Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
I wonder if some of the oil (1/2 a cup is pretty hefty) could be substituted with vegetable or chicken broth to make a dressing similar to German-style potato salad?
I don’t see why not. If you try it that way, please let us know how it turns out for you. ~Elise
Wow! I have tried several of your recipes posted here before and they have all turned out great, but this potato salad is unbeatable! Thanks for sharing. This one is going to be one of my staple dishes to bring to parties! Not to worry, though…I’ll give credit. Thanks again! Love it, love it, love it!
RE: Loss of nutrients during cooking. If one is really so concerned that they will not be able to get potassium from any other food sources, then make a point of saving the cooking liquid. I usally don’t salt the water I cook vegetables in, and use the nutrient-rich liquid for a quick stock, in baking, even as a refreshing drink. I sometimes water my plants with it, too!
I thought I would post my modifications to this recipe, since the end result was so delicious. I followed everything to the letter except:
1) I used red potatoes instead of yukon gold (I peeled a few, left the peels on a few)
2) I used fresh dill instead of fresh thyme
3) I omitted the bacon
4) I used half the onion and added half a red bell pepper, cooked them together in grapeseed oil and added a generous handful of sliced almonds at the end to get them nice and toasty.
I brought this to a potluck and folks went nuts!
I grew up eating my grandmother’s German potato salad. It too included bacon and used a small amount of the bacon drippings to create the sauce along with vinegar (that she insisted had to be boiled first — we never really knew why!?) and mayo. Like with this recipe, the bacon adds depth of flavor. I am looking forward to trying this!
I just made this potato salad last evening to accompany pork chops. This was a hit! Just delicious! Thank you, Elise.
I made this minus the onions ahead of time to go with some pulled pork but I ate a lot of it already, it was so good! I am not a big potato salad fan either.
I prepared a red cabbage/apple cole slaw recently, albeit with a mayo-based dressing.
Ginormous deliciosity: http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Purple-Apple-Slaw/Detail.aspx
I love the idea of the lighter, French-style vinaigrette for this salad, which will make me feel worlds better about the fact that I’ll be making it with 7 strips of bacon, instead of the suggested five.
Shame on me :-)
This really is a great recipe. I love the apple crunch and its sweetness juxtaposing against the tartness of the mustard.
Does it have to be Golden Delicious? I am wondering if a sweeter, yet still firm apple could be substituted.
You could use any sweet, firm apple. ~Elise
Hey everyone, Have to tell you all that this potato salad made me the queen of my family picnic this year. The great thing is the children loved it.It really amazes me how much a little bacon and apple can do in potatoes.For all of us that like hot potao salad this would be great. Thanks Anna
I heard that you can steam the diced potatoes instead of boiling them from a food magazine somewhere, but I haven’t tried that trick yet.
I grew up on Italian-style potato salad with olive oil and vinegar, but I’m definitely open to the idea of new potato salads, and this is high on that list. The addition of apples is so appealing to me and makes this a perfect potato salad to glide into fall with.
I’m so happy you like my skinny berry parfaits too. Thanks for the link, Elise!
How about avocado added at the last?
Let us know how it turns out! ~Elise
Dicing the potatoes before cooking ensures that they will lose almost all their potassium to the cooking water—a shame, since potatoes are particularly rich in potassium. Why not simmer them whole and then dice? That would retain the potassium. See this post.
Quartering them first will help them cook faster, and more evenly. I notice some people feel the same way about boiling beets; I have no problem cutting those either. If potassium loss is a concern, then it’s good to know about boiling potatoes uncut. ~Elise