Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
The stew was delicious! However I had an epic fail when I tried to make my own pomegranate molasses! I ended up with a pomegranate lollipop! I substituted balsamic vinegar reduction and it seemed to work well. Is there a temperature one can test while making the molasses? Maybe use a candy thermometer?
Hi Penny, So glad you liked the stew! It does sound as if you reduced that pomegranate juice a little bit too much. From my years of jelly making, I would guess that the temp of the syrup when boiling should be about 220°F, or 8° above the boiling temperature at your altitude. Lollipop (“hard ball”) stage liquid will be at about 250°F, firm stage would be at about 244°F.
Thank you for the advice. Going to give it another try and will test with a thermometer!
Hey Elise! I love this recipe! I’ve made it a couple times now.
I’m curious about the peeling and then scoring of the eggplant. Skin is where most of the nutrition is in most vegetables – presumably also eggplant – and some of the skin is left on. Why not leave it all on? In sweating eggplants, I’ve never seen instructions to cut hashmarks in them (though that may be due to my inexperience with eggplants). So I’m wondering if it’s important to do. (These both represent time-saving measures if the steps can be eliminated.) Also, it seems like rinsing the eggplants afterward partially defeats the purpose of sweating them, and also washes away the salt that I’m going to otherwise add to the recipe later. Why not blot the water away, keep the salt, and then I don’t need to add more salt later (so long as I know how much I used to sweat the eggplants with)?
Hi Tim, typically I peel or partially peel globe eggplants because the peel itself is so tough. It’s not pleasant to eat if there is too much of it. Japanese eggplants are different—thin skinned, so you don’t need to peel those.
Scoring the eggplant slices helps the salt penetrate and release more moisture from the eggplant. That is the purpose of the salt—to release moisture from inside the eggplant. You rinse off the salt and pat dry because otherwise the eggplant will be way way too salty.
Thanks for the additional info, Elise!
I also realize that I’m confused about the mint called for here. While there is “mint” available among cut herbs at grocery stores, I’ve no idea whether this is spearmint, apple mint, peppermint, or some other variety of mint that I might have in my garden. Can you clarify?
Hi Tim, I’ve only ever seen spearmint in the markets here, so that is what we are using in this recipe.
just this morning came across this recipe (it sounds great!) but am also wondering about the instructions to score the eggplant slices – which side of the eggplant slice is to be scored – is it the outside or the inside or does it make no difference? Thanks
Hi Rick, score the inside of the eggplant slices.
Made this delicious meal for dinner last night — we really enjoyed it. I love pomegranate molasses — I purchase it from a local restaurant so I always have it on hand. I really like the addition of the lentils.
I’m slightly confused about the ‘bringing to the boil’ part for the very last step. I see no instruction to add water and it’s a bit worrying that the veg won’t have enough moisture. What should I do? Just put in everything with no water and turn on the heat? What is there to bring to the boil? Will the vegetables seep out enough moisture?
Hi Sammy, I’ve changed the instructions to make them a bit more clear. There is some liquid in the stew – oil, pomegranate molasses. Bring it to a simmer then cover and reduce the heat.
Yum Yum. Made for my daughter in law who is a wegan (vegan on weekdays!). I made the pomegrante molasses from scratch. It really blends in with the flavors, so hard to distinguish but, added color for sure and some sweetness. It took much less than 1. 5 hours. Probably closer to 50 minutes. Also scorched the Le Crueset pot I used, so glad I was checking regularly.
I also found the directions for the eggplant confusing, but just winged it and it turned out great. Used 1 jalapeno, because that’s what I had on hand and certainly didn’t use as much oil as called for. Served over Israeli couscous. Next time though would probably serve over brown rice for the chewiness factor.
Wow! I normally don’t like any type of stew but this is amazing. I don’t even think it needs honey. I made my own pomegranate molasses and cooked the whole thing in a stainless steel pot since I don’t own an enameled cast iron casserole dish. It was perfect!
Used this as an accompaniment to duck and so it was perfect – the sweet tartness of the molasses and the gentle heat from the chillies off setting the richness of the duck.
I used puy style lentils and red chillies – being what I had to hand – so very good.
