Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
This cake tasted and I’ll make it again when I really appreciate my guests and want to do something special – because it is a lot of work. However, my curd was very opaque and not semi-transparent and not very orange as the picture showed. It was also very thick and I had to hand mix it before using. Also, my cake shrunk at least 1/2 – 3/4 inches from the side of the pan. Any thoughts on this. Whenever I bake a whipped egg whites cake, it does this (never this bad though). Thanks
Hi, David! I’m glad you enjoyed the recipe. The color of curd can vary because of the color of the egg yolks. Farm fresh eggs tend to have deep, orange yolks whereas grocery store eggs are often a pale yellow. Where you purchase your eggs can impact the color of your curd. Cakes can shrink in on the sides for a variety of reasons. Your oven could run hot and you’re cooking the cakes at too high a temperature for too long. You could’ve over greased the sides of the pan or aggressively over mixed the batter. If this is a common occurrence when baking try adjusting some of these variables and see if that helps.
I really want to make the orange curd, but have a question, please: the first step says “put lemon juice in a small bowl and sprinkle gelatin over it. Let it sit for 10 minutes”. However, after cooking the curd, it says ” remove from heat and stir in the gelatin mixture”. Since recipe only calls for 2 tsp. unflavored gelatin, how much of it do I sprinkle over the lemon juice? How much do I stir into the cooked curd?
Hi Patsy! Sprinkle all 2 teaspoons of the gelatin over the 1/4 cup of lemon juice. Let it sit for 10 minutes. That is now your gelatin mixture you will use in the next step.
Not a cake for the novice cake baker. However I have just pulled mine from the oven so I can say I actually did it! The curd will keep a week in the frig with plastic wrap covering the top. That’s when I started the cake but company arrived and baked another one instead. Today I pulled the curd out and it tasted wonderful. That alone inspired me to give it a try. This is a cake made with LOVE.
I made this cake last night for a Spring Equinox party and it was delicious! I live at 6,500 feet and my high-altitude conversions worked great. I increased the cake flour to 3 cups, decreased the first sugar measurement to 1 cup, and decreased the baking powder to 1/2 teaspoon. It needed 25 minutes baking time — next time I might increase the oven temperature a bit. I also used a whipped cream frosting instead of the cream cheese frosting. I folded some orange curd and zest into the whipped cream (had to let the curd sit out for a bit because it was very firm). It was light and delicious, perfect for spring. Not a single bit was left over! Thanks for a wonderful recipe and a fantastic site, Elise!
I needed a white cake recipe for cupcakes, so I gave this one a go (leaving out the orange peel). They turned out ok. They flavor is good, but the cupcakes don’t have a “pretty dome”… they are rather flat. We’ll cover them with frosting, so it’s not a problem, but I’m a little sad that they collapsed after I took them out of the oven.
I tried this recipe over the weekend because of the delicious picture. It turned out pretty well..but I fear I did something wrong because the orange curd was a little watery and kept leeking out of the cake…consquently only a very thin layer of curd was left inside..haha.
The cake, however, was very good, and the frosting delicious…I just wish that we had more curd inside for that wonderful orange flavor..however, we do have some curd leftover in a bowl still..so I guess we’ll just slop it over a slice whenever we eat some :)
I made this yesterday as I needed a Superbowl dessert and felt like making a cake. This was incredibly delicious, decadent yet light. It was gobbled up quickly! Thanks for the recipe:)
I must thank you (and your father!) for this wonderful cake recipe. I spent the better part of Saturday making all the parts of the cake/curd. The cake was for my mother’s (60th) and father’s (62nd) birthdays! Boy was it a hit…even among the pickier eaters in the family (WHO HAD SECONDS!!). I will treasure this recipe and I have come to the conclusion that I CAN bake. :) Thank You!
