, I have no idea what additional changes I made to the source recipe in the book. I agree that it certainly doesn’t sound at all West African, but I do recall that the recipe from which I originally based this recipe was called West African in the book. So whatevah! The important thing is that it tastes good. :-)
This recipe looks delicious and I can’t wait to try it! I was wondering what kind of curry powder you used? I am used to making Indian food and not sure which would be the most appropriate. thank you!
I love all curries and stir fries that in any way integrate nuts/nut butters into the recipe. Peanuts, cashews, you name it, I love it! Good thing I’m not allergic!
I made the dish last friday.Today as the new recipe came I remmebered it was so tasty. My husband and my children thought it was Absolutely delicious!I used chicken breast and cooked it for 5 minutes.
I printed this recipe this morning and made the dish earlier this evening. My husband and I thought it was beyond AMAZING! Absolutely fabulous!
I used 525 grams of chicken and halved all the rest of the ingredients. The sauce was really thick — like we like it — probably because when I dumped the chicken into the wok, I dumped all the left over flour in as well (purely by accident).
While doing the dishes, my husband said that I can add this recipe to our collection of A+ recipes.
Good but would have liked more peanut taste. If I made it again I’d at least double the peanut butter. Used 2 green chilies instead of the serranos. Takes about 1hr to make with ingredients on hand. I like the idea of adding chickpeas, with carrots, peas or green beans.
I made this recipe to a T and it was amazing. It was very flavorful and filling.
I’m a cooking newbie, and I’m always hesitant to experiment on my own. I’m wondering if this recipe could be made in a slow cooker, maybe simmered for a couple of hours? I work at home and it would be nice to start dinner cooking at lunch, so its ready when I “leave” the office at 5. Plus, seems like the chicken would only get better the longer it simmers in the curry?
Sounds like a worthy experiment. If you try to make it in a slow cooker, please let us know how it turns out for you. ~Elise
I tried it in the slow cooker today. It is good but I feel like the flavors all became very mellowed instead of richer. I prefer cooking it the tried and true way but it definitely isn’t bad in the slow cooker if you have no time.
We had this for dinner last night, with white rice, okra, and orange juice. Amazing, delicious, out-of-this-world! Thank you.
Krissypants, I used TraderJoe’s natural peanut butter. I used salted, but I think the unsalted would have worked better, as there’s plenty of salt in the chicken stock. My husband doesn’t like spicy food, so I replaced the chili peppers with a red bell pepper. My cilantro had gone to slime, so I substituted dill weed. Next time, I’m going to add some chick peas and carrots to the sauce.
And, yeah, I’m with nyush. I didn’t let a drop of this goodness go to waste.
Absolutely fabulous! Added cubed potato & very thin sliced carrots and 1/2 cup sugar. Restaurant quality!
I’ve made so many recipes from your blog, and they are always reliably delicious! This was amazing and more than what I was hoping it would be. Although it was tasty on its own, the garnishes elevated this delicious curry! I made some relatively minor changes: used only 1 lb of chicken thighs (that’s all I had), made the same amount of sauce (b/c i’m ALL about the sauce), added some carrots, chick peas, and green peas, and served over quinoa. This was amazing. I licked the pan clean after I transferred the leftovers. Thank you so much! I love your site.
I love this recipe. It is our new household favorite. I have a toddler who doesn’t like anything spicy, so I hold the peppers and my hubby and I use hot sauce to our taste. I experimented with the rice by adding some of the mint leaves in the water while it cooked. It gave the rice a wonderful mint scent and a little added mint flavor.
This recipe was absolutely spectacular! Easy to prepare, we ate until there was no more! We sat at the dining room table and wondered aloud if it would be over the top to make another batch! Thanks for this!
This was wonderful! Thank you Elise.
This recipe was delicious. It was my first curry ever and my roommate loved it. I did leave out one of the chilies, because I don’t handle spicy very well. However, I think it would have been okay. There was just the barest hint of spicy, it actually could have used a bit more kick.
My roommate commented that it smelled more like peanut than it tasted and she would have liked if that flavor were stronger.
The mint, cilantro, and lime juice were the perfect contrast to finish up this dish. Thanks Elise for such a wonderful recipe.
This was excellent. Really suited me since it is dairy free and curries usually have dairy. Thanks for the recipe. Will make this again!
I recently found your site and this recipe….I am eating it right now and it is fantastic. Cannot wait to try out your other recipes…I am eyeing that rhubarb drink right now.
I didn’t have a few of the ingredients for this recipe but made it anyway with what I had and it was delicious.
I used potatoes instead of chicken, and left out the chili peppers, garlic, corriander, mint, cilatro and lime, and used a white onion instead of green onions. (I know that’s half of the ingredients, hehe)
It’s even good cold from the fridge. Will definitely have to try the full recipe.Yum :) Thanks
This has become a new “old favorite” of mine; as a matter of fact I am making it tonight!
Even my 88 year old Grannny (who’s never had curry before) loves it! Thanks for this great recipe.
