These are awesome Super Bowl potato skins!!! I roasted about 3.5- 4lbs of russet potatoes (18) on Saturday, then let them cool off. Then I shredded up some cheddar cheese and set this in the fridge. After the potatoes cooled off, I put them in a gallon baggie in the fridge for the night. I meant to cook the bacon Saturday as well, but didn’t get around to it. All the extra prep I did manage was well worth it! It was pretty labor intensive, but spread over two days was nice! Husband and son both raved about the potato skins. I prepared them exactly as instructed (except I made extra potatoes). So easy, but hard, but worth it!!
I made these once again and I do make them exactly as scripted here although I do not rub canola oil inside the skins just the outside. I have to say these potato skins are perfect I see no way to improve these they are absolutely delicious!
My family love these guys. Super easy. I also use the bacon grease to glaze the skin side while they grill. Provides a nice crispy touch and my son devours them.
Also, I used avocado oil instead of olive oil (olive oil oxidizes at high heat whereas avocado is safe up to 500 degrees, plus it has an extremely mild taste – which I think is better for most things, imo).
These are really good! I made double so I can have some for tomorrow and so glad I did. They aren’t exactly quick because of the time for cooling and baking, but hands-on time isn’t much. (Just the start-to-bite time takes a while).
I used Mexican cheese and is turned out well, though I’m sure your favorite cheeze of any kind would work.
I also use uncured bacon bits intended for use as a salad topping instead of cooking my own separately. This cut down on the time. You could likely use pre-made chives instead of green onions to further reduce hands-on time.
I’d like to see if they freeze well (usually when bought from the store they are frozen, so I don’t see why not.) That’d be great for the person who grows their own potatoes and ends up with more than they could eat at once :)
Oh, and I used the potato guts for mashed potatoes. :)
Made these this afternoon AMAZING! Didn’t have green onions, my husband likes heat so I topped with jalapeños . Will definitely make again. Thanks for the recipe
Tonight I was trying to think of some light meal to make for dinner, then I remembered I’d seen this recipe and try it. Wow! They were so tasty and easy to make. These are now going to be a regular treat at our house. Thank you for posting the recipe.
I’m so glad you liked it Lisa!
These were really delicious!! I made them for my Super Bowl party and they were a hit!!
I had these queued up for Super Bowl, but ended up doing something else, so I made them today for myself. Nice and crispy, just like the deep fried restaurant version. So easy to do at home. Thanks Elise.
Can I use Bacon Bits instead of cooking bacon?
Hi Shantell, I don’t see why not!
Hello Shantell; I really do believe real bacon is worth the extra effort.
Just made these! They were really good! :D
Made these for Mothers Day. They went over great! Thanks for all the tips as well.
When I’m making mashed potatoes I started to just roast my potatoes off in the oven . Just wet the out side of it and sprinkle them with kosher salt and bake them at 400 for an hour them scour the flesh out and use the crunchy skins for potato skins or just baked potatoes. One time I forgot to stab the potatoes and heard a boom in the oven, opened up the oven and there was potato every where!! Lol
In the 80s there was an appetizer making the rounds of nice parties. Potato skins made with little potatoes (reds OK), baked nice and crispy in a regular oven and scooped out, then topped with good quality caviar and sour cream. Yum.
I’ve been making these since the recipe fist appeared on your site, and they are always a huge, huge success!
This is a GREAT recipe (Like most of your recipes!). I use the innards to make twice baked casserole.
These potato skins really look good. I used to always buy the frozen ones at M&M but will try your recipe this time. However can you let me know if I can make a batch of these and freeze them and when ready to serve, I could just warm up in the oven. Thanks.
WOW! All I can say is this recipe is awesome. gotta remember not to be impatient next time with letting the potatoes cool before scooping them. had a couple of them break apart on me, but that’s ok – I can still use them to make mashed potatoes later with the leftover filling.
Wow…I just made these for the first time tonight. Delicious and easy to prepare. Nice and crispy, just like a restaurant!!
Excellent recipe! I used the removed potatoes for a baked potato soup recipe I wanted to try. Your the potato skins recipe was the most complimented dish at dinner. Thanks!
