Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Best potato salad ever! Perfect for a potluck or a cool summer dinner. Leave out the anchovies and it’s completely vegan.
Thanks Elise for the reply. Sun dried tomatoes sounds excellent.Yum!
Have these mini potatoes that I have been wanting to use up…Will try this one. Being a vegetarian, I can’t use anchovies..will skipping them make a huge difference or would I have to sub it with something else?
If you skip the anchovies, I would add some finely minced sun-dried tomatoes. ~Elise
This potato salad was a big hit with the family for last night’s dinner. It’s definitely a keeper! Loved the French twist on an old standard. Thanks, Elise for such a great blog.
You’re welcome! So glad you liked it. ~Elise
This salad is awesome! I just made it for lunch and wanted to share that I LOVE it. It is a wonderful, easy and quick recipe for the small new potatoes that I am now getting from my CSA. Thanks!
Thank you for a potato salad without mayo. This is my perfect potato salad!
What a great recipe. All of these ingredients compliment each other so well. Thanks!
Did anyone else see the comment about washing potatoes in their dishwasher? Huh? Is this a joke? or serious? Potatoes today are pretty clean when I get them home. The small ones seem like they hardly need a rinse before plopping in the pot. They are boiled so . . . ? Folks listen to Elise — anchovy paste is GOOD! Plus it comes in a tube — just like toothpaste — so you won’t waste it.
I saw that dishwasher comment. I have heard of cooking things in the dishwasher, don’t know about washing potatoes in it though! ~Elise
Yes, everyone DO try the anchovy paste! I’d never be caught dead eating anchovies on pizza, but use the paste in cooking all the time. It melts into everything else and you (nor anyone!) would know it’s there. But as Elise says, it adds/does something wonderful!!
This is a keeper. Made it tonight. Reminds me of a dish a family member made year’s ago. No capers but she included beautiful tender French green beans.
These spuds are also good with just snips of fresh herbs, salt and pepper and olive oil. Put aside some, or all, take out of the frig the next day and sauté in a hot skillet.
Hello. I love reading your recipes. They all sound yummy. My problem is that you frequently use ingredients that I have difficulty figuring out how to store. I do not cook every day and this looks like an awesome recipe! However, what do I do with the other 8 anchovies? Thanks!
I tend to use anchovy paste, which comes in a small tube and lasts a really long time. You can easily add a dab to any salad dressing to make it taste better. ~Elise
I love to use small and multi-colored potatoes. They add color to the plate and each different color has a different flavor. These potatoes look absolutely delicious. I must pin immediately.
This does sound excellent, and a nice sneaky way to slip some anchovy appreciation under the radar of my family’s food sensibilities.
Herbes de provence is an unfamiliar blend to me. I do not keep it among my spices, only the more common things like thyme, oregano, basil, sage, dill, etc. Could you suggest any substitutes, or are there elements you feel are essential there?
p.s. you have a typo in the instructions of “hermes” for “hermes”
Thanks for the typo catch, it’s been corrected! Herbes de Provence is sort of like Italian seasoning, but with a French twist. Typical mixtures include thyme, rosemary, summer savory, and dried lavender flowers. ~Elise
I think this recipe is GREAT and I’ll try it tonight :)
Just for the record though, I strongly recommend to not let it sit for longer than 24 hours (or eat it later than that).
Boiled potatoes are naturally quiet high in bacteria and after 24 hours these bacteria proliferate even more as the fermentation begins (just like with home made broth).I know you will store them in the fridge but even if they are not exactly noxious, they may not be suitable for sensitive intestines or smaller children.
Plus it’s the nitrites level you don’t want to let raise in your food ;)
The potato salad should be stored in the refrigerator. ~Elise
I love anchovies but my family does not .- Does the paste add a strong flavor? May I omit it or leave it in and hope it just enhances the dish?
Hi Mary, the paste doesn’t add a strong flavor, it only greatly enhances the flavor of the vinaigrette. You can skip it if you want, but I highly recommend trying it. ~Elise
Yummy recipe Elise. The great thing with anchovies [and other umami-rich food] is that they accentuate the flavor of the other ingredients w/o tasting “fishy”.
Much like mushrooms, tomato paste, grilled meats and shellfish, anchovies are loaded with that umami taste/sensation.
I chuckle when folks say they don’t like anchovies yet eat Caesar’s salad. :)