New Jersey Italian Hot Dog

Hot Dog

A New Jersey classic hot dog, with fried potatoes, peppers and onions, served with deli mustard on a hoagie roll.

Photography Credit: Elise Bauer

Jersey boy Hank Shaw is back, and with his favorite home town hot dog. Enjoy! ~Elise

I was a boy the first time I ate this sandwich. I remember being somewhere around 13 years old at the time, and I went down with my stepfather Frank to a place called the Corner Store in Fanwood, New Jersey.

Frank always bought the newspaper and coffee at the store, which, oddly, was not on a corner. I can’t remember why we were there around lunchtime, only that I was hungry, and that Frank suggested I get an Italian Hot Dog. Seemed like a decent enough idea.

When the cook handed it over the deli counter, it did not look anything like any hot dog I’d ever eaten. For starters, it was on a sub roll, and was huge. Four hot dogs lurked within that roll, but you could barely see them—they were covered in a jungle of potatoes, peppers and onions that had been grilled on the deli’s flattop.

New Jersey Italian Hot Dog

I took a bite, and instantly tasted a hit of deli mustard. Then the tangy hot dog—I love that pop! you get when you bite through the casing—and finally that curious, breakfasty combination of potatoes, peppers and onions. This was good! I ate the whole thing, which probably weighed close to two pounds, long before we even got home, just a few miles away.

This is my Jersey dog.

I know there are other versions, some with special bread, some where everything inside, including the hot dog, has been deep-fried. I’ve even heard of a few versions of this sandwich that use ketchup, a condiment which, when combined with a hot dog, will get you whacked in most parts of Jersey. I like those Italian hot dogs, too. (Except for the ones with ketchup) But this one always reminds me of that otherwise unmemorable day I spent with my dearly departed stepdad long ago. It’s a memory I still hold close.

New Jersey Italian Hot Dog Recipe

  • Prep time: 10 minutes
  • Cook time: 35 minutes
  • Yield: Serves 4-6

Ideally you would find the special pizza bread roll, which is round, like a muffuletta roll. These can be hard to find, though, so use a good sandwich loaf. Try to avoid using a hot dog bun; those are too small for the Jersey dog.


  • 1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil
  • Salt
  • 2 pounds potatoes, peeled and cut into 1/2 inch chunks
  • 2 medium green peppers, sliced into strips
  • 1 large yellow or white onion, sliced into strips
  • 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning, or a mixture of oregano, basil and rosemary
  • 8 beef hot dogs, preferably with natural casings
  • 4 sandwich buns
  • Mustard


1 Fry the potatoes: Heat the olive oil in a large frying pan or skillet or griddle until it shimmers. Put the potatoes in the pan in one layer and fry on medium-high heat for 2-3 minutes without touching them.

Use a metal spatula to scrape the potatoes off the bottom of the skillet, flipping them. Sprinkle salt over the potatoes, and cook for another 2-3 minutes without touching them.

2 Brown the peppers and onions, add back the potatoes: Remove the potatoes, which should be partially browned, to a bowl and set aside. Increase the heat to high and add the peppers and onions. Arrange evenly in the pan and cook for 2-3 minutes without touching them.

Sprinkle salt over them, then flip and cook for another 2-3 minutes untouched. There should be some browned and even blackened bits here and there.

Add the Italian seasoning and the potatoes to the pan, stir to combine and cook over medium-high heat until they are soft and nicely browned, about 8-10 minutes.

3 Grill the hot dogs: Heat a grill or a frying pan to cook your hot dogs; don't boil your dogs for this recipe. Grill or fry until they are done to your liking and set aside.

4 Assemble: Liberally smear mustard on both sides of the sandwich roll. Add two hot dogs per roll and top with as much of the potatoes, peppers and onions as will fit. Serve at once.

Hello! All photos and content are copyright protected. Please do not use our photos without prior written permission. Thank you!

This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Simply Recipes. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.


More on the Jersey Italian Hot Dog - from Serious Eats


Hank Shaw

A former restaurant cook and journalist, Hank Shaw is the author of three wild game cookbooks as well as the James Beard Award-winning wild foods website Hunter Angler Gardener Cook. His latest cookbook is Buck, Buck, Moose, a guide to working with venison. He hunts, fishes, forages and cooks near Sacramento, CA.

More from Hank

71 Comments / Reviews

No ImageNew Jersey Italian Hot Dog

Did you make it? Rate it!

  1. Tom Palasits

    A legit recipe. As a native Jersey Boy, eating these brings back memories. I like using half of one of those flat, round loaves of Italian bread instead of a sandwich bun.


    Show Replies (1)
  2. Doug

    Being from Scotch Plains I know the Fanwood corner store well from my youth. Almost every pizza place in our area made these as well. You gotta try these but be warned, you might not be able to look at a regular hot dog again!

  3. Bloomfield Dave

    I used top work at First National State Bank on Bloomfield Ave., in Newark, NJ in the 70’s I made many trips to Dicky Dees for the wonderful Italian hot dogs. I remember them deep frying the hot dogs, using the bagel shaped Italian rolls, putting mustard in the bottom, then the hot dogs, topped with fried peppers, onions, deep fried potatoes and topped with ketchup. Now living in Vermont, I sure miss those hot dogs and Taylor Ham and cheese sandwiches which we use to get on the shore boardwalk.

    Show Replies (1)
  4. Dianne Setaro

    When I read Robert Peloquin’s recall of the hot dogs in Newark I almost jumped out of my skin. Amato’s made the BEST — I was so little then and the memory even has it’s own smell! Here in Kansas I couldn’t match if I wanted to. Thank You Hank for the revival of a PERFECT memory! Without the big circle bread cut in halfs or quarters I don’t think it could come close to what I could create but this weekend is going to be a first class trial to repeat


  5. Anthony

    A real Italian hotdog in Essex County was never served on a sub roll but on pizza bread.It looks like a bagel on steroids but has the consitency of a sub roll. It had steak fries and peppers on the bottom to which you add ketchup then 2 hotdogs with mustard on top. The hot dogs were always fried in oil. Check out Jimmy Buff’s. Their nickname was slide in and slide out due to the oil

View More
New Jersey Italian Hot DogNew Jersey Italian Hot Dog