This potato skins recipe tasted awesome it was the best for my family birthday party!
I just made these tonight and everyone loved them! Thank you for posting this recipe!!
These were awesome!!! My whole family loves them thank you so much for a great recipe.
We substituted the bacon for turkey bacon and used light sour cream instead of regular. Then we sprinkled a bit of paprika and parsley flakes onto the sour cream along with the green onion. These turned out great and we will be making them again. Thank you so much for the recipe without having to deep fry these bad boys.
I didn’t know what to make for SuperBowl Day but I heard alot of people talking about potato skins. I came across this recipe.. OH MY GOD !They were awesome. I loved them and so did my husband and friends. There doesn’t need to be a superbowl for me to make these again. Great eating. Now my man ( John ) is going to read this and hold me down to it LOLThe shell was so crispy oh they are just to die for.
Thanks for a great recipe for super crispy potato skins! just made a big batch for the super bowl and they turned out fab! :)
I just made these potato skins…and have to say these were amazing. So simple to make yet so delicious. I have had a lot of potatoe skins in my 36 yrs and have to say these were phenomonal. Even my husband who is a hard food critic to please said they were the best that he ever had.
What to do with the leftover skins…my parents owned restaurants and what they used to do (and what I will do tomorrow!) is put the extra potatoes in a bowl, covered with saran wrap and make fried hash browns tomorrow morning. Cooked potatoes like this are good for about 2 days to make hash browns in my opinion.
Can I pre make any part of this recipe? I have a BBQ and I was hoping to have them ready and when guest arrive put them in the oven for the final stage, I don’t want to be stuck in the kitchen. Thanks so much. I do miss the days we could eat and drink with out ever thinking about it.
Sure. Make the bacon ahead. Cook the potatoes ahead. Scoop out the centers. Then cover with plastic wrap and bring out for the final bake when your guests arrive. ~Elise
The directions on this recipe are spot on. I just made some and had to come post on this recipe. The only thing I had to do was extend my baking and broiling time because I used very large potatos. I love that these are brushed lightly with oil and not deep fried, they turn out very crispy (I was a little skeptical) and filling them with cheese and bacon bits just makes them perfect. I froze the rest of my skins for later use. What a great way to do potato skins, one of my favorite snacks. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!
Wow, we bought frozen store bought Friday’s brand skins the other day. They were small, and okay…We followed this recipe to the T and they were extremely good.The green onion really makes it.A real keeper!!
I love this recipe! I also added some Thyme in the potatoes which added a lot more flavor!Thanks so much. :)
Thank you for the great recipe! I never thought of covering it in olive oil before baking, However, I do add a lot of the scooped filling back into it after frying it in the bacon greese… but it’s not exactly a healthy way to go.
These look and sound fabulous! I’d like to fix these in advance and then serve a few hours later. Have you ever tried preparing them (except for the broiling), refrigerating them and then broiling just before serving? Thanks.
I have not, but I don’t see why that wouldn’t work. ~Elise
Potatoes Done in a Crockpot. There are several different ways to do these. They are all good substitutes for real baked potatoes:Seasoned Crock Pot “Baked” Potatoes
Potatoes, unpeeled, washed and scrubbedOlive or vegetable oilSeason-All or favorite dry seasonings
1.Rub each unpeeled potato with oil.2.Put about 1 t. seasoning per potato in a bowl or a plastic bag.3.Add potatoes one at a time and coat with seasonings. (I would prick them a few times.)4.Put potatoes in slow cooker as they are coated.5.Cover. Cook on high 4 hours or on low 8-10 hours or until potatoes are tender when pricked.Makes as many as you need
Slow Cooker Baked Potatoes
1.Rinse, scrub and dry the potatoes. 2.Prick them in a few places. Lightly coat them with butter or oil. 3.You can sprinkle them with a little salt or seasoned salt. Wrapping them in foil is unnecessary.4.Old instructions tell you to put them in the crock, and cook 6-8 hrs. on low or do Idaho potatoes about 3 to 4 hours on high. Newer slow cookers cook at higher temps so they may take less time.5.To test, lightly squeeze the potatoes; if baked through, they’ll be slightly soft, not mushy, but give a little as you squeeze.6.The “steamed-soft” potatoes in the crock pot can be used in many ways.