This recipe is in my top 5! I couldn’t find pomogranate molasses so I made my own. So tasty and filling knocked my socks off! Can’t wait to make it again.
First of all, thank you! I bought the molasses for a different recipe and had no idea what I’d do with it, and since the weather in NYC is perfect for a stew, I chose your recipe. To mention that I’ve never made stew or cooked eggplants or lentils would tell you that I’m a novice cook but a daring one.
I was confused with the eggplant instructions but once I visualized it, it was no problem. Make ### marks all over the pieces! No problem.
It turned out quite amazing, with a capital A. I didn’t put any honey because I’m cooking for a vegan, but next time I’d put some agave if need be. It’s slightly tart but delicious.
This was so delicious. I was especially happy to have finally cooked eggplant well! It’s usually the bane of my cooking, but this turned out wonderfully.
I used thin Chinese eggplants cut into chunks for this recipe and left the skin on, and those work just as well as the larger eggplants.
It was very yummy! I added dried apricots, cinnamon, and garnished with pomegranate seeds and mint at the end
I found this recipe searching for pomegranate mollasses. I had bought some on a whim, because I love pomegranate.
I didn’t do too well with this recipe; certainly didn’t “wow”. For one, it turned into mush mainly because I bought the wrong type of lentils, the red ones or petite crimson (looking for flavor and color). So may want to add a note to this recipe about that. Another contributing factor to mush was overcooking, but I had cooked it for about an hour as instructed. I don’t think you would really need to pre-cook any lentils for very long if at all if you are going to cook all this for an hour. On the otherhand, the eggplant goes to mush too, even as the somewhat thick slices as instructed, so may want to ease up on cooking time perhaps check it at 30 minutes by poking at the eggplants on top.
I’m also not sure I like cutting the egg plants longitudinally because it seems more difficult to maintain an even thickness this way rather than in rounds (unless perhaps you square it off). Perhaps an additional photo or two on the process would help.
All in all, this had nice flavors but I might add some additional middle eastern spices. Personally I wouldn’t add honey or sugar that’s why I like pomegranate; needs to be specific about lentil types, cooking time, eggplant thickness, to work on the texture perhaps. I know there’s debate, but I’m still not convinced salting eggplant is necessary.
Hello Thomas, good point on the lentils. Yes, you should use brown lentils. I’ve now clarified that in the ingredients. Red lentils have a very different taste and they completely turn to mush after just a few minutes of cooking. Here’s some more information on the difference between brown, green, and red lentils. ~Elise
I threw in garbanzos (not canned but dried, then soaked overnight and slightly cooked), which added a great texture to the soft lentils and eggplant. Great recipe and I’m not a vegetarian!
WOW. One of the best vegetable (vegan at that) stews I’ve had. Since it’s only veggies, use only the best you can find. Although I found half the oil was enough for me.
Has anyone tried making this in a slowcooker? I’d love to hear about how long you cooked it for and how it turned out.
I want to express my appreciation for this blog. It has literally taught me how to cook since getting married! I love the recipes and the clear, unassuming way they are presented. Thank you.
That being said, I want to make this soup for my in-laws. My father-in-law has a lot of food restrictions so this is one of the few recipes that will work for him. I too am wondering about cutting the eggplants — should there be any skin left on them when they begin cooking? I will follow the explicit directions you posted on how to cut them, but I am still not sure if, in the end, it should just be chopped bits without the skin or if there are unpeeled pieces being cooked.
Thanks a lot.
You cut peel the eggplant in stripes, so that there are some stripes of peel left on the eggplant. This means that some of the eggplant pieces will have some peel on them. ~Elise
I made this tonight, and it was great! I added the honey (about 2 Tbsp) to the vegetable mixture and I served it over casbah couscous. My 13 year old practically licked the plate! Thanks, Elise.
Made this for dinner and it was delicious. I decided to cook it on the stove top for 15 minutes and then 40 in the oven at 400 degrees. We topped it with a little feta cheese and it turned out really well!
This is absolutely delicious. But I had the same experience as Rose with the thick layer of char. Is there any reason to do it in this layered way rather than just stir everything together so it doesn’t stick to the bottom?