Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
Excellent recipe. Only change I made was to put 2x the amount of horseradish in the cocktail sauce – we love horseradish!
Perfect! Great balance of flavors.
I had this for dinner this evening and it was great! Of course, I added my two cents worth of ingredients and won’t bore you with that!!! Great job, Simply Recipes!
I have a problem I live in Africa and haven’t been able to find Old Bay Seasoning. Any suggestions for a replacement?
Hi Harry, try this combo (from https://thepioneerwoman.com/food-and-friends/how-to-make-old-bay-seasoning/):
1 Tablespoon Celery Salt
2 teaspoons Ground Bay Leaves
2 teaspoons Smoked Paprika
1-1/2 teaspoon Ground Black Pepper
1 teaspoon Ground Mustard
1/4 teaspoon Allspice
1/4 teaspoon Cayenne
1 pinch Ground Cinnamon
1 pinch Ground Nutmeg
1 pinch Ground Ginger
This was FANTASTIC. A huge hit at our annual Feast of the Seven Fishes meal. It will now be on our regular rotation. Thank you for the great recipe!
I do everything almost exactly as you say, with a couple of small changes:
I add peppercorns, a halved lemon, and two bay leaves to the court bouillon and simmer it for at least 15 min. before adding the shrimp. It adds to the flavor.
While the water is simmering I sprinkle the shrimp with dry creole seasoning. It adds a little zip without being over-powering.
To Ade above: If you add mayonnaise, some creole mustard, and some paprika, finely chopped onion, celery, a little red wine vinegor, and parsley, you’re on your way to a New Orleans style Remoulade, which is good on both shrimp and crab cakes. Leave it in the ice box over night before you serve it for the flavors to fully develop.
I’ve made my share of shrimp cocktails in my lifetime…but never were any as delicious as the recipe I found here! Needless to say, all my other recipes are trashed…and this one is the only one I’ll ever use again! Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for the recipe! We’ve had them at Grove Park too and they are good. When we do them at home, we use Zatarain’s seafood boil. It’s a much more complex flavor layer that allows the sweet buttery shrimp to really shine. Our sauce uses green onion instead of cilantro. C’est si bon! Yes, I’m a North Carolina resident, but a Cocodrie, Louisiana native where there’s a motto that the shrimp are so fresh, ya have ta slap ’em” :)
Sounds wonderful! The sauce recipe reminded me of Gulf Coast vacations with my sister and the wonderful hole-in-the-wall seafood shacks which place sauce ingredients on the table and each person mixes up their own sauce. I like mine a little heavy on the horseradish and not too sweet. Nothing better than freshly caught deepwater Gulf shrimp dipped in homemade cocktail sauce. Try your shrimp steamed and eat them hot instead of cold. Yum!
I have never cooked shrimp before but was so inspired by this recipe that I went to Costco for the shrimp over the weekend and put this together. It was FABULOUS! Thanks for the link on how to prepare shrimp – very helpful, and thanks for the clear, step by step instructions. The only thing I did different was I used fresh grated horseradish and cut it to 1 tsp. because the person at the store warned me that it was stronger than the jarred stuff. The shrimp were appetizers for an outdoor barbecue; I wound up using the sauce on my burger, too. Thanks for sharing!
I made this yesterday for a wine tasting party I attended. It was fantastic and a huge hit!! Thanks so much for posting this. It was so easy, quick and delicious. I had some sauce leftover from the party, so I just made another batch of shrimp today for lunch. Can’t wait to make it for another party!
This looks like a fabulous recipe and plan to race to the nearest town to stock up on what I’ll need to try it out, however I would like a small clarification.
In the first section “For the Shrimp” the list of ingredients includes 1 teaspoon of granulated garlic, followed by the 1 teaspoon of garlic. I assumed that meant fresh chopped garlic but found that in the second portion of the recipe, “For the Cocktail Sauce” one of the ingredients is 1/2 clove of garlic finely minced. So, that tells me that when it’s fresh garlic you say so. Can you help clear this up for me?
I can’t wait to try this,
Ah, I see. To clarify, in the “For the Shrimp” it should be fresh chopped garlic. I’ll fix now. Thank you! ~Jaden
Great post, Jaden.
Have to tell you, I am an AVID shrimp cocktailer. The best one I’ve ever had was at some rinky dink casino in Old Vegas. Yum.
This post sounds like a winner. I also like to serve my shrimp cocktail roasted. Just a little olive oil, some salt, pepper and a little Old Bay at 400 for 6 minutes. Gracious, me…it’s good. It’s also good served slightly warm or at room temperature.
For cocktail sauce – there is something about fresh onion juice and coarse ground pepper that gets me all twitterpated. Also, I like to mix it up a bit. The sweet chili sauce and spicy mustard or dijon with horseradish, or adding in a little bit of bloody mary mix, finely chopped celery, horseradish, etc.
Thanks for the recipe/story!
Quick question, what is “Old Bay Seasoning”, what does it taste like? Id say its another one of those things you cant get in Australia.
It’s a pretty popular seasoning in the U.S. http://www.oldbay.com. The mixture is celery seed, bay leaf, mustard seed, red pepper, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, cinnamon, black pepper, etc.. If you can’t find, there are a few recipes online for the spice mix, just search for “Old Bay Seasoning recipe.” ~jaden
I almost put my foot in my mouth… i’ve always shied away from shrimp recipes as I didn’t really want to use frozen, and a little clueless on prep/de-veining. Facepalm, I just searched and there it is
How to Peel and Devein Shrimp
going to have to try this over the weekend now.
BTW, Elise, I love the blog… I make a bolognese sauce based off your lasagna post with El Cocinero Loco’s input… it’s the absolute best.
Does the cocktail sauce need any mayo in it? I always thought that shrimp cocktail sauce needed a carrier of mayo where u mix the other ingredients in? :P Then it turns the beautiful coral peach shade of pink.
Appears I am wrong based on your recipe… hee hee
Hey there, no you do not need mayo. Well, if you LIKE mayo, I’m sure you can add it! ~jaden
Do you peel and devein them before boiling, though?
Sorry, I’ll clarify in recipe. You can buy any type of raw shrimp you want – most important is that it’s tail-on for traditional shrimp cocktail. Devein prior to cooking, it’s easier. ~jaden
OMG…sounds like a keeper which I want to try this weekend. How many servings per recipe?
Should be four ~jaden
You don’t state to use whole(head-on), headless or(OMG!!) peeled shrimp to boil?
I’m originally from southeast Louisiana and always tend to use whole shrimp when they are to be boiled.
Everyone has different preferences – buy and use what you want! I use whole, head-on shrimp when I can find. ~jaden