Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Made this in a presure cooker. Came out perfectly. 40 minutes and it was done. I added a squeeze of lemon juice and it elevated this dish tremendously. Give each guest a lemon slice on the plate. Thank you. It was wonderful
So glad you liked it Marthinus!
Hi Elise! This is my first time commenting (shameface) but your website is our go-to and everything has always turned out absolutely delicious. Super late in the game but, I started this recipe and forgot that we don’t have cream or half and half, which is what I’ve used before for it. I just have milk, but I also have creme fraiche and was wondering if that would work as a substitute? I know the consistency isn’t the same, but I figure it’ll reduce in the braise anyway. No worries if you don’t see this in time!
Actually never mind, looks like you can use a combo of milk and butter to sub for cream. Woohoo!
First of all, I added the parsley at the earlier point. When I make it again, I will do the same AND add some at the end. This is a great dish! I could not stop eating it! Wow! The barley worked really really well. Will try the spelt next time. Keep these great recipes coming–so glad I found this website!!
I’m in the process of making this right now and it’s already delicious and I’m not done. However, I have a question–you have me adding the parsley with the garlic and fennel seed, then again at the end. Which is it, or both? Thanks so much–I can’t wait to eat it. I’m substituting barley for the farro, which I cannot find. I did find spelt but am not using it today. Is spelt actually a good substitute? Thanks–your website is absolutely the best!
Hi Holly, good catch on the instructions. Add the fresh parsley at the end. Regarding spelt and barley, both make good substitutions for farro. ~Elise
Just made this tonight and it was a huge hit. Had to send husband out for emergency parsley run during the early stages because I’d forgotten to read the ingredients list all the way through. Wonder if it would have worked without the parsley? Would love your thoughts on that. Made the FARRO too! My first time — what a crazy delicious grain! Elise, I am a huge fan of your website. Your recipes are go-to for me. Especially the chile verde. It was a huge leap of faith to try braising in milk — and as I’d bought four pounds of lamb (originally for guests — long story). It came out perfect. I can’t wait to eat it again tomorrow! (Am assuming it reheats well.)
Hi Julie, so glad it worked out for you! I know how nerve wracking that can be, especially when you make a big $ commitment for the ingredients. Here’s the deal with parsley. It’s a “bitter”. Your tongue can only taste five things – salty, sweet, sour, bitter, and umami (you’ll have to look the last one up if you are unfamiliar with it.) A well balanced dish hits many of these tastes. This recipe doesn’t have acid, but it does have sweet (fennel), salt, and bitter (parsley). A bitter can also help balance the fat in a recipe, the way acid (lemon juice) can. So yes the recipe can be made without the parsley, but the parsley does help balance the flavors. And I agree, farro is crazy good! ~Elise
When I told my husband that this was what I was making, he wasn’t excited, and in fact urged me to “take it easy tonight, I’ll just make a sandwich.” I explained that for once I had shopped for a recipe and I WANTED to make it. I served it up when he was enjoying football on TV, and he couldn’t stop exclaiming how good it was. He wanted to take some with him for lunch today. We were both VERY impressed. I’m inclined to prepare lamb more often if it can be this easy, and tender, and flavorful (without being overpowering).
I made this a few nights ago. It was fabulous and received rave reviews. I put the lamb on a bed of brown rice too which I added raisins for sweetness and crushed red peppers for warmth. To blend the sauce I just used my stab mixer right in the dutch oven. I served chopped red cabbage on the side.
I have some rice and sauce still left over. I’m planning on grilling pork chops tonight and finish it off.
This reminds me of a bizarre conversation I had one day with a meat exhibitor at the Minnesota State Fair. I was perplexed by the size of the “leg of lamb” on display and asked what it was. “Lamb” was the reply. I commented that it was too big to be lamb and the exhibitor, looking at me as if I was very stupid, told me that lamb is sheep’s meat like beef is cow and pork is pig.
As an Australian, I replied that lamb is baby sheep’s meat and that anything older than a year wasn’t lamb but mutton or if it was really old, hogget. Needless to say I then got the cold shoulder.
But I do think that is the problem that many Americans have with so-called lamb. What is sold is actually older than lamb and has a strong flavour which takes some getting used to. To get lamb, you have to specifically ask for “baby lamb,” however much of a tautology that might be.
As for me, I will make this recipe with lamb when the temperature gets out of the 90s.
This recipe looks great. I wondering if the sauce will be okay if I skip the blender since I don’t have one. Would it be all separated?
Personally I think the sauce needs to be blended. But if you skip that, please let us know how it works out for you. ~Elise
What an awesome idea! This makes me think of a couple of cooking tips I learned somewhere…that you soak meat in milk to help tenderize it, and that soaking game meats (like venison) in milk helps to reduce the “gamey” flavor when cooked. I wonder if this preparation does a little of both? I know that there are some people don’t like lamb when it is a bit stronger flavored–do you think it helps soften this a bit?
Hi Rachael, don’t know about the tenderizing, but I do think it mellows the flavor a bit. ~Elise
I’ll definitely try this as grass-fed lamb is my faaaaavorite red meat! Will have to try something other than the farro, though, as “less gluten” is still too much gluten for my son and me (and too much starch/glucose for my BG, too). Usually I make some sort of roasted, smashed, or cauliflower puree side dish instead of a side starch. Or Turnips Anna with lots o’ grass-fed butter…mmmm.
Hey, looks like a great recipe. I’m just curious: won’t the milk curdle if it’s boiled too hard? Is there a certain type of milk that should be used (full fat, 2%, etc)?
If it curdles, it’s okay. You’ll be blending it all in the sauce anyway. As for the type of milk, I used 2%. I don’t think it matters because you’re adding a bunch of cream. ~Elise
A milk reduction for a sauce sounds so obvious but innovative at the same time. Do you know if it would work as well with skim milk?
You mean skim milk plus skipping the cream? Don’t think so. The sauce needs the fat in the cream to thicken it. If you use skim milk and keep the cream, then yes, it should work fine, though you might need to add a bit more cream. ~Elise
Hello… any Italians out there? I live in italy and I would assume that this recipe would be okay for abbacchio, which is much younger than american lamb, I think. Working with italian lamb would there be any additional ingredients? or cooking times? I almost think that the addition of fennel to “italian” lamb would be kind of strong, what do you think? thx. kathy
Yum! I actually just made a pork loin braised in milk over the weekend ( I haven’t posted about it yet) and it was delicious! Plus interesting and so different. I love the idea of using fennel to flavour the sauce.
This looks delicious. Do you think it could be made with lamb shanks instead of lamb shoulder? I have some lamb shanks in my fridge and am looking for a way to cook them.
Lamb shanks may take longer to cook before they are tender, but other than that, should work fine. If they are bone-in, you might try cooking the dish bone-in just for kicks (and added flavor). ~Elise
Lamb is a favorite in our house – and barley makes a great combination with most lamb dishes in case you can’t find farro. I do plan to try this. In Venezuela we cook lamb in coconut milk, but the seasonings are quite different.
Yep, farro reminds me a lot of barley too. Love the idea of cooking lamb in coconut milk, care to share the seasonings you would use? ~Elise
What a great recipe! I would keep a few pieces of fennel instead of pureeing all…just for the sake of texture and presentation.
Would it work with veal?
Haven’t tried it with veal, but if you do, please let us know how it turns out for you. ~Elise