Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
I want something without sugar, or replace sugar with honey
We’ve not tried this recipe with honey or no sugar and I don’t think the results for would be worth it. I’d look for a peanut butter cookie recipe specifically formulated to use honey exclusively, or just no sweetener at all. Good luck! And leave off the Hersey’s Kisses!
I enjoyed making these traditional-style peanut butter cookies. The changes I made were that I sifted the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients then mixed them all together. I also added one cup of toffee bits to the mix. I rolled the balls in sugar, flattened each ball then baked. I did not use the chocolate kisses as I felt the sweetness was plentiful at this point. They were delicious.
Easy to make and my little granddaughter was a big help!
Great recipe, I’ll definitely make these this weekend! I was wondering if the sugar coating was necessary though? Is it just for flavor or does it help the shape of the balls?
Hi, Tara! The cookies will still bake without the sugar coating, but it adds another layer of flavor and texture to the cookies making them extra special.
Really delicious! We made half the batch with kisses and half with hugs. Both are so good. They are very rich, don’t skip milk on the side
Instead of a Kiss, use an unwrapped caramel!