Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
I made the cake and it smelled wonderful it even tasted good, however, it was DRY. What did I do wrong? I’m willing to try it again. Plus, the top was crazy looking that the cake couldn’t rest level on the plate.
Hi Robin, perhaps in your oven you need less time to cook this cake. Also, bundt cakes typically have the issue of an uneven top. You can fix it by using a long serrated bread knife to even the top so that it sits evenly on the plate.
This is arguably the best cake I’ve ever made! I added a tablespoon of orange zest and swapped one teaspoon of vanilla for almond extract. I used cake flour and the imperial whatever it is butter substitute because it was way cheaper than butter. I made whipped cream and added vanilla and almond extract and powdered sugar. I used Nordic Ware’s heritage bundt pan… Got lots of compliments on the presentation, and sighs of pleasure when we finally dug in. It was a huge hit! My only issue was that the edges got pretty hard and crust like (which people actually liked-could be due to the ridges of the bundt pan), but then there were small pockets of very very slightly undercooked cake near the top (which when flipped was the bottom). We kept it in for ten minutes longer, but not sure how to evenly cook it in the future. Still tasted divine and was quite easy to pull together. This is a five star recipe! Thanks, Elise! You’ll make gourmet cooks of us all
Ok, I prepared this one last week and, as always, the recipe worked perfect (with margarine, despite my wife’s complaints). Without a problem, I got a perfect pound cake that looked perfect for a magazine cover. I added the zest of one lemon and the aroma and flavor just got better. However it still looks a little dry to me so next time (It will be next time) I will try with adding some liquid (I’ve heard of milk, yogurt or even sprite, like half a cup or so) and see what happens. I would go back to butter as well, just for the sake of the health and stuff. Thanks Elise!
Hi Miguel, if you try it with butter, please let me know how it turns out! I also love adding yogurt or sour cream to pound cakes, makes them more moist and dense.
I make it exactly the same except i alternate 2eggs with 1 cup of all purpose flour using 3cups of flour. I’ve never used cake flour nor have I shifted it but going to try it sounds yummy
Thanks For the receipe
Thank you for posting this recipe. My grandmother, Bigmama, made a pound cake with powdered sugar and I was searching for something like it. This pound cake is it! I used Imperial margarine, because that is what I had. I have started using it again, as the laws have changed and it does not have trans fat anymore. I was very careful to cream the margarine and sugar very well, until really fluffy. And I was careful to just barely mix in the flour, so gluten did not develop. It was rich and dense on the inside, crispy on the outside, all around perfect. I will keep this recipe to pass down to my daughters. Thanks again!
After my mom passed away, I inherited her recipe box, which was also my grandmother’s. Inside the box was “the” cake recipe I remember from my childhood, only when we had company! I had to google it, and ended up here! This recipes has been around for ages, and for good reason. I wonder where it originated? The handwritten copy of it I have is at least from the early 60’s. No matter, it’s a delicious cake and brings back memories. Thanks for sharing it.
I believe Imperial margarine put out this recipe. I’ve had mine for years and it’s called “The Imperial Pound Cake”
I haven’t made this cake yet, but I can already say your mother is wrong about one thing. There’s a third type of person–one that loves cakes and pies equally–and that’s me!
I love the simplicity of this recipe. Cooking Light has a great brown sugar pound cake for another option that’s not too sweet but absolutely delish…almost caramelly. It’s on myrecipes.com.
I followed the recipe exactly just today; even purchased a new bundt pan.
It is soo good. Cut slices very thin because I didn’t have topping. Tomorrow out for strawberries.
Caution: I checked cake at 1-hr and only left it in for about 10 min. more, if that, only because it looked a little pale on top. Perfect and DELISH! Slid right out of the pan. I imagine this recipe has probably only 1/2 of calories/saturated fat as butter.
Thank you Mrs. Adams.
I was wondering why this recipe doesn’t need baking powder/soda? I tried this a while ago without cake flour (I used all purpose with cornstarch) and the cake turned out hard and heavy… But the taste was amazing~ Was it because I didn’t sift the flour so it’s light? I shouldn’t use self raising flour next time, should I? Haha. I’m sorry, it’s just I can’t purchase cake flour… Thank you for sharing. :)
Pound cake is traditionally made with a pound of flour, a pound of eggs, and a pound of butter. That’s why it’s called pound cake. The eggs are the leavening, which is why you don’t need baking powder or baking soda. Cake flour has less gluten in it than all purpose flour (in contrast with bread flour which has more gluten), which is why the crumb is light when you use cake flour. Cake flour is ideal for making cakes. ~Elise
Does it have to be in a bundt cake pan? I don’t have one… Could I just use a normal round cake pan instead?
Pound cakes are typically made in a loaf pan or in a bundt cake pan, not a round cake pan. If you make it in a round cake pan, you will likely need to reduce the cooking time (I don’t know how much, you’ll have to guestimate). ~Elise
My Aunt prepared this for my grandaughter this summer. It is so perfect. She (my Auntie) is now 93. She had a few disaters in the past. One just has to patient..She sifts her Swansdown flour..Always uses butter…and always have to be careful not to overcook. I believe she alternates the flour and egg..making sure the egg is last. My 10 yr old grandaughter called me for the ingredients. Thank goodness you were here. The recipe is in my Auntie’s head and not written down anywhere!
This recipe is pretty much the classic pound cake (“ye pound” of butter, flour, eggs and sugar). If yours was rubbery, I suspect you didn’t mix it properly. You really do need to cream the butter and sugar together for at least two minutes, and add the rest of the ingredients slowly.
I followed this recipe to a T expecting the best pound cake I’ve ever had – it was a disaster. Like many a poster above the result of two loaf pans instead of a tube pan ended up in the garbage. The very top was baked a nice crumbly cake – the rest was almost gelatinous and rubber-like as if the flour had congealed. I baked it twice as long and then flipped them over and baked again, and then sliced and baked the flat slices and still would not turn into “cake”. If I made this in a tube pan would it actually turn out right, I’m now more apprehensive to remake it.
This recipe is the same as the one I’ve been using for 25 years.
This is a really EASY cake to make. It’s perfect for beginners. Just follow the recipe and you’ll look like a culinary queen (or king).
Although the recipe I received from my home econ friend, Roz called for margarine, I use butter and it works perfectly.
In the beginning, I used regular flour sifted 3 times. Now I use cake flour. Both work equally well but the cake flour saves time.
Tips from 3 generations: Let the eggs and butter sit out until they reach room temperature. The batter will be silky and the texture perfect.
Experiment with different flavors. I love almond or lemon or orange (so far). Enjoy!
I was looking for a simple recipe that i could make for Thanksgiving dinner and let me tell you that this cake is very simple and so good.
It is not very sweet and that’s what i think made everyone like it so. I was thinking about making it again and this time using butter, but I think that I will stick with the Imperial margarine and maybe add some lemon yest to it.
At first, I decided to make this cake for my sister-in-law, who loves pound cake. I have never been a big fan myself. Now, after baking this wonder twice, let me tell you all how delicious this cake is! I baked it both using butter, in a loaf pan, and using Imperial margarine, in a bundt pan. Both times without baking soda, or baking powder. Both cakes came out smelling, looking and tasting great; and they disappeared very fast. I could not help adding fresly grated lemon zest, though, into the batter. This is my grandma`s recipe, and I believe it just makes the taste come out so much better. Thank you for this wonderful recipe!
I’ve been making this pound cake for 40 plus years and if you subsitute butter for the Imperial it is a completely different taste to the cake and it is not as moist and smooth and the crumb texture is different.
Like all recipes if you change an ingredient you change the original taste.