Wow! Absolutely delicious recipe. I’m definitely going to make this for my family! Thanks for sharing it. :D
Just wondering what kind of peanut butter to use. I usually eat the Real brand of peanut butter which has no added sugar. Would this work for the recipe or would you recommend something like Jif or Skippy which has added sugar?
I used no added sugar peanut butter and it was delicious
This was so easy and delicious. I used boneless skinless thighs and they worked really well. It was even more delicious the next day. Don’t skip the garnishes- they really make the dish!
Hi, I just tried a really similar recipe for Groundnut Stew that sounds like the same thing, from an African woman’s family recipe. It’s super-economical (from a blog on $5 family meals), and if you start with a whole roasting chicken you can end up with many servings to freeze. 1 chicken. 1 onion. 6-8 c water. (you can add stock stuff: celery, carrots, salt & pepper). Boil chicken, remove meat from bones, shred/ split into manageable pieces. Put chicken back in strained broth, and add:1 can diced/crushed tomatoes or a few of the real thing. 1 onion, diced. Red pepper to taste. 1 jar natural peanut butter (separated into chunks to help dissolve). Boil until oil rises to the top. Feel free to add more water. Serve over rice (can make into balls first). Feeds 8.
I originally learned this recipe from some family from the Ivory Coast. I then found this recipe and used it to tweak what already had.It’s so delicious I’m making it again for a dinner party tonight…
This was fantastic! I served mine with couscous instead of rice.
Visiting our daughters and son-in-law in Colorado-hungry for peanut chicken curry-dida search, this recipe came up-Excellent!! We didn’t use the coriander seeds, mint or cilantro-and put the chili peppers on the sidefor those who wanted more spice. The mealwas served with brown rice and mixed AsianVegies-we had great reviews from the family.Thanks so much!!
You score again. I made this last night and it was so good I had to stop eating it so I’d have leftovers. I had to improve a teensy bit because I didn’t have stuff on hand (no cilantro, just mint; no serranos; one orange pepper and some thai chili peppers) but it was wonderful, it’s def. going in my popular rotation. Thanks!
Hi, I have recently found your webpage and love it! I tried this recipe the other night and my boyfriend and I couldn’t get enough! We love the combination of spicy with a hint of sweetness! Thanks for the great recipe! Yummy, yum, yum!!!
I made this for dinner, and HOLY COW was it excellent! I tweaked it a little – I used a pound of chicken, but only halved the rest of the recipe. I also used 1/4 of a HUGE red jalapeno. In the end, I decided I wanted it “saucier” so I mixed some cornstarch/cold water and added enough so it was just thickened up enough for what I was in the mood for.
Just tried this recipe over the weekend and it was SO DELICIOUS! Elise, you’ve done it again. There’s no use referring to epicurious as long as you’re around posting these wonderful recipes. Many thanks!
Your Chicken Peanut Curry Recipe sounds delicious. I grew up in the central Africa region, in Zaire (Belguim Congo, now DRC), and frequently enjoyed a similar, but much simpler, recipe…Central African Curry Chicken:4-6 chicken breasts, cubed 1″ pieces4 large tomatoes, diced small4 large onions, diced small3-6 Tbsp curry, depending on your taste level26-28 oz. jar of Chuncky peanut butter2 oz. roasted peanuts (optional)While browning the chicken in a frying pan, place the tomatoes and onions in a 5-6 qt. stock pot and simmer for 35-45 minutes. Add the peanut butter and curry and simmer for about 30 minutes until the consistancy is uniformly smooth. Add the chicken and continue to simmer while you prepare the rice. Serve over the rice, sprinkle the roasted peanuts and enjoy.
Hi Gary – I think it would be quite hard to eat this dish without rice, which is why I didn’t categorize it low carb. What do you think, should it be in the low carb category anyway?
Hi Alyssa – please do share the recipe if you are able to get it.
Hi Cinara – I’ve been collecting interesting pieces of ceramics and china for years. Now I finally have a use for my odd indulgence. What, an excuse to buy individual pieces of china? I’m in heaven.
I made this with cauliflower “rice” and it was delicious! Could definitely be low carb.
Oh I also battered it with coconut flour instead of traditional flour which was also yummy and added a nice flavor
Besides the wonderful recipes you are so kind in sharing with us, I was wondering about the stunning plates and dishes you use in your pictures! There are so many different ones, and they sure make your recipes look even yummier!Are they all yours or are they borrowed? Do you buy them specially for the site pictures? Do you keep all of them? Anyway, you have a great taste for dishes too!Best regards from Brazil…
For very Indian tasting curry powder, lightly fry in 1tsp of oil the following at low flame:2 inches cinnamon stick, 1 green cardamom (whole but crushed-so that it does not splatter), 4-5 cloves, 1/2 tsp cumin seeds, 5-6 black pepper corns. Fry until your kitchen fills with a pleasant aroma of spices. Grind the fried spices without water. Use as much as you need and store the rest in air tight container in the fridge for upto 15 days! To make it more hot, add 1-2 Indian red chillies or Thai red pepper (dry) while frying.
Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.