I made this and it came out great !! I like to mix recipes or tweak them, so I made a different recipe for the curd which didnt use so many egg yolks, but I did add the lemon and it was really good. The only thing was that the frosting was a little loose (but tasty)…but that could be because I used light cream cheese and a shot of sour cream for “twang”.
Thanks for posting this recipe !
This looks fabulous but I must ask: what exactly is the difference between grating an orange, for example, and obtaining the zest of an orange? I take it the grating is a more coarse version of the peel, while the zest is quite fine. Can I get some clarification? I would really love to try this recipe; looks like a nice little adventure for this novice baker :).
This was an amazing cake. I’ve always been terrified of baking cakes, but the photo alone convinced me to try. Loved it!
***This is an update on the cake for the graduation party.***
It was a big hit! Everyone loved it and was eating the leftovers for breakfast Sunday morning. I made 2 10-inch rounds instead of 3 9-inch rounds and torted them so I actually had a 4 layer cake. The cakes took a few extra minutes to bake but there were no adverse effects.
My cakes did not turn out to be “heavy” or what I would describe to be dense. They were fairly light and fluffy. You have to be exceptionally careful to not overmix the egg whites, otherwise you will get a very heavy cake. It is better to have the batter be slightly lumpy than overmixed.
My mom’s favorite part was the orange cream cheese frosting, as was my husband’s. I personally enjoyed the orange curd and the cake itself. My brother’s fiancee liked everything about it, and asked if it would be too much work for me to make this cake for their wedding! (My answer was YES – since they are having 300 people!!!!)
I am also pleased to report that the cake went well with the (beer) margaritas. It sounds strange, but the best way to make margaritas without a mix is to use a 12 oz can of frozen limeade and mix it with one can of water, one 12 oz beer, and one can of tequila. You can also add some triple sec if you like. Serve it over lots of ice and enjoy along with the cake!
Thanks for a great recipe, Elise!
I am in the process of making this cake for my brother’s fiancee’s graduation party. She, her mom, and her younger sister are three of the pickiest eaters I have ever met. They are the only women I know who won’t even eat salad! We went to lunch once at Red Robin (which serves hamburgers and chicken burgers topped lots of different ways for those of you who aren’t familiar), and all three of them ordered a plain chicken sandwich!
The cake that I was requested to bake just wasn’t doing it for me – yellow cake with chocolate ganache frosting. I bake a lot and I enjoy baking things that make people stop and say, “Wow! I can’t believe this didn’t come from a bakery!” I had to sell my soon-to-be sister-in-law on the idea of a cake with a fruit filling (the response I first got was, “Ick – I hate cakes with filling in them!” and, if this is possible, I *heard* her making a disgusted face through the phone), but I promised that it would be delectable. I have discovered that this girl is not nearly as picky as she thinks – e.g., she claims she doesn’t like lemons, lemonade, anything lemon flavored, etc., yet she ate EVERY lemon cookie I made last Christmas, including the lemon-glazed lemon shortbread jumbles. I have a feeling the orange cake will be a success.
I made the orange curd last night and this morning I had a bowl of creamy, sweet-tart heaven (I had to taste it, of course!). The party is Saturday (Cinco de Mayo!) and I will try to report back as to how the cake turned out and if it was enjoyed by all. I hope the tart orange flavor goes well with margaritas! It may be an overload of citrus, but I personally won’t mind.
All the times, I’ve used granulated or castor sugar in my cake recipes, they have never turned out well. I always end up with granulated sugar in the baked cake. The sugar’s supposed to dissolve, right?
Janelle- I’ll bet a whipped cream frosting would be fantastic. Nice and light, not competing with the orange curd.
I love baking cakes. After several failures with boxed cakes, in my early cooking years, they always fell, I switched to making cakes from scratch. I’ve had success ever since. Weird, huh? This recipe is definitely going on my ‘to do’ list. The orange curd sounds yummy, and very different. To bad I’m not that crazy for cream cheese frosting. What else could I use in its place?