Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
I plan to try this, with some roasted chiles from my garden, and canned, crushed tomatoes. What is the reasoning behind cooking? Is it to remove the “tinny” taste of the canned tomatoes and blend flavors better? You don’t explain why this salsa is cooked. Thanks!
Hi Carolyn, we make this salsa by cooking fresh tomatoes, not by using canned tomatoes, which are already cooked. Cooked tomatoes have a different taste than fresh tomatoes. There are all kinds of salsas, this is just one of them.
This is a fantastic recipe; it’s simple, one doesn’t have to run to store, and extremely tasty. I used the perfect tomatoes and the less than perfect tomatoes, and the salsa is still great. I’ve used one jalapeno with the seeds removed and two jalapenos with seeds, plus a couple Serrano’s. More heat, but still great. And with this recipe, the salsa doesn’t spend much in fridge. Tonight I used about half batch while watching the news. Good stuff!
I love this method. I also left out the water, and for those who want a less runny salsa, just cook it longer! The next time I make it, I will use a ghost pepper…
I changed a little, did not add the water (fresh tomatoes were watery already) and used whatever peppers were from my grandmother’s garden. It was very tasty but very thin/runny. I like smooth salsa but was expecting something a little thicker. As the recipe goes it is IMHO too thin for e.g. dipping with chips. Probably very good as a sauce though. I may try just finely dicing the tomatoes next time instead of blending on puree.
Cooking it longer will thicken it more. ~Elise
Just made this with tomatoes from our Grandma’s garden. FINALLY after many attempts to make home made salsa only to be disappointed in the taste. For me this one is a Keeper. Very simple. I really like cilantro so I took a handful with some stems and added it to the blender. I made one mistake I used 6 tomatoes so I figured i needed to add more water then the 1/4 cup so I doubled the water. To me there is NO NEED to double the water probally would not of tasted watery if I did not double the water. I did double the garlic though and to me that worked out nicely. Thank You, Thank You .
Can I freeze this? If so, how long do you think it would last in the freezer?
Yes, you should be able to freeze. No idea how long it would last. A few months? ~Elise
Hi Elise, I loved this salsa although I too found it a bit salty. Next time I will use a little less. Overall, delicious! Thank you.
I made this salsa yasterday and it turned out surprisingly DELICIOUS!
I didn’t think it would turn out this great, few very simple ingredients combines to form this exceptional tomato salsa. Although in the picture it looks red but after I simmered it, it turned out orange color, is that normal?
But who cares? It tastes great.
As you simmer it, it should turn a darker shade of whatever shade it was to begin with. Glad you like it! ~Elise
Hey Elise, I just made a double batch. I forgot the oil and 1/4 cup water, but more importantly I roasted the jalapenos first. I broiled them on hi until the skins were black, removed/discarded them. Otherwise I followed the recipe exactly and it came out excellent. Although I don’t have a regular batch to compare to, I highly recommend you try using roasted jalapenos for a smokey flavor. Thanks for the recipe!
I like roasted tomatoes, onions and jalapenos in this salsa. If the skins are a little blackened, no problem. If they’re blackened all over, I remove them.
Great basic recipe for table salsa, Elise. Between our our garden’s production and the plethora of organic lovelies from the Big Box of Produce (Early Girls and San Marzanos), I had plenty to work with. This is lovely salsa all on its own and a fantastic base to build on. Try adding finely chopped white onions and/or cilantro after cooking. Try it with chipotle instead of jalapeño. Go nuts.
Thanks for another classic, Elise.
I’m trying to be creative with my overabundance of cherry tomatoes and be thankful come dreary winter. I’ve made your fresh salsa and just tried this cooked one.
Does cooking reduce the heat of the pepper? I used serranos from my garden and was surprised that is wasn’t hot at all compared to uncooked versions.
Thanks for another yummy recipe!
I don’t think cooking reduces the heat, though I think it disperses it more. I also make pickled jalapenos which are just as hot as the fresh ones. ~Elise
Love the simplicity of this, as well as all the garlic. I tried mixing it up a little and added mango to some and pineapple to some more. Both turned out well, though the mango one was a little better. Love that spicy/sweet combination. Thanks for the recipe!
This recipe was good, but a little too salty and garlicky for me. Last night I made my standard pico de gallo salsa, and today I added another half jalapeno (I make a pretty mild pico de gallo) and another garlic clove and blended my leftover pico de gallo up and then cooked it with oil according to the recipe. So good!
My son grew 6 habanero pepper plants this summer and I need to use the resulting peppers (I’ve pickled them, made hot sauce, made hot-sweet sauce). Could they be substituted in this?
Habaneros are a lot lot lot hotter than jalapenos and they have a different flavor. I would try it, maybe with half of one, and see if you like it. ~Elise
This is a great recipe. I made my second batch today. The first batch, was too garlicy for my taste. The second batch, I cut back on the oil, added one more tomato, and then only used four cloves of garlic.. YUM.. also.. mine doesn’t turn as bright red as I was hoping.. is that the tomatos?.. I’m using.. “Vine Ripened” from the super market..
Love your site.. Elise.. thanks..
Do the tomatoes get peeled before pureeing? I’ve had some bad experience with tomato skins in sauces (they curl up, get tough and taste bitter).
Also, could you define ‘coring’? Is that removing the part where the vine is attached to the fruit (a cone-shaped section of the fruit about half an inch high?)? Or is it removing the seeds and what-not?
No the tomatoes do not get peeled first, but you could if you wanted to. Basically you purée the heck out of the tomatoes so the skin shouldn’t be a problem. Regarding coring, that has to do with cutting out the part of the tomato where it had been attached to the vine (the cone shape you mentioned). ~Elise
This recipe sounds very similar to the salsa my grandmother taught my mother to make and that I make at least weekly. The biggest differences are that we do not cook the sauce and we don’t add oil. The ingredients my mom taught me to use (and sorry, I do it all by taste and consistency so I don’t have exact measurements) are about 2-3 Roma tomatoes (she never used any other kind of tomato) to 1-2 serrano peppers (my aunt always used chili piquins in her sauce because she grew them in her back yard), about 1/4-1/2 onion, 2-3 cloves of fresh garlic, and salt and pepper to taste. I’ve added lime juice and cilantro to the mix for my taste. I throw it into the blender and puree until slightly chunky. Occasionally, I’ll roast the tomatoes and the serranos or I’ll substitute tomatillos but the basic recipe remains the same. We never used jalapenos because my grandmother said they weren’t hot enough!
Thanks for the recipe. I tried and I liked it :)
This recipe is perfect example of the reason that I love this site. I made this tonight too. Good recipes need to be made right away sometimes. I used about 7 Roma tomatoes, added 1/2 med white onion to the blender, and a pinch of Cajun seasoning instead of salt. It will be gone before it ever has a chance to chill. Thanks!