Per an internet source, another method:One can get 3 fairly large potatoes in a very small pot; in a 2 quart pot, 4 large potatoes; in a 4 qt. pot, 6 or 7. Before you wash and prick them, put them in the pot to see how many fit.Those “baked” in foil have a soft skin which is easy to peel off. Crock pot on high. The smaller the pot the hotter and faster it cooks. One can bake potatoes in 3 hours in the smallest pot.
Twice Baked Potatoes in the Slow CookerWash, prick, and oil them and stick them in the crockpot over night. In the morning, cool; they are ready to turn into twice baked potatoes.
I use the same process, except I baste the skins using olive oil with pressed garlic in it, and then I put a small amount of minced red onion in each skin before adding the cheese & bacon……..YUMMY!
This potato skins recipe is super delicious!!! You will absolutely love it! I used to make them all the time before. Just follow the recipe and your tummy will thank you for it…trust braddah! Ha! I’m really wanting to make these for the Super Bowl tomorrow…it’s been a while since my fiance and I had these awesome skins! Go Colts! Mahalos!
I’ve made these several times and they are soooooo good! Easy to make too.
Reduce Baking time:If you don’t mind your skins being a bit smaller you can do the following: Cut the potato in half lenghtwise and then cut each half in half again lengthwise. Cut out however much raw potato you want. Lay out your skins on a lined baking sheet and prick the flesh of each a few times with a fork. Bake in the oven until crisp (way less time than baking a whole potato). When they are at their desired crispness take them out and sprinkle on your cheese and bacon, put under broiler until gooey! Your left over raw potato pieces could be used for anything at that point. Potato pancakes anyone?
I did this recipe….they tasted great. Just took me two hours total before I was able to serve them. I recommend this recipe but plan in advance!
Does anyone have any recommendations for what to do with the left over potato insides?
Make mashed potatoes. ~Elise
These were awesome. Enough said.
I made these potato skins for Superbowl Sunday and they were delicious. The only change I made was that I re-stuffed the skins with the scooped out potato once I mixed it with alot of butter. Then topped with cheese and bacon. Everyone loved it.
EXCELLENT!! Making again for SuperBowl Sunday! THANKS!
If these are for an app then you could use the scooped out for homemade mash for a side dish at dinner or make baked potato soup ( you already have the cheese,bacon, and onion)!
Last week, it was cheaper to buy 10 pounds of potatoes than just the couple I needed for my Thai Yellow Curry Chicken, so I used some to give this recipe a try … we loved them! So crispy and delicious.
I love these potato skins.They were so delicious when I made them.
Book club is coming here next week. We read Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. Someone decided long ago to serve, for dinner, something related to the books we read. Having looked many places for a potato peel pie recipe (not sweet potato), and having not had any luck, I think I’ll just bomb them with your recipe. Potato peels (skins), loaded, why not? Good book, by the way.
My dad actually makes something like this, but WITH the potato. Requires a lot more work, but worth it.
I don’t know the procedure exactly, because there are too many people in the kitchen the twice a year he makes his famous double baked cheesy potatoes (Christmas and Thanksgiving).
Basically, slice some nice big potatoes in half lengthwise, and bake for a bit. Take them back out again, scoop the potato out into a bowl and mash with obscene amounts of unsalted butter.Refill the potato skins with the tasty stuff and put back in to bake for a while. Take out again, remove potato insides and add more butter, and lots of sharp cheddar cheese. put back in skins, and sprinkle with a little bit of paprika.Tasty, and is perfect with my Aunt Mary’s homemade cranberry sauce. Not a low fat recipe!
Sounds like your dad is making a version of Twice Baked Potatoes. Yummy indeed. ~Elise
I made these tonight, and WOW…they were so good!! It’s always nice to make restaurant food at home and it ACTUALLY tastes like what you are trying to recreate. Great recipe.
