Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Great recipe. First time making scones and they came out perfect. I use honey goat cheese in the recipe. Was so delicious. Thank you for taking my fear out of making scones.
You are so very welcome Nicole, I’m glad your first foray into scone making was a success with this recipe!
I was looking for a good goat cheese scone recipe! I made these about a month ago. Here I am making them a second time. I made them a bit more herbaceous with 1/2 a cup green onion and 1/4 cup each of parsley and dill. Mmmmm they were so good. They were gobbled up very quickly. Thank you!
What would happen if I used 2% milk instead of buttermilk?
Hi, Julia! I think using 2% milk would result in a slightly less rich and flavorful scone, but it should still work. Add 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar to the milk so that you maintain the correct ratio of acidity in the recipe (otherwise you could have leavening issues and your scones could have an aftertaste of baking soda!) Good luck!
I subbed olive oil for butter. Even faster. Also whole wheat flour. Increased the baking powder to 1 tablespoon. So yummy. Thanks
This is the best scone recipe I have ever tried. My mum taught me to bake and I have never been as good as she is, her bread is heavenly, I think it’s the potato water she uses, besides her vast experience. I made these with her and she asked for the recipe :) I wanted to add that I have made them before, froze them on the sheet pan, and then stored them airtight in the freezer, and pulled them out a couple weeks later for a family breakfast, and they were perfect! I used the same cooking time. Thanks for this recipe!!
What does “knead 8 times” mean? That is, what needs to be done to be considered as one knead?
From the Wikipedia, “the dough is put on a floured surface, pressed and stretched with the heel of the hand, folded over, and rotated through 90º repeatedly.” The “repeatedly” part? Do that 8 times. ~Elise
My Mom used home made feta cheese and green onions…even my picky sister ate them!
Thank you for this recipe! Trying to explain to my friends out here in the US why their scones aren’t ‘real scones’ has been driving me nutty. I’m originally from Bristol, and I read a comment up the page by ‘sarah’ about Rock Cakes – my mother used to make those! I thought they were just an excuse for poorly made scones!
Looking forward to making these this weekend. Your recipes are making me run out of flour so quickly! (The banana bread recipe was heaven!)
This is a great recipe and versatile as well. I used this recipe to base another, which featured sundried tomatoes, smoked gouda and ground green peppercorns. Worked well. I turned my oven down to 375 so as not to burn the bottom of the biscuits and took them out after only 16 minutes. They were quite delicious according to the ladies in our soup club. I’ll have to write this on an index card – it was that good!
Lordy, Lordy, Lordy! I just found your blog, and immediately had to try these out. Even though I’ve never attempted scones before, your recipe was clear enough, and easy enough for me to manage. It was so quick to whip up and made my kitchen smell deliriously good. AND, they tasted great! Brought them to work and they were crowd pleasers. Thanks for the explanations and sharing!
Elise, you’re my Hero.
Thank you so much for that explanation. Baking Soda isn’t commonly used for baking in germany, at least not to my knowledge. I usually have trouble finding it in the baking isle… Usually “Baking Soda” or “Natron” is found with cleaning supplies, though it says it’s suitable to cook/bake with on the back of the package. (It usually comes with some kind of instruction pamphlet with ratios to clean stuff and I think one recipe but I can’t remember what the recipe was).
Again, thank you! And I’ll have a go with just baking powder and see what happens ;-)
Ok, I have a problem with Baking Soda. Last time I used some (and yes, it was fresh) I made some kind of cornbread and it was fine while hot but tasted really disgusting and bitter when cooled down. I made it without the baking soda and just used more baking powder and it was fine, so I’m pretty sure the Baking Soda was the problem.
Can I substitute Baking powder for the Baking Soda? How much extra would I need to use, on top of what’s already in the recipe?
Also, what’s the reason for using both Baking Soda and Baking Powder ins this recipe?
Here’s the deal with baking soda and baking powder in any baking recipe. Baking soda is a pure base. Baking powder is comprised of baking soda plus a dry acid. A base reacts with an acid to form bubbles. Every try sprinkling vinegar on to baking soda? That’s an acid reacting with a base. For baking soda to work, you need an acid in the mixture. Buttermilk is acidic, so baking soda reacts with it to form bubbles, which helps with the leavening in the biscuits. Baking powder doesn’t need that extra acid, because all you have to do is get it wet in the mixture and it will begin to react with itself. Baking is all chemistry. Changing a leavening ingredient will change how the recipe works. Many recipes use a combination of baking soda and baking powder, so that the leavening process throughout the cooking is more even and controlled. If you want to omit the baking soda called for in this recipe, and substitute baking powder, you’ll have to do your own experimenting to see what works best for you. Because that is what it will take, experimenting. Good luck! ~Elise
Do you think that it would be a feasible idea to make the dough the evening prior to an event, and bake the biscuits in the morning? My concern would be that the texture would become less airy if the dough was to rest over night in the fridge.
Thanks for your help.
The dough should be made right before cooking, not the evening before. Otherwise the acid in the buttermilk will react with the baking soda and you will lose a good portion of your leavening. ~Elise
Made ’em without chives and black pepper due to persnickety family preferences. Fabulous. This is a keeper. After a thousand batches yielding varying degrees of brickness in my lifetime I finally followed Alton Brown’s advice and turned the dough out onto the board when it was hardly mixed at all and did most of the blending of wet/dry ingredients in the 6-8 kneads. Perfect biscuits at last!
Elise I spent 10 minutes googling biscuit recipes before I found yours and I knew I could trust it. I used Abbeydale cheese with chives instead of goat cheeese and chives and it turned out well.
One trick I figured out is if you don’t have a pastry cutter to work the butter into the flour mixture, freeze the butter and shred it up with your microplane. Works like a charm!
These biscuits are moist and yummy! They are easy and perfect for a weeknight meal. Thanks for the step-by-step photos.
I did it in my bread machine into a loaf of bread. Yum yum eveyone loved it.
I just wanted to tell you that I turned this recipe into sweet scones with currents – ommitted chives & cheese, and increased the sugar to 1/3 of a cup, and added 3/4 cup of currents. It worked out really well – they were given rave reviews by family.
These were so easy to make and were quite delicious. I loved biting into small chunks of goat cheese. I have a scone pan that is divided into 8 compartments and they came out just perfect. Keep those great recipes coming!
I made these biscuits to accompany the Irish stew, the combo was delicious, they went surprisingly well together. We loved the stew – which became even tastier second day. I am very excited about the biscuits (scones) – it is the first time that a scone/biscuit recipe has worked out well for me, they were delicious – I would love to try a sweeter (or at least non-savoury) version – could this recipe be adapted with a bit more sugar and currants? Thanks….