Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
I made this today and it turned out great. Pretty to look at and delicious to eat. It’s perfect for my family since there’s just two of us.
Everyone wanted seconds of this yummy dessert. I’m gluten free so used rice flour with a little xanthan gum. Instead of the cinnamon, I used cardamom and I used 1/2 tsp vanilla and 1/2 tsp almond extract. I baked in a 9 inch cake pan for 30 minutes and it came out perfect! All the dinner guests asked for the recipe.
Thank you for this wonderful recipe! I had no vanilla at home so I substituted it with a bit of rum and the result was delicious!
Any chance I could do this on a small scale in a muffin pan?
Why not? If you try it, please let us know how it turns out. Note that the cooking time will be greatly reduced. ~Elise
What a delicious recipe, Elise! This worked well with the end-of-season Santa Rosa plums from the farmers’ market. I loved how the cake portion turned out moist and tender –and it’s pleasantly surprising how much character there is with the orange zest.
I almost always have plain yogurt around, so I used that instead of buttermilk. For grins I added the cinnamon to the sugar-butter sauce…which with my prolonged whisking and extended time on the heat turned into caramel, but ended up quite tasty.
I’ve made this quite a few times. My in-laws love it. I substituted allspice for the cinnamon, though, because my SIL is allergic to cinnamon. Have some wonderful freestone peaches from my MIL’s tree. Want to try it with those. Thank you very much for the recipe Elise!
So good! I alternated large red plums & small yellow sugar plums in a larger cake dish. It came out beautiful & delicious.
I made this as one large cake last night, and it came out great!
My boyfriend is not really into sweets, but he loves plums. He tried the cake last night and said it’s the “best cake ever.” He also moaned, “Oh my god” after each bite, because it was just so delicious.
This cake is buttery, but not too heavy. It’s really perfect.
Thanks for the amazing recipe!!!!
A large pluot tree branch fell in our backyard. Now we have almost three full garbage bags of pluots begging for cooking creativity before they spoil! Most of them are on the tart side– they did not fully ripen.
I used the apple corer/peeler/slicer to produce lovely rings for this recipe, which I doubled and cooked in two 9″ cake pans. It turned out great! Our tart fruits tasted wonderful and refreshing in this dessert (we served it hot with ice cream), which was quite beautiful, too.
Thanks again, Elise!
p.s. – I am also using those pluots for your “Fruit Leather” recipe!
Now that’s a gift from the heavens if there ever was one! You might also want to try out the plum conserve recipe and the plum galette recipe. Both are great with pluots. ~Elise
Thanks Elise! Someone brought us a basket of Santa Rosa plums this week and I was looking for a way to bake them.
I doubled the recipe (did I mention the basket was huge?) and baked in two 9″ cake pans since I only had small ramekins. They took about 25 minutes at 350 and came out looking nicely. I’m saving them for a picnic this afternoon so I haven’t tried the cake yet!
I did make one substitution – I used whole wheat pastry flour instead of cake flour. I suspect the cake will be dense but it seemed to work fine.
I just made this cake today. I used a regular cake pan, since I don’t have ramekins, and I didn’t change the measurements of the ingredients as I’m a baking novice. It came out beautifully and tasted absolutely delicious! A deep ruby red with a lovely brown cake crust. I love tart desserts and this was perfect. It was about as sweet as your strawberry rhubarb cobbler, give or take a bit.
The first time I made the brown sugar butter sauce I made the mistake of over-whisking while the saucepan was on the heat, causing the sugar to caramelize and separate. I also simply buttered the cake pan, when I probably should have done something else (grease + flour?) as I had a bit of a struggle getting the cake to release onto the serving platter once it was cool. All in all though, I was immensely pleased.
Your father reminds me of my father! He was very much the same way. He made the meanest apple strudel you’ve ever tasted, while being a vibrant, endearing, classically masculine sort of man. He was 55 when I was born so I was always proud of and impressed by his energy and vigor.
I really love your blog, Elise. Every recipe I’ve used has been delicious; not a one has failed me yet. Preparing the recipes you share reminds me so much of growing up. I dearly miss California and family dinners around the table. Thank you for everything you do. :)
I love plum cakes, this one seems very similar to the one I make which is basically a slight adjustment to a plum cake recipe on allrecipes.com.
The only thing I do differently is to mix into the cake batter some chopped plums and blueberries. The carmelizing of the black plums makes it so pretty and the sauce so yummy.
Now, this cake looks yummy, but I’m more curious to see what your [6’2″, 200 lb, works out 3 times a week at the gym, mows the lawn, splits the wood, 78-year-old father] looks like :)
Hello-this looks like a lovely recipe-I especially love that they are individual cakes! Quick question-I’ve never seen a recipe that called for 3/8 C. before-I just want to be sure it is not a typo (3/4) before I attempt it.
Hi Lisa – I changed the measure to 1/4 cup plus 2 Tbsp. Easier to figure out that way. ~Elise
Can I make it with other fruit? I don’t like plums… Apples, for example? A lot of thanks
If you want to make an upside down cake with apples, look online for a “tarte tatin” recipe. You can try this recipe with other fruit if you want, apricots might be nice for example. ~Elise
This sounds really great but I was wondering if it could be adjusted to make one larger cake?
I don’t see why not. Just cook for a longer period of time. ~Elise