I want to make small redskin potatoes as an hor d’oeuvre. If I make them on Monday and freeze the skins, should I defrost them first before filling and then do I broil them. With the very small potatoes, what are the cooking times? Can I use vegetable oil instead of canola? Thanks. Audrey
I just made these potato skins and they rock! I added some extra spices to the potatoes but other than that, followed the recipe. It was so much fun making these, can’t wait to do another batch! Thanks Elise.
Hi! I made these from your recipe last weekend for a family party, and they were very popular! I made probably 40, and pretty much were all gulped down, with rave reviews. Thanks!
I also made these for Super Bowl Sunday, and they were a big hit for my family, as well! I found them to be fun to prepare. Thanks!
Elise, I tried these yesterday for our super bowl party. They were easy and delicious! My fellow revelers were pleased and a bit surprised when I told them they were not deep fried. Thanks for another great recipe.
I made these for our own little super bowl party (just us and the kids). They were fantastic! My hubby just raved about them the entire time he was eating them. Thanks for the great recipes.
Could you cut out the potato before you bake them? And would they still turn out the same? My husband wants me to make hash browns with the leftover potato.
Don’t know. You could try it and see. ~Elise
Other ideas for using up the insides: Soup (potato cheese for us), hashbrowns, mashed (I know it’s not traditional to bake for this, but I think it’d work). And any other application where you use cut up or mashed potatoes.
I’ve read this can also be good with sweet potatoes. I’d use different toppings though.
These came out perfectly and w ere fantastic. I never thought to make potato skins – just always bought them. These were so good. Your instructions were excellent. I did mine in the oven and came out nice an crispy on the edges. Thanks, Elise, for another great recipe.
We just made a big batch of shells and froze some for later. Filled the ones for dinner last night with bacon and cheddar, and some with leftover beef enchilada filling and cheese…wonderful! THink I may try some kind of goatcheese filling in some next time.
My husband and son think that they have died and gone to heaven when I make Potato Skins. I’ve never baked the shells after scooping out the centers. I think I might give it a try and see if it improves the taste and texture. I usually serve with sour cream and Ranch Dressing on the side. “To die for”, they are that yummy!
Thank you, my picky eaters ate them up in a flash!
You know, the only thing I hate about potato skins is how fast they disappear. They almost seem too labor intensive to make considering how quickly I devour them. Most foods I have control over myself on, but well loaded potato skins, thin sliced haystack onion rings, and chips and salsa are distinct areas where I have no sense of self control. My stomach is growling now.
Oh yeah, my two cents on the deep fry method. Yum! However… totally unnecessary. When I worked in a Sportsbar years ago as a short order cook, we would have pre-scooped frozen skins and that’s the way we made them. It’s fast and effective. However if you’re making them at home the best way is to bake them so you get the nice cripsy outsides and soft middles, then scoop out the middles (not too much though) and salamander them (broiler) with the goods on top.
I like to split up the batch into 1/2s of jalepeno slices and cheese and the the other with bacon and cheese. All get green onions. The bacon ones are complimented with a nice rich sour cream and the jalepeno ones are favorited with salsa topper.
Great, now my mouth is watering as well as the stomach growl. Darn your wonderful blog!
I love this kind of baked potato! And I’m with you that deep-frying them is unnecessary.
Our variation of this is to mix the insides of the potatoes with grated cheese and onion and rebake them that way.
P.S. In response to Fran’s question about pricking the potatoes before baking, one of my friends reported in amazement about the potato that had exploded while baking in the microwave. She didn’t know that the skin was supposed to be pierced. I doubt that it has to be pierced all over though. I usually just do one small slash if by some miracle we have gotten potatoes that are completely unblemished.
Could you use the potato innards to make gnocchi? Mmmm, gnocchi.
Yum. I love potato skins, but I don’t do deep frying. I can sit and eat them one after another, just like the way I eat devilled eggs.
I will have to pick up a bag of potatoes and do this recipe over the weekend. :)
Then I can have homemade mashed potatoes, another favorite comfort food.
Never thought of doing this. When I peel potatoes I just take the peelings and flash fry ’em real quick then add some salt and pepper.
The skins freeze great once they have been scooped out, seasoned and baked the first time…then you can top them and heat whenever you want them; so make a big batch of baked potato soup so you have skins left over to make these!
Brilliant! I love potato skins, and leave them on when making potato salad. But when making mashed potatoes, I always threw them away. No more!
Lately I have been steaming, rather than boiling potatoes, for mashing them. They don’t get mushy that way. But I can see how baking them would be better for making your potato skins, as they would be easier to get crisp. I could still use the insides for mashing or whatever. I love the versatility of potatoes.
Regarding the green potato skins, I always thought they turned green due to exposure to light. One should store them in a cool, dark place, out of the light. Or the light will also make them sprout. I have cut away my share of green skins and sprouts but will make sure they are good and brown before making this recipe, just to be on the safe side.
Yes, exposure to light increases the production of the toxins and increases the chlorophyll that indicates the presence of toxins. ~Elise
How can you tell the difference between the toxins and an unripe potato? Is the skin green or the flesh just under the skin?
And soup would be my vote for what to do with the leftover potato.
It’s the flesh right underneath the skin, but you can see the green through the skin. And unripe potatoes aren’t green. The green is chlorophyll that comes from exposure to sun. ~Elise
For variety and a real taste treat, substitute sweet potatoes for the russets. Made skins with the “sweets” recently, CAUTION they can be addictive.
Concerning the note on the green part of the potato, we have always been told that you never eat the green part un-cooked.
That cooking, baking and boiling neutralizes the toxins.
The toxins come from the fact that potatoes are a member of the Nightshade family.
According to the Wikipedia “Deep-frying potatoes at 170°C (306°F) is known to effectively lower glycoalkaloid levels, whereas microwaving is only somewhat effective and boiling has no effect.” ~Elise
I like making mine with a layer of bbq sauce on the potato, then add the other ingredients. Gives is a little zip.
Elise,I have another dirty little secret to go along with my skins, I cook up some extra bacon, then I saute a small diced onion in the bacon skillet along with the potato I removed from the skins. Once the potatoes have started browning I dump them in a bowl with the extra bacon (chopped) a few healthy squirts of cider vinegar, the leftover sour cream, and salt and pepper. That’s lunch for the next couple of days.
Oh, what a great idea, thanks Kevin! ~Elise
Very good of you to put the Solanine warning. Most people don’t realize how toxic green potato skin can be. What do you do with the left over potato innards?
Thanks for the tip about green potatoes.I, unintentionally, got a bag of them at the grocery store about 2 months ago.
Every recipe was turning out terrible (I thought perhaps they were not ripe or something). I got my money back when I went back.
Thank God I never got really sick from them.
I love how you’re not afraid to blog about trashy, fatty foods. You know we all crave them sometimes!
Thank you, I think. Actually, I don’t consider these trashy. Deep fried twinkies, now that’s something else. ~Elise
Ok, you just made me laugh out loud with the deep fried twinkies. And let’s not forget about deep fried gummies or or the more recent bacon donut. Potatoes are really healthy! I honestly don’t know why they always get such a bad rap. I Love this recipe as I love all your recipes, you nail it with the word simple. You never work with ingredients that are unfamiliar to me and “I can do it” is the name of the game. I can always implement your recipes and I can’t say that for all I see out there on Pinterest or wherever. Thanks again! Huge fan of your food!!!
from a new viewer…
This has got to lead to a 101 things you can do with the potato you scooped out list, surely :)
Great idea! ~Elise
The potato skins look amazing! One of my favorites. I’m putting it on my Super Bowl menu. What about some potato croquettes for the insides?
Do you have to prick the potatoes with a fork before going in the microwave?
I used to think so, but because I wanted to keep the skins intact I didn’t and it wasn’t a problem at all. ~Elise
I have a 1300 power microwave. If I don’t prick the potato skins, they explode. I found this out one time – the hard way.
prick the round the edge of the potato that you’re going to cut
so for STEP 3 “brush or rub on canola or high heat oil”, I only had vegetable oil and these puppies were super crunchy, other than this substitute I followed the recipe exactly